Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The Oxfam scandal is about more than sex
The Oxfam scandal is about more than sex
May 6, 2025 1:00 AM

Oxfam released its internal report on the Haiti scandal Monday, exposing that the controversy enveloping the agency was deeper and more expansive than previously known.

In addition to the details already made public, the report states that allegations of fraud, negligence, sexual harassment, nepotism, and accessing pornography on an puter led to four firings and three resignations.

The figure at the center of the controversy, Haitian country director Roland van Hauwermeiren, was allowed to make a “phased and dignified exit,” according to Oxfam chief executive Mark Goldring in an interview published in Saturday’s Guardian.

The report’s most explosive revelation is that three employees in Haiti threatened a co-worker with physical violence in order to coerce the eyewitness into silence.

Oxfam perpetuated the silence by misleading UK government officials in order to preserve its share of foreign aid funds – which totaled£31.7 million (approximately $43.8 million U.S.) last year alone.

“We were categorically told there was no abuse of beneficiaries involved in the allegations,” said Michelle Russell, the UK Charity Commission’s director of investigations, monitoring, and enforcement. “Nor were we told that there were issues or possible issues around possible crimes, including those involving minors.”

Prime Minister Theresa May called the agency’s behavior “absolutely horrific” on Monday.

Despite the broad, deep, and variegated nature of its wrongdoing, Oxfam’s CEO said over the weekend that he is indignant – at the public’s reaction.

“The intensity and the ferocity of the attack makes you wonder, what did we do? We murdered babies in their cots?” Goldring asked incredulously.

“Certainly,” he continued, “the scale and the intensity of the attacks feels out of proportion to the level of culpability. I struggle to understand it.”

One puzzles at which is the bigger mystery: 1) why taxpayers would not object to being lied to about pulsory funding of the potential sexual abuse of minors, aid workers using food as leverage to exploit vulnerable women, and witness intimidation, or 2) how their doing so is an “attack” upon Oxfam.

The report’s release follows an announcement Friday that the agency will not apply for government funding until UK officials are “satisfied that they can meet the high standards [they] expect of [government] partners” … after government officials strongly implied they would withdraw funding over previous malfeasance.

Oxfam trumpeted the report’s release as an effort to be “as transparent as possible” … a week after it became clear it had been leaked to The Times.

And on Monday, Oxfam announced that it has reported the malefactors’ names – which are redacted in the report – to Haitian authorities for potential prosecution … seven years after the fact.

This level of wrongdoing cannot be fixed by bureaucratic or procedural changes. “It was not just the processes and procedures of that organisation that were lacking but moral leadership,” said UK International Development Secretary Penny Mordaunt.

Those helping the poor must be motivated by the highest ethical standards, including promptly disclosing its workers’ legal infractions to all relevant authorities. Fear of losing government funding fueled a cover-up that enabled additional sexual abuse and exploitation around the globe.

At a minimum, Oxfam’s reaction demonstrates that the harmful effects of ing dependent on government aid apply as much to its distributors as to its recipients.

East Africa. This photo has been cropped. CC BY 2.0.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
World War I and the Break with History
Much of the art before World War I can be seen as moral in nature, says Bruce Edward Walker in this week’s Acton Commentary, while post-Armistice monly celebrates materialism if not outright hedonism: After the Great War, however, the genie was out of the bottle, leading to works meant only to shock, dismay or anger would-be censors and art consumers in general. These works lacked what Irish philosopher and statesman Edmund Burke were essential for a “moral imagination” of which...
A Cultural Case for Capitalism: 9 of 12 — Berry vs. Salatin
[Part 1 is here.] Jonah Goldberg’s Liberal Fascism: The Secret History of the American Left, From Mussolini to the Politics of Meaning, details how the growth of government-corporate cronyism during the past 120 or so years has been largely a phenomenon of the socialist left. Wendell Berry misses this crucial historical insight in his running critique of capitalism, and his missing it draws him into flatly inaccurate claims, as when he asserts that “the United States government’s agricultural policy, or...
Video: Rev. Sirico on Pope Francis and the Mafia
Earlier today, Rev. Robert Sirico spoke with Fox News’ Lauren Green on ‘Spirited Debate’ about Pope Francis’ decision to municate members of the Italian mafia. From Heard on Fox: “Italy has e increasingly more secular and that has impacted the secularity of the mafia – they don’t have the kind of dramatic religious ties that they might have had at one time … the stuff of which movies portray,” said Sirico. He added, “they [the mob] have an appearance of...
Using Drones for Good
Drones, or unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), have been a prominent and controversial topic in the news of late. Today, the Washington-based Stimson Center released its mendations and Report on US Drone Policy. The think tank, which assembled a bipartisan panel of former military and intelligence officials for the 81-page report, concluded that “UAVSs should be neither glorified nor demonized. It is important to take a realistic view of UAVs, recognizing both their continuities with more traditional military technologies and the...
The Disease of Self-Chosen Sacrifice
In our efforts to serve others and do good in the world, we humans have a remarkable tendency to fall short, no matter how carefully constructed or well intended our plans and designs may be. When failure occurs, economists are likely to point to some kind of knowledge problem, notingthat, for instance, Western Congregation X didn’t (and perhaps couldn’t)know or foresee that sending hundreds of free shoes to Developing Nation Y would put several local merchants out of business. To...
Calvin Coolidge’s warning against an entrenched bureaucracy
As we read about the increase of scandal, mismanagement, and corruption within our federal agencies, it is essential once again to revisit the words of Calvin Coolidge. Recent actions at the IRS, Veterans Administration, and the ATF gunwalking scandal all point to systemic problems e from an entrenched bureaucracy. As more and more of the responsibilities of civil society is passed over to centralized powers in Washington, federal agencies have exploded with power and control, leading to greater opportunities for...
The Moral Value of Economic Growth
In 1820, America’s per capita e averaged $1,980, in today’s dollars. But by 2000, it had increased to $43,000. That economic growth has benefited the rich, of course. But it has also transformed the lives of the poor — and prevented many more from ing or staying poor. In this superb short video, the American Enterprise Institute briefly explains the moral value of economic growth. ...
From Steadfast Conservatives to the Faith and Family Left: Highlights from Pew Research’s Political Typology Survey
In discussions of political issues, the American public is too often described in a binary format: Left/Right, Republican/Democrat, Red State/Blue State. But a new survey by the Pew Research Center takes a more granular look at our current political typology by sorting voters into cohesive groups based on their attitudes and values: Partisan polarization – the vast and growing gap between Republicans and Democrats – is a defining feature of politics today. But beyond the ideological wings, which make up...
Finding Meaning in Blue-Collar Work
Over at the Patheos Faith and Work Channel, Larry Saunders shares about his journey from pastor to grocery-store clerk to blue-collar factory worker to current MBA student in search of a white-collar job, offering deep and personal reflections on faith, work, and meaning along the way. When he became a United Methodist pastor, Saunders enjoyed certain aspects of what he calls the “white collar work of ministry,” finding “a strong correlation between my personal sense of vocation and my gifts.”...
A Cultural Case for Capitalism: Part 10 of 12 — The Free Market that Wasn’t
[Part 1 is here.] Some might answer any defense of the free economy by pointing to the housing and financial crisis that came to a head in 2008, holding it up as proof positive the free economy is a wrecking ball swinging munities and leaving all manner of economic and cultural destruction in its wake. The financial crisis did enormous damage, but the major drivers of the crisis were a series of public policies that manipulated the market in pursuit...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved