Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Economist as prophet vs. savior
Economist as prophet vs. savior
Jul 12, 2025 3:25 AM

What do economists actually know? What can they possibly know?

Assuming his usual role as the insider skeptic, economist Russ Roberts ponders those questions at length, concluding that far too much economic analysis is conducted and promoted with far too little humility.

bination of economics with statistics in plex world promises a lot more than it delivers,” Robertswrites. “We economists should be more humble and honest about the reliability and precision of statistical analysis.”

This is especially true in an age when our models and measurements are struggling to keep pace with variables even within the more typical areas of study. Roberts begins his critique with the question of free trade and whether it actually creates more jobs than it destroy (much of this relies on the unseen or unforeseen). James Pethokoukis recently highlighted a study that highlightssimilar questions and gaps as it relates to economic growth.

Tying it all together, Walter Russell Meadconnects the dots accordingly, reminding us that in the Age of Information, and particularly in the industrialized West, those same gaps and blind spots are likely to occur and re-occur here and there and everywhere:

Here’s the big picture we should never allow ourselves to forget: Our world and our economy are going through a phase change more profound, more sweeping and harder to assess than the Industrial Revolution, as disruptive and transformative as anything perhaps since the Neolithic Revolution when wandering bands of hunter gatherers settled down in villages to farm and began to develop written language.

Virtually all of our ways of measuring economic activity are grounded in the realities of the industrial age. So are our ways of thinking about stimulating economies, stabilizing financial systems, regulating panies and organizing such vital functions as central banking. The gap between the ways our societies function on the one hand and the assumptions we use to think about them and the institutions we use to run them has widened dramatically in the last two decades—and the gulf continues to grow.

Modern Western societies consist oftechnocracies thatlack the techniques they need to measure social indicators with precision, meritocracies thatno longer really know what merit is, and democracies whose political institutions and ideas don’t mesh well with the lived experience of their peoples.

But althoughit’s easy to get carriedaway with the ranging debates and micro-debates over metrics and measurements of particular areas of study, we’d do well to more deeply digest thebigger questions, asking what it might imply about thelimits of economics and the role of the economist therein.

Surely it needn’t mean that we simply dismiss the power of empirical analysis and give way to aknee-jerk disregardof expertise altogether. But it does require us to return to Roberts’ original question — “What do economists actually know?” — and align our perspectives accordingly.

Let us remember: The economist was not always hailed as the grand-planning poohbah of the republic. As Peter Boettke explainsin his book, Living Economics: Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow, over the past 150 years, economics has slowly drifted away from Adam Smith’s more passive perch, moving ever closer toward self-confident grand-standing and interventionism.

Whereas economists were once seen as “cautionary prophets,” Boettke writes, they are now elevated as “engineers,” ready and equipped totransform society using “economic science” as their tool. Whereas the economist once assumed the role of a student offering predictive warnings (“If you do x, y might happen”), he has now assumed the role of “practicing engineer.”

Or, as Boettke also describes it, “economist as savior”:

The economist as prophet is more likely to utter “Thou Cannot” than “Thou Shalt Not.” This sort of economics has a default, though not inviolable, respect for the workings and value of institutions that have survived the process of social evolution. This puts him or her in the position of cautioning those who would remake or ignore the lasting results of those historical processes…What unites the engineers…is their rejection of the cautionary prophet’s default respect for historically successful social institutions.

And here’s where the “bigger picture” gets even bigger, because even as the economic engineer wields his severe disruptions on and throughout the economic order, the effects of that intrusion stretch well beyond mere material misallocation and misinterpretation.

For in disregarding the prophet’s “default respect for historically successful social institutions,” the “economist as savior” also partakes in a rebellion against something more profound: the spiritual nature and creative of capacity of individuals and human relationships, deferring insteadto top-down plans that treat dignified man as a predictable piece in an otherwise static game.

Indeed, areturn to the economist as prophet requires not just the routinereminders about missing variables x, y, and z, and the humility it ought to inspire. It also requires a renewed regard for human possibility and the mystery of human exchange, never mind the abundance of a Creator God.

Boettke is speaking specifically of economists as academics and scientists, but the lesson applies to us all: Recognize the limits of the tools in our hands, appreciate the unknown, and more importantly, respect the power and capacity of individuals and institutions just as much, if not more, than the sciences we’ve created to study them.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
How did money-lending stop being a sin?
“Moneylending has been taboo for most of human history,” notes Alex Mayyasi. “So how did usury stop being a sin and e respectable finance?” Today, a banker listening to a theologian seems like a curiosity, a category error. But for most of history, this kind of dialogue was the norm. Hundreds of years ago, when modern finance arose in Europe, moneylenders moderated their behaviour in response to debates among the clergy about how to apply the Bible’s teachings to an...
Work too much? You might have the ‘Proletariat Touch’
Two weeks ago, a group of scholars from around the world gathered in Notre Dame, Indiana for Holy Cross College’s Labor and Leisure Conference. Among the many present was scholar Joseph Zahn, who presented his paper, “The Status of Leisure in the Human Person: Whether Leisure is a Virtue?” With levity in his voice, Zahn began: “Writing a paper on leisure without leisure is a difficult, if not utterly futile, task.” Set to begin his doctoral studies in philosophy at...
New teaching program aims to revive Catholic education
For the past decade, Catholic education has been on the decline. Data from the 2016-2017 National Catholic Education Association Report shows that since 2006, the number of Catholic schools has decreased by 14 percent and the number of students attending Catholic school has decreased by 17.6 percent. Perhaps Teach for Christ can help reverse this trend. The name may ring a bell, as it bears resemblance to the existing program Teach for America. However, Teach for Christ, which will be...
Evaluating Trump’s tax reforms
In April, the Trump administration provided a broad outline of proposed reforms, including simplifying tax brackets, eliminating the marriage penalty, and creating child care deductions. The National Catholic Register recently published an article on the reforms, focusing on its effect on the family. Rev. Robert Sirico, co-founder and president of the Acton Institute, provided his thoughts on Trump’s plan: “A refundable tax credit, instead of a direct subsidy from the government, is more in line with the principle of subsidiarity,”...
Did the Reformation lead to ‘economic secularization’?
In his famous work, The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, Max Weber attempted to draw a clear link between the Protestant Reformation and the rise of capitalism, focusing mostly on the Puritans and their (faulty) connections between spiritual significance and economic prosperity. But while Weber may have offered some significant observations on the developments of his day, his overall theory has long been dismissed and discredited on a number of grounds, whether historical, theological, or economic. “Weber missed...
Maximizing profit under competition
Note: This is post #42 in a weekly video series on basic microeconomics. In petitive market, pany can’t control how much they charge for goods and services. So how do firms maximize profits when they don’t control prices? In this video by Marginal Revolution University, Alex Tabarrok defines profit, including how to calculate total revenue and total cost, and covers costs, variable costs, marginal revenue, and marginal cost. (If you find the pace of the videos too slow, I’d mend...
Explainer: What you should know about civil asset forfeiture
Earlier this week, Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced the Justice Department would be reinstating the Equitable Sharing Program, a controversial policy related to civil asset forfeiture. Several states have been making it more difficult to apply such forfeitures so this allows state and local law enforcement to explicitly circumvent state forfeiture restrictions. Here’s what you should know aboutcivil asset forfeiture. What is civil asset forfeiture? Civil asset forfeiture (hereafter CAF) is a controversial legal tool that allows law enforcement officials...
Review: A visually powerful tribute to The Dunkirk Spirit
In a new blockbuster film, director Christopher Nolan faithfully captures for the big screen the frantic chaos and desperation of the Allied forces at Dunkirk in 1940. It is another vivid reminder that, as so many throughout history have reminded us, “War is hell.” Those who know their history understand that on the French beaches of the Strait of Dover, the Allied forces are thrown once again into another world conflict, this time to protect Western freedom and its democratic...
The kind of ‘tolerance’ the West needs
In the modern lexicon, “tolerance” stands alongside “equality” as an unquestioned and absolute good, a cornerstone of transatlantic values. True tolerance has brought the West unparalleled prosperity. But what kind of “tolerance” should we advance, and what other cultural concepts must support it? In a new essay for Religion & Liberty Transatlantic,Josh Herring examines “The foundation of true tolerance.” He begins with the triumph of tolerance in public discourse: In The Ethics of Rhetoric, University of Chicago rhetorician Richard Weaver...
The most effective way to reduce child poverty
A vital fact lies buried in the recent IFS study on e inequality: the most effective way to alleviate poverty. This was true even though the IFS study, and UK government statistics, don’t actually measure poverty but rather inequality. Maybe it’s best to say the IFS study contains the secret to reducing both phenomena. Whichever metric one uses, according to the IFS report the most effective way to reduce that number is through work. The UK government defines “poverty” as...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved