Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
The Only Hope for Civic Renewal
The Only Hope for Civic Renewal
May 12, 2026 9:23 PM

In the last few years, there has been a revival in interest in the role that private charity can play in the revitalization of civil society. This renewed interest is partly driven by an overwhelming sense that most of us have, regardless of political and ideological interests, that the modern welfare state has produced less-than-impressive results. I would take this analysis much further: The welfare state has been plete disaster, in some instances creating, and in others enhancing, a myriad of problems—family disintegration, the loss of respect for the elderly, the moral nihilism of the youth, the loss of a clear sense of right and wrong, and the collapse munity at all levels in society.

But if we are really entering the post-statist age in which the welfare state is going to continue to disintegrate bit by bit, where do we go from here? A good start would be to build on the substantial pocket of civic virtue that remains despite the tendency of government to destroy and replace it, to build on and extend the sense of responsibility that individuals and families still have to create a viable civic culture.

This is obviously easier said than done. Some concrete steps that could take us very far in the right direction, though, relate directly to the mission of churches in the practice of authentic social work. I am not suggesting that our churches can or should be the only source of charity, and I am especially not arguing that their social mission is limited by their social utility. But from time immemorial, it has been the case that the most difficult work of caring for the least among us has been initiated by them and from the resources that church leaders and members accumulated voluntarily. They must not be overlooked. But there is a preliminary step that must be taken before churches can again pletely viable institutions in this regard. They must regain a sense of their salvific mission, and apart from this theological and soteriological task, I have strong doubts as to whether they can pick up where the state leaves off and e vital instruments of social and cultural healing. The churches must truly believe that the doctrines they preach really are good for others, both in a temporal and an eternal sense. They cannot profess a belief in the truth of faith and then not want to mend it to others.

The ability of the church to take care of the poor is directly connected to its understanding and confidence in its own mission. Believers must be confident that they are doing more than merely providing for material needs; they must believe that their mission is broader and more important. They must believe they are also meeting spiritual needs, that they are saving souls, that they are preparing people not only to face this world but also the next. This requires, in the first instance, a revitalization of doctrine and faith. If the church does not believe in its primary mission—human redemption—it will not be able sustain enthusiasm and interest in its proximate mission—works of charity. And that means our churches must again seek to convert souls.

All of which goes to say, show me a group of God-fearing people of faith who reject the secular world, who reject the values of the mass media while embracing those beliefs about this world that are shaped by Holy Scripture and other ancient texts, and I will show you people who are capable of providing the greatest service to the poor.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
Straddling the border of ‘democratic’ socialism
The thin ice separating purportedly “democratic socialism” from authoritarianism is melting in Serbia. It is impossible to understand the modern political landscape of the Balkans without understanding the region’s enormous plexity. It literally has been the crossroads of East and West – the place where Western Christianity, Eastern Christianity, and Islam have collided over the course of 1,000 years, creating often-hidden fault lines that produce dramatic consequences in the present day. The Yugoslav Wars, which were so brutal they...
Challenging monopolies: the National Health Service
In March, I joined millions of others in standing outside my house and applauding the doctors and nurses serving the nation during the global COVID-19 pandemic. While many of us directed our heartfelt gratitude mendation toward the medical staff and essential workers who kept us safe from the coronavirus, the government set about praising itself. London landmarks lit up in the colours of the nation’s single-payer healthcare system, the National Health Service. It was reminiscent of the opening ceremony...
Democratic socialism: Back to the feudal future?
The Coming of Neo-Feudalism: A Warning to the Global Middle Class Joel Kotkin | Encounter Books | 2020 | 224 pages Reviewed by John Couretas California has long been regarded as a cultural bellwether, a place where America’s future gets its trial run. Look to California, the thinking goes, and you will see where the country is headed just a few years hence. After all, how can you argue with the genius of a place, a people, who gave...
Black Lives Matter: the proposition, the organization, and the movement
We must assess three issues surrounding the Black Lives Movement (BLM) if we are to understand and respond to it. These are the proposition, the organization, and the movement itself. One must strain to find anything objectionable with the proposition that “black lives matter.” It ought to be obvious that the lives of blacks matter, because blacks are human beings made in the image and likeness of God. They matter because they are human, just as the members of...
Humankind: a hopeless history
Humankind: A Hopeful History Rutger Bregman | Little, Brown and Co. | 2020 | 480 pages Reviewed by Josh Herring The West has described the human race as living in various stages of depravity since the Book of Genesis. This is erroneous, writes Rutger Bregman, who contends in Humankind: A Hopeful History that “most people, deep down, are pretty decent.” He frames this as a “radical idea,” and over the course of 18 chapters, he attempts to show both...
What turns protests into riots?
On Saturday, May 30, the riots that swept the nation after the death of George Floyd came to Grand Rapids, Michigan – the home of the Acton Institute. Vandals looted and damaged 100 businesses and destroyed seven police cars. Businesses alreadystruggling as a result of lockdownsare nowgrappling with damage and theftinflicted by looters. The National Guard was mobilized, and the city issued a 7 p.m. curfew which expired on June 2. Things became relatively quiet once these measures took...
The ‘public option’ will destroy choice
Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden has made it abundantly clear that he opposes the “Medicare for All” model of health reform favored by Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., and the progressive wing of the Democratic Party. Instead, Biden proposes creating a public insurance option that pete against private insurers on the Obamacare exchanges. On its face, this plan might seem sensible. Unlike Medicare for All, a public option would not abolish private insurance. It would just give people one more...
The deceit of ‘democratic socialism’
There is often as much concealed as revealed in our language. Context and framing are key. The serpent, the subtlest of wild creatures, knew this well when he tempted Eve by asking, “Did God say, ‘You shall not eat of any tree of the garden’?” (Genesis 3:1). Careful readers note that he was misquoting God. But the trap was baited. So too with socialism’s modern apologists, who recently added the modifier “democratic” – as though to disassociate the contemporary...
My life under democratic socialism
Democratic socialism has had a global resurgence. As many as 70% of millennials say they are “likely” to vote for a socialist candidate. The problem is that the youth of today – and for that matter Bernie Sanders – do not know what democratic socialism looks like. I do know. I lived it. And it was not pleasant. Back in 1979, the state owned the energy, steel,coal mining, shipbuilding, automobile, and virtually everyotherimportant industry you can imagine. My first...
The ‘public option’ will destroy choice
Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden has made it abundantly clear that he opposes the Medicare for All model of health reform favored by Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., and the progressive wing of the Democratic Party. Instead, Biden proposes creating a public insurance option that pete against private insurers on Obamacare's exchanges. On its face, this plan might seem sensible. Unlike Medicare for All, a public option would not abolish private insurance. It would just give people one more choice...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved