Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
The Wizard of Oz as an Allegory for the 1896 Presidential Election
The Wizard of Oz as an Allegory for the 1896 Presidential Election
Nov 21, 2026 11:22 AM

  Mention “bimetallism” today—the coining of both gold and silver as legal tender—and the eyes glaze over immediately. However, in late 19th century U.S. politics, along with the tariff, bimetallism was the major political obsession of the era. Everyone talked about the subject. It featured as the foremost political issue in the presidential election of 1896. William Jennings Bryan won the Democratic nomination due to his “Cross of Gold” speech at the convention advocating bimetallism. So obsessed was the era with this policy debate that a line of scholarship in the latter half of the 20th century argues the well-known children’s book, The Wizard of Oz (originally titled The Wonderful Wizard of Oz), is an allegory of the era’s political conflict over bimetallism.

  The Coinage Act of 1873 ended the U.S. mint’s legally-authorized practice of converting silver bullion into legal tender at no cost. The “free silver” slogan referred to the price the mint would charge to convert bullion into coins: free coinage. Prior to this, except for the Civil War, the U.S. had a bimetallic monetary standard, coining both silver and gold at a fixed exchange rate.

  Congress statutorily fixed the exchange rate between silver and gold in 1834 at sixteen ounces of silver to one ounce of gold. After the Civil War, however, the ratio of silver prices to gold prices consistently exceeded that standard, with the ratio reaching 32.8 in 1894. William Jennings Bryan’s “free silver” position would have legally reestablished mint prices far below the ratio of market prices, at the old sixteen to one ratio. “Free silver” effectively was an inflationary policy. Free silver meant that loans taken out in dearer gold dollars could be paid back in cheaper silver dollars.

  Note, however, that bimetallism is not inherently inflationary. Bryan’s platform would have caused inflation only because it proposed to set the exchange rate between silver and gold at the earlier legal level, a level that diverged significantly from the existing market price ratio. There would be no inflationary effect if the exchange rate were set at extant prices and allowed to float. Indeed, Milton Friedman argued the evidence showed greater monetary stability under bimetallism than under the monometallic gold standard. That makes sense given that combined variance in the supply and demand for both silver and gold would generally be less than the variance of one metal alone. So prices denominated in a bimetallic standard would vary less than with a monometallic standard of either gold or silver.

  Several scholars have posited The Wizard of Oz as an allegory for the politics of bimetallism during this period. Perhaps the best-known and best-argued is economist Hugh Rockoff’s 1990 article, “The ‘Wizard of Oz’ as a Monetary Allegory,” in the prestigious Journal of Political Economy. The evidence, however, is entirely circumstantial. Rockoff and others argue the circumstantial case is compelling. Other scholars beg to differ.

  Important to note first is that the allegorical reading riffs off L. Frank Baum’s book, not the 1939 film. The most pertinent difference between the book and the film is, in the book, the slippers/shoes Dorothy gets from the Wicked Witch of the East are silver, not ruby. So Dorothy journies clad in silver shoes on the yellow brick (gold) road, to the Land of Oz (“ounce,” of gold or silver). Both silver and gold take her there. Bimetallism.

  Dorothy is whipped out of Kansas by a tornado with her little dog “Toto” (short for teetotalers, who made a loud noise yip-yapping but were otherwise ineffective political companions). On her way to the Land of Oz, Dorothy picks up her electoral coalition. First, the Scarecrow, representing western farmers. According to Rockoff,

  He thinks that he has no brains because his head is stuffed with straw. But we soon learn that he is shrewd and capable. He brings to life a major theme of the free silver movement: that the people, the farmer in particular, were capable of understanding the complex theories that underlay the choice of a standard.

  Next, the Tin Man (or Tin Woodman). The working class man, once a true human, is now just a cog in the industrial machine. Piece by piece his human body was replaced by metallic parts. He is now little more than a machine, a heartless (literally) machine. The Populist hope of the era was a grand farmer-labor coalition that never quite solidified—and we still see residual evidence of this hope in the official name of Minnesota’s Democratic Party, the Democratic-Farmer-Labor Party.

  The Cowardly Lion, then, was William Jennings Bryan himself. Capable of a great roar—his speeches were legendary—alas, to mix metaphors, he was all bark and no bite.

  Once they gain admission, the Great Oz instructs the small group, “In this country everyone must pay for everything he gets.” Rockoff writes “this Wizard who speaks through various figure heads and adheres to . . . a purely Republican world view” could be none other than Marcus Alonzo Hanna, a “close adviser of McKinley and the chairman of the Republican National Committee.”

  Rockoff continues to unfold the allegory with considerable detail, but the above provides a flavor of his argument.

  Rockoff concedes that “Baum left no hard evidence that he intended his story to have an allegorical meaning.” He judges the circumstantial evidence to be “considerable. Economist Bradley A. Hansen, writing in the Journal of Economic Education twelve years later begs to differ, pointing out how important parts of the story don’t fit the politics of the time, and arguing at length that Baum would not have sympathized with populist politics in any event. I tend to agree with Hansen on this point, at least: The circumstantial evidence is not as compelling as Rockoff suggests it is. Nonetheless, whatever Baum intended, Rockoff’s allegorical reading of The Wizard of Oz is a great way to teach an important, but overlooked, controversy in American political history.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
Civilization
  Aristotle is known for the theory that there are four causes structuring reality. Best-selling author and American classicist Victor Davis Hanson follows Aristotle’s lead, identifying four causes that transform wars into civilization-ending defeats. Whilst most conflicts between great powers end in compromise, The End of Everything: How Wars Descend into Annihilation gives four reasons why wars sometimes liquidate entire civilizations....
Good Deeds Unpunished
  On March 8, 2022, police officers in Bullhead City, Arizona, arrested Norma Thornton for serving home-cooked meals in a park near her home. The city charged her with violating an ordinance that essentially prohibits anyone from sharing food on public property for charitable purposes. Under that ordinance, individuals may share food on public property for any purpose whatsoever, so long...
Rest in God
  Rest in God   Weekly Overview:   The Christian life is meant to be marked by simplicity. Jesus summed up our purpose with two statements: love God and love people. But in our humanity we have made complex what God designed to be peaceful, purposeful, and simple. A. W. Tozer remarks in The Pursuit of God, “Every age has its own characteristics....
The Joy of Escapist Catastrophism
  Apocalyptic and dystopian myths today are different from the ones we used to have. The dystopian stories of yesteryear were tragedies—dark cautionary tales with unhappy endings. In The Planet of the Apes, Charlton Heston’s character discovers that the dystopian world ruled by apes he’s been trying to escape was actually Earth all along. Brave New World, 1984, and Animal Farm...
Why People Don’t Believe in Jesus
  Weekend, July 20, 2024   Why People Don’t Believe in Jesus   Jesus told him, “I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one can come to the Father except through me.” (John 14:6 NLT)   It has never been popular to say that Jesus Christ is the only way to God. And perhaps that statement has never been more controversial...
In Pennsylvania, Locals Remember Corey Comperatore’s ‘Greater Love’
  Corey Comperatore loved reading Romans.   His pastor at Cabot Methodist Church, Jonathan Fehl, recalled how much Comperatore drew strength from the book. It was the first thing hed recommend to new believers.   But it may be that Comperatore is remembered by another portion of Scripture, John 15:13: Greater love has no one than this: to lay down ones life for...
5 Verses to Gather from Psalm 25 When Life Gets Heavy
  BIBLE VERSE OF THE DAY:In you, LORD my God, I put my trust. - Psalm 25:1   5 Verses to Gather from Psalm 25 When Life Gets Heavy   By Kristi Woods   God and His word are faithful – even in times of heaviness, even when we might question whether He or His word could do a single thing to help us....
Historic First Baptist Dallas Sanctuary Burns in Four
  The historic sanctuary at First Baptist Church Dallas burned Friday evening, July 19. The cause of the blaze is not yet known. The Victorian-style, red brick sanctuary building was erected 1890 and is a recognized Texas Historic Landmark.   According to media reports, Dallas Fire and Rescue received a call at 6:05 p.m., Friday evening regarding a building on fire in...
Mugged By Reality
  “Hence like most people who have substituted the habit of delusion for reality, they became hysterical whenever the root of their delusion was touched, and reacted with a violence that completely belied the openness of mind which they prescribed for others.”   — Whittaker Chambers, Witness, 1952   Nellie Bowles could easily have used Chambers’ observation as the epigraph for Morning After...
Religious Liberty in the States
  When Americans think about religious liberty, our minds naturally turn to the protections offered by the First Amendment: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” This amendment, and related federal legislation, offer important protections, but there are numerous areas in which states are free to protect, or not protect, religious liberty....
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved