Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Education as liberation: 4 priorities for reform
Education as liberation: 4 priorities for reform
Sep 9, 2025 4:37 AM

With the recent appointment and confirmation of Betsy DeVos as Secretary of Education, the movement for educational choice has plenty of reasons for optimism.

Throughout the nomination process, opponents of DeVos ridiculed the school-choice movement for caring little about quality, equality, and opportunity, ignoring that these are the precise drivers of advocates for school choice.

Given the abounding confusion and misrepresentation, I was reminded of a wonderful talk given by Professor Howard Fuller at the American Enterprise Institute, in which he clearly outlines four key priorities for education reform in America.

“Education is about liberation,” Fuller argues (channeling Paolo Feire). “It’s about freedom. So if people have freedom, but the freedom is to choose from mediocrity, then it’s the illusion of freedom.”

The four priorities heoutlines are highlighted below (summaries are my own loose paraphrase; excerpts are direct quotes from Fuller):

1. Educational choice: Parents and children of all es need choice.

It’s very important that e and working class people in this country have choice. I think that is a critical thing. I know that you all don’t want to have an America where only those of us with money have the ability to choose the best educational environment for our children…This idea of parent choice is crucial.

2. Quality of schools: We need good choices andschools with a proper understanding of what education is actually about.

If people are going to have choice — and choice is about freedom — then you want to make sure that the choices are quality. You want to make sure that when people choose, they have great schools to choose from. Because I do believe that education is about liberation. It’s about freedom.

…The fight for quality has to be a critical part of ed reform. But at the same time, it’s not just about high test scores. We want to develop kids who can engage in the practice of freedom. Paolo Freire said that it’s not just about preparing young people to engage in what’s currently there and conform to it. It’s giving them the skills that they need so they can engage in the practice of freedom – the transformation of their world.

3. Bottom-up leadership: The “liberators” need e from among the liberated.

I think it has to e clear that if education is about liberation…the people who are being liberated have to be a critical part of their own liberation… What we’ve got to figure it is how do we do not just diversity, but how do we do power? When does the transfer take place?

When are we going to reach the point where we’re very clear that if this is going to work long term, somehow we’ve got to change the narrative and make sure that the people we’re trying to liberate are critical definers of what they need to be liberated.

4. Recognition of the social reality: Race still matters. Class still matters.

People talk about what we’ve got to do to improve schools, but we’ve also got to talk about what’s happening to our kids before they ever get to us. We must talk about the fact that race matters in America and class matters…You know that some of these kids ought to get a medal just for showing up at school, given everything that they’re going through…on a day to day basis. It’s got to be clear to you all that if you’re hungry, it’s hard e to school and learn. If you’ve been abused and neglected, it’s hard e to school every day.

In the work that lies ahead,theschool-choice movement would do well to keep these concerns at the forefront of our thinking, reminding skeptics and opponents of the importance of each along the way.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Joseph E. Stiglitz: An Economist in Freefall
In this week’s Acton Commentary, I review a new book by economist Joseph E. Stiglitz, Freefall: America, Free Markets, and the Sinking of the World Economy. Text follows: A rare growth industry following the 2008 financial crisis has been financial mentaries. An apparently endless stream of books and articles from assorted pundits and scholars continues to explain what went wrong and how to fix our present problems. In this context, it was almost inevitable that one Joseph E. Stiglitz would...
Popes Say No to Socialism
Popes in Rome have attempted to steer the Catholic flock away from the “seductive” forces of socialist ideologies threatening human liberty, which since the late 1800s have relentlessly plucked away at “the delicate fruit of mature civilizations” as Lord Acton once said. From Pius IX to Benedict XVI, socialism has been viewed with great caution and even as major threat to the demise of all God-loving free civilizations, despite many of their past and present socio-political and economic “sins.” In...
Olympians Behaving Badly
Almost nothing is mon in sports than to hear a sportscaster going on about how some athlete is a fine young man or young woman. How they work hard, sacrificed for their sport, are respected by their teammates, and volunteer with children. We enjoy the thrill of petition and rejoice in a game well played or a move perfectly executed, and it is natural that we hope these athletes are as excellent off the field as on. We want heroes...
The RTT Ruse
On February 25th, while Barack Obama chatted about ObamaCare with members of Congress, the Federal Department of Education – lead by its cabinet level chief Arne Duncan who’s also from Chicago – prepped for release to the public his and his boss’s second assault on our freedom; this time a scheme to further intrude on your child’s education. As an announcement from two think tanks put it: “generationally important Tenth Amendment issues [were] opened on two fronts—the prospect of centralizing...
Beyond Sovereignty: Money and its Future
Over at Public Discourse, Acton’s Samuel Gregg has just published a piece about the future of money. The issuance of money, he writes, is often associated with issues of national sovereignty, despite the fact that governments have long abused their monopoly of the money supply. Gregg argues, however, that the role played by mismanaged monetary policy in the 2008 financial crisis may well open up the opportunity to consider some truly radical options for how we supply money to the...
Die Hard — The Welfare State
[news video expired/removed] No, that’s not the new Bruce Willis movie. That’s the spectacle we’re witnessing now of general strikes in Greece in response to proposed austerity measures designed to keep the country from the fiscal abyss — and maybe dragging down other European Union members with it. But Americans shouldn’t be too smug. Despite some very substantial differences in political culture and economic vitality, the United States is showing early signs of the mass hysteria, the widespread delirium tremens...
Review: Environmental Stewardship and wealth creation
In the Orange County Register, Senior Editorial Writer Alan Bock reviews the Acton Institute book, “Environmental Stewardship in the Judeo-Christian Tradition.” (Available in the Acton Bookshoppe for the bargain price of $6). The book might be viewed as an extended rebuttal to a famous 1967 Science magazine article by Lynn White that contended that the biblical injunction for people to have “dominion” over the Earth led to an arrogant view toward the environment that led to widespread environmental despoliation. The...
Acton’s William F. Buckley Tribute Video
Saturday February 27 was the second anniversary of the death of the conservative giant William F. Buckley, Jr. I first saw Buckley in person when Ole Miss hosted Firing Line in 1997. I read National Review in High School even though I admit I did not always understand some of his words at that age. It was a wonderful reminder of the importance of intellectualism and conservatism, and that I still had a lot to learn. The political left too...
Preview: R&L Interviews Nina Shea
Nina Shea In the next issue of Religion & Liberty, we are featuring an interview with Nina Shea. The issue focuses on religious persecution with special attention on the ten year anniversary of the fall munism in Eastern Europe. A feature article for this issue written by Mark Tooley is also ing. Tooley is president of the Institute on Religion and Democracy in Washington D.C. In regards to Shea, the portion of the interview below is exclusively for readers of...
Acton Media Alert – Kishore Jayabalan on Vatican Radio
Vatican Radio in Rome turned to Kishore Jayabalan, Director of Instituto Acton, ment on a recent Italian court ruling which held three Google executives criminally responsible for a YouTube video depicting a teenager with Downs Syndrome being bullied. Vatican Radio’s short article on the matter is here; the audio is available via the audio player below. [audio: ...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved