Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Lord Acton vs. the ‘New Socialists’ on Freedom
Lord Acton vs. the ‘New Socialists’ on Freedom
Jul 1, 2025 4:15 AM

‘Lord Acton’ Public Domain

Corey Robin, professor of political science at Brooklyn College and the City University of New York Graduate Center, wrote an interesting and troubling piece last week in the New York Times titled, “The New Socialists: Why the pitch from Ocasio-Cortez and Bernie Sanders resonates in 2018.” It is part chronicle of the recent rise of self-identified socialist politicians in the United States and part meditation on what people in 2018 mean when they talk about socialism.

Robin believes that the socialism of today is fundamentally different from its 19th and 20th century predecessors. During this period many socialists believed that scientific state management of production and distribution would lead to greater prosperity by getting rid of inefficient market mechanisms petition (For the most devastating critique of this see Ludwig von Mises’ Socialism: An Economic and Sociological Analysis). Speaking of contemporary arguments Robin says, “The Socialist argument against capitalism isn’t that it makes us poor. It’s that it makes us unfree.”

This argument is unsurprising and I had it in mind as I wrote the introduction to Lord Acton: Historical and Moral Essays arguing that,

The nature of liberty—that motive of good deeds mon pretext of crime—is contested: “No obstacle has been so constant, or so difficult to e, as uncertainty and confusion touching the nature of liberty.” It is contested to this day by liberals, conservatives, libertarians, and socialists, who all claim to be the champions of authentic freedom. From everywhere and everyone we hear calls for freedom on all sides of contentious issues.

The argument that one is not free as long as one is subject to the demands of others be they bosses, churches, and even the family itself is an idea rooted in even early pre-Marxian socialism. Lord Acton’s most concise definition of liberty strikes a similar cord when he states, “By liberty I mean the assurance that every man shall be protected in doing what he believes his duty, against the influence of authority and majorities, customs and opinion.” There is, however, a subtle and significant difference which is made clear by Robin’s citation of Irving Howe and Lewis Coser’s attempt to define socialism, “Socialism is the name of our desire.” This socialist definition of freedom, shared by even many free market advocates, is freedom from constraints to perform our desire while Acton’s is freedom from constraints to perform our duty, to do what we ought.

In his essay, “The Roman Question”, Acton fleshed out this distinction,

“There is a wide divergence, an irreconcilable disagreement, between the political notions of the modern world and that which is essentially the system of the Catholic Church. It manifests itself particularly in their contradictory views of liberty, and of the functions of the civil power. The Catholic notion, defining liberty not as the power of doing what we like, but the right of being able to do what we ought, denies that general interests can supersede individual rights. It condemns, therefore, the theory of the ancient as well as of the modern state.”

Part of the exercise of our freedom to do our duty is to act for ourselves and not to act for others. Navigating conflicts of interest, demanding our rights of conscience, and recognizing the demands of the consciences of others is the tricky business which the liberal political order, markets, the church, the family, and other institutions of civil society strive to do. And while this work is always needed and often done imperfectly it has led to greater peace and prosperity than any system of state socialism this world has ever seen.

While I am encouraged that the New Socialists have abandoned long discredited arguments that socialism is the path to greater wealth in society the notion that freedom is synonymous with socialism and can be won by, as Rubin argues, “Mass action — sometimes illegal, always confrontational…” and that, “…it is workers who get us there, who decide what and where “there” is.”, is disconcerting to say the least. If the New Socialists really want freedom Acton points to a more peaceful, realistic, and morally rooted vision of, “The society that is beyond the state – the individual souls that are above it.”

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Spartan Austerity and the Fiscal Cliff
Is spartan austerity driving us over the fiscal cliff?The latest step in the budget dance between House Republicans and the White House has to do with where tax increases (or revenue increases in general, depending on what is called what) fit with a deal to avoid the so-called “fiscal cliff.” As Napp Nazworth reports, President Obama has apparently delivered an ultimatum: “there would be no agreement to avert the ‘fiscal cliff’ unless tax rates are increased on those making more...
Textbook Bubble-Boys
According to AEI author Mark Perry, there is another education-related “bubble” to worry about: the textbook bubble. He writes that this textbook bubble “continues to inflate at rates that make the U.S. housing bubble seem relatively inconsequential parison.” He continues, “The cost of college textbooks has been rising at almost twice the rate of general CPI inflation for at least the last thirty years.” Given that many students use loan money to purchase books as well as pay for classes,...
Africans Join Together to Aid Frozen Norwegians
Africans unite to save Norwegians from dying of frostbite. By joining Radi-Aid, you too can donate your radiator and spread some warmth in the frozen wasteland of Norway. Why Africa for Norway? Imagine if every person in Africa saw the “Africa for Norway” video and this was the only information they ever got about Norway. What would they think about Norway? If we say Africa, what do you think about? Hunger, poverty, crime or AIDS? No wonder, because in fundraising...
Rachel Carson’s Environmental Religion
Review of Silent Spring at 50: The False Crises of Rachel Carson. Edited by Roger Meiners, Pierre Desrochers, and Andrew Morriss (Cato, 2012) During the 50 years following the publication of Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring, much has been written to discredit the science of her landmark book. Little, however, has been written on the environmentalist cult it helped spawn. Until Silent Spring at 50, that is. Subtitled “The False Crises of Rachel Carson,” Silent Spring at 50 is a collection...
How Powerball Preys on the Poor
When es to government programs for redistributing e, nothing is quite as malevolently effective as state lotteries. Every year state lotteries redistribute the e of mostly poor Americans (who spend between 4-9% of their e on lottery tickets) to a handful of other citizens—and tothe state’s coffers. A prime example is yesterday’s Powerball jackpot. Two people becameinstant multimillionairesfrom a voluntary transfer of wealth from their fellow citizens. The money came from the563 million tickets that were sold, as the old...
Calvin Coolidge, Excessive Taxation, and the Moral Economy
Below is an excerpt from a 1925 Washington Post editorial on President Calvin Coolidge’s Inaugural Address. ments speak directly to the moral arguments Coolidge was making for a free economy. It is the kind of moral thinking about markets and taxes we desperately need today from our national leaders. The es from an excellent book, The High Tide of American Conservatism: Davis, Coolidge, and the 1924 Election by Garland S. Tucker, III. Few persons, probably, have considered economy and taxation...
Raising Taxes without a Balanced Budget is Insane
It makes little, or really no sense for Americans to fork over more taxes without a balanced federal budget and seeing some fiscal responsibility out of Washington. The fact that the United States Senate hasn’t passed a budget in well over three years doesn’t mean we aren’t spending money, we are spending more than ever. The last time the Senate passed a budget resolution was April of 2009. We are constantly bombarded with rhetoric that “taxing the rich” at an...
Audio: Rev. Sirico on the ‘moral dimension of economic activity’
On Vatican Radio, Acton President and co-founder Rev. Robert A. Sirico discusses his new book Defending the Free Market: The Moral Case for the Free Market Economy with reporter Ann Schneible. According to Vatican Radio, the broadcasting station of the Holy See: … Fr Sirico highlighted his objectives in writing this book. Defending the Free Market, he said, was written “with the intention of making accessible economic ideas that I thought were important in general terms; but, in particular, especially...
Interview: Rev. Sirico on ‘A Moral Case for a Free Economy’
Ann Schneible, who interviewed Rev. Robert A. Sirico for Vatican Radio today (see PowerBlog post for audio) also published an interview with the Acton Institute president and co-founder on the Catholic news site, Zenit. Excerpt: ZENIT: In response to those Christians and Catholics who are hesitant about buying into the idea of a free market economy, how can one demonstrate that there are elements to a free market – or Capitalist – economy which patible to Catholic social teaching? Father...
Commentary: Living in the Shadow of the Fiscal Cliff
Jordan Ballor looks at the bipartisan lack of discipline in Washington on debt and spending, and the effect on future generations. “Christians, whose citizenship is ultimately not of this world and whose identity and perspective must likewise be eternal and transcendent, should not let our viewpoints be determined by the tyranny of the short-term,” he writes. “If we continue the current course of American politics, the fiscal cliff will end up being nothing more than a bump in the road...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved