Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
The Market and the Manger
The Market and the Manger
Jul 15, 2026 10:34 PM

This November/December issue of Religion & Liberty coincides with the celebration of the feast of the Incarnation – Christmas. This holiday season, like every other, we will hear calls to take mercialism out of Christmas. What are the connections between the market and the manger?

This past year we have witnessed discussions on issues of welfare reform, private charity, and the virtues of free-markets. At the heart of these topics is an incarnational theology – a manner of approach which understands implicitly that Christ became a man and thus redeemed the created order.

The meeting of God and humanity in the incarnation is the beautiful event which marks the beginning of our Lord’s earthly life of redemption. Through this redemption, begun on Christmas morning, e to realize the inherent worth of each human person, regardless of race, creed, gender, or social status.

The denunciations merce at Christmas are usually issued by the same people who castigate capitalism year ‘round. In doing so they offer a gnosticism; the view that the material world is fundamentally suspect, even evil, and that the possession of material goods, beyond the “essentials”, is in itself sinful.

The birth of Christ is the beginning of an eternal embrace which sanctifies all of the created order. The material world is therefore not evil or rank, but is rather the handi-work of God and given over to the stewardship of His creatures made in His likeness and image. A truly free and virtuous society is motivated by the fact that Christ redeemed not only the human race in the abstract, but also all individuals and human projects, including the market.

The incarnation has implications for business. Jesus understood personally what it was to be in need, to be concerned about where the next meal ing from, and how to cooperate with others to meet his own needs, as well as the needs of others. Entrepreneurship can be a vocation. Business people have a special role to play in the economy of salvation. They share in the task of furthering the faith when they use their talents in a way consistent with their religion. They have their own assignment in the mission of the people of God. Everyone has talents, and God wants us to cultivate them and treat them as gifts. If the gift happens to be for business or stock trading or investment banking, its possessor should not be condemned because of his or her trade. In order to attend to the needs of the poor, we must also recognize the blessing of the freedom to create wealth.

In addition to the creation of wealth, which benefits all of society through the improvements in standards of living, business professionals can also find Christ in the lives of those they serve everyday in the market. We have grown accustomed to looking for Christ in the faces of our family members, loved ones and associates. We need to also see Christ in the lives of those with whom we trade, buy and sell. Christ belongs in the market place, not as modity, but as the moral authority for all our economic actions.

There is nothing base or unworthy about market cooperation. The incarnation teaches us to look for, and expect to find, God in all places and things. Is there is any reason to doubt that we cannot also find Him in our attempts to make a living and provide for our families?

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
Private Solutions: The Best Hope for Cultural Renewal
R&L: In your book Transforming America from the Inside Out, you diagnose America’s social condition as “Cultural AIDS”. That has e a controversial metaphor. What do you mean by “Cultural AIDS” and why is it more accurate than mon phrase “culture wars”? James: The concept of culture wars is that there are two, three, perhaps four cultures in America that are clashing with one another, and the strongest will ultimately survive. I believe, however, that America at its core...
There is a Crucial Link Between Culture and Economics
R&L: Do you agree with Josef Schumpeter’s thesis that capitalism is ultimately destructive of both itself and the culture within which it operates? Berger: I don’t think I can answer that with a simple yes or no. Schumpeter saw certain things very clearly, and certainly capitalism creates certain processes which have negative cultural effects. I would say that capitalism is very much part of modernity, not just the economic system. It is other institutional consequences of modernization, for example...
Civilization Held Together by Persuasion, Not Force
R&L: You have written, “The triumph of persuasion over force is the sign of a civilized society.” Could you explain what you mean by this? Skousen: I made this statement in a pamphlet I wrote several years ago titled “Persuasion vs. Force.” Alfred North Whitehead, the British philosopher and Harvard professor, elaborated when he said, “Commerce is the great example of intercourse by way of persuasion. War, slavery, and pulsion exemplify the reign of force.” (Adventures of Ideas, p....
Learning from Victorian Virtues
R&L: Let’s begin by discussing your latest book, The Demoralization Of Society. In it you state that Victorian society stigmatized the recipients of government assistance. Tell us about that. Himmelfarb: Well, it stigmatized them in several ways: first, it stigmatized them rhetorically. The recipient of relief was called a pauper, not a poor man. The Victorians made a great attempt to keep the distinction between pauper and poor. The word poor was synonymous with the working classes or the...
Faith Essential Ingredient of Democratic Capitalism
R&L: You opened your essay in Reinventing the American People, a recent book from the Ethics and Public Policy Center, by noting that a long line of political theorists, dating back to the days of the Romans, would regard you as “a dangerous man, a threat to the public order” because you are “an orthodox Christian.” What is the appropriate way for Christians to be political? Weigel: My book, Soul of the World, begins with this claim: The most...
Current Government Policies are Hurting Our Families
R&L: Many Christians are fortable with Capitalism as an economic system, often blaming the “system” for such things as poverty and social ills. Often this fear of Capitalism leads many to endorse forms of Socialism as more Christian. What are your views concerning Capitalism? Dobson: On the world stage of varying economic philosophies, I believe that Capitalism has been shown to be the best economic system for improving the living conditions of mankind. It is not perfect, just like...
The Free Market and Public Morality
R&L: What was it that caused you to have second thoughts about the role of the state in economic life and about the left-wing agenda of the 60’s of which you were so much a part? Novak: In many places the liberal agenda did not work as we had hoped. I was living in New York at the time, and the city almost went bankrupt. Crime and illegitimacy were mounting. Those of us who were in favor of the...
A Revolution of Compassion
R&L: You are viewed by many as one of the architects of the “Welfare Revolution”. Many believe that this revolution is motivated solely by financial concerns, but in your work The Tragedy of American Compassion, you speak of other dimensions and motivations. What do you believe are the strongest reasons for welfare reform? Olasky: I am glad to be viewed as an architect, but there are others who have done far more than me. I think of people like...
Freedom From Welfare Dependency
R&L: What are the differences between the genders as articulated in your book Men and Marriage and what impact does this have on the social order? Gilder: The key difference is that the woman holds in her very body a link to the long term future of the race. Her sexuality determines her long term goals. As a very physiological consciousness, she knows she can bear and nurture children. She has a central role in the very perpetuation of...
Michigan Welfare Reform has Long Since Begun
R&L: Many conservative leaders, including yourself, have referred to the “paradigm shift” that is occurring in the nation’s approach to welfare. What does that term mean to you? Engler: “Paradigm shift” is a much better word than “reform” to describe the dramatic changes we see taking place in this nation’s thinking about welfare. No one defends the current welfare state anymore, which discourages mothers from marrying, encourages fathers to abandon their children, and puts no value on work and...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved