Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The Surrogacy Industry And Human Trafficking
The Surrogacy Industry And Human Trafficking
May 25, 2025 5:33 PM

Supporters of surrogacy tend to believe it is a win-win situation. Someone who desperately wants a child is given the opportunity to be a parent by someone who can have a baby, and is willing to do so either for money or out of benevolence (such as a sister acting as a surrogate for a sibling.) The truth is that the majority of surrogacy cases are ones where money changes hands. And when money changes hands, and the very lives of humans are at stake, things going badly awry.

In India, there is virtually no control over the surrogacy industry, and an industry it is. Gianna Toboni, a reporter for the HBO series Vice, traveled to India to investigate this industry. What she found was a lot of money, Indian women being taken advantage of and human trafficking.

Toboni and her team quickly expose the dark underside of an unregulated and dangerous industry. Women are routinely recruited from slums, made to sign contracts they can’t read, before spending a year living in a facility. Once the baby is born — via cesarean section so that doctors can maximize births per day — the surrogate is sent home, often without the pensation she was promised.

Toboni describes surrogacy in India as “anything goes:”

The Indian government just hasn’t passed regulations that would allow this to be a safe industry. More regulations and increased effort by couples would help. It’s the responsibility of the couple to really research and see what kind of pressure their surrogate is under. I asked one woman when she was on the delivery table about to give birth if she was ever afraid she could die during childbirth. She said, “Yeah, I know that’s a real possibility.” The surrogates understand what the situation is medically for them, but it doesn’t seem like missioning couples do. The medical facility is good and clean, but at the same time, these women are risking their lives.

Right now, the surrogacy industry is anything goes, which is really scary. There was legislation proposed in India in 2010, it just hasn’t been passed. We didn’t see anyone receive poor medical service at the clinics we were able to visit. At the same time, there’s no limit to how many embryos can be implanted. Doctors have been known to insert more than one or two embryos to increase the chances that the woman will get pregnant without losing time or money.

What Toboni uncovered next can only be described as human trafficking. She went to meet a couple to discuss surrogacy, and she was offered something more:

Does surrogacy meet the definition of human trafficking? Decide for yourself.

Traffickers use force, fraud, or coercion to lure their victims and force them into labor mercial sexual exploitation. They look for people who are vulnerable for a variety of reasons, including economic hardship, natural disasters, or political instability. The trauma can be so great that many may not identify themselves as victims or ask for help, even in highly public settings.

Traffickers often operate by:

Using violence or threatening the person or the person’s family members;

Harming or depriving the person of basic necessities, such as food, water, or sleep;

Making false promises of love panionship;

Making false promises of a good job and home;

Restricting contact with friends or family;

Limiting freedom of movement;

Controlling the person’s identification documents;

Threatening deportation or law enforcement action;

Garnishing the person’s salary to pay off alleged debts; and/or

Preventing the victim from attending religious services.

Surrogacy preys on the vulnerable, puts women’s and babies health at risk, modifies human life.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Guatemala’s Liberty Movement and the Gospel as Social Cure
Guatemala is not known for freedom and stability, with a history colored by authoritarianism, political corruption, civil war, segregation, colonialism, post-colonial interventionism, and so on. Dire poverty and street violence remain endemic, and yethope remains: for political and economic liberty,yes, butalsofor freedom of spirit. In a beautiful long-form essay for the new PovertyCure Magazine, J. Caleb Stewart explores the promise of Guatemala, highlighting the story of Antonio Cali, “a one-time socialist who began his drift from the left when he...
Audio: Samuel Gregg explains need for Brexit
Samuel Gregg appeared on the recent episode of the podcast The Catholic Cave, “Britain, the EU and You,” to discuss Britain’s recent referendum vote to leave the EU. The show considers factors that potentially led to the Brexit other than trade and immigration issues, including dissatisfaction with international bureaucracy, cultural and philosophical differences between Britain and other European countries, and problems of subsidiarity. Gregg sees Brexit as a “reassertion of national sovereignty,” “reaffirmation of the importance of the nation state,”...
Deirdre McCloskey on Spiritual Change in the Great Enrichment
In Dierdre McCloskey’s latest book, Bourgeois Equality: How Ideas, Not Capital or Institutions, Enriched the World, she builds on her ongoing thesis that our newfound prosperity is not due tosystems, tools, or materials, but the ideas, virtues, and rhetoric behind them. Much has been made of herargument as it relates to the (ir)relevance of thosematerial features as causes: “coal or thrift or capital or exports or exploitation or imperialism or good property rights or even good science.” Butless has been...
Without Natural Law, We Have No Rights
Our rights as Americans are considered unalienable, says Heritage Foundation president JimDeMint, only because they were inherent in the natural order of life established by the laws of nature and nature’s God. While musing on thewritingsof author and philosopher G.K. Chesterton in his personal notebook, a young John F. Kennedy wrote, “Don’t ever take a fence down until you know the reason why it was put up.” Fences hold things in we want to keep close, and protect us from...
Socialism Makes People Selfish
Does socialism make people kinder and more caring, while capitalismmakes people greedy and more selfish? No, in fact, justthe opposite is true. In this video, Dennis Prager explains the moral differences between socialism and capitalism, and why anyone who wants a kind and generous society must support one and oppose the other. ...
Christians should support markets and churches, NOT social democracy
David Schelhaas, Professor Emeritus of English at Dordt College, recently published an article titled “What Does Social Democrat Mean?” Schelhaas suggests that “Christians should seriously consider the merits of social democracy.” Schelhaas is quick to point out that he does not advocate socialism, with state control and management of the means of production, coupled with the redistribution of wealth. Instead, he advocates for the lighter “social democracy.” Schelhaas goes on to outline his vision of social democracy, including the state’s...
The ‘Shale Revolution’ is Re-energizing U.S. Manufacturing
U.S. manufacturing is making eback, says Mark Perry economist at AEI. Because of innovative fracking technologies that have made shale gas abundant and cheap, manufacturing jobs are quickly returning to the United States, as the cost advantage of producing overseas disappears. Perry estimates that the revival of manufacturing production in the United States has the potential to create 3 million jobs in the next decade: The impact of the shale revolution is profound because the economic growth it continues to...
5 Facts About the Political Party Conventions
From Monday July 18 through Thursday July 21, the Republican Party will be holding their national convention in Cleveland, Ohio. Then, from July 25 to 28, the Democratic Party will hold their convention in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Here are five things you should know about these events: 1. The political party conventions are held every four years as the culminating event of the presidential primary season. For America’s two main political parties, the Democratic Party and the Republican Party, the convention...
6 thought-provoking quotes from AEI’s ‘Economic Freedom and Human Flourishing’
In considering issues of political economy today, it is always prudent to refer to wisdom from the past. The American Enterprise Institute’s recent publication “Economic Freedom and Human Flourishing: Perspectives from Political Philosophy” is a collection of essays that analyzes the thought of several prominent philosophers on the connection between the title’s two subjects. Many of the quotes below, pulled from six of the nine essays, challenge foundational aspects of classical liberalism and the value of the free market. As...
Low Employment of Adults Affects Children Too
Not having a job — whether by choice or by circumstance – can adversely affect spiritual and psychological well-being of adults. But living in a home where the parents don’t work can also have a detrimental impacton children. In a new report, “America’s Work Problem”, Angela Rachidi examines the data related to children in poverty. She finds that while most children in America live with a working adult, those who are in a home without someone working full-time, year-round employment...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved