Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
(Pope) John Paul, George, and Ringo on the harms of high taxes (video)
(Pope) John Paul, George, and Ringo on the harms of high taxes (video)
Jun 16, 2025 4:14 AM

Every November 29, fans pause to remember George Harrison of The Beatles, who died in 2001. In addition to his sensitive lyrics, intricate melodies, and legendary chart-topping success Harrison should be remembered for another feat: He may have been the first singing supply-side economist.

In a 1969 interview with David Wigg, Harrison showed profound insight into how taxes discourage work and wealth creation. “The shy Beatle,” as he was known, said:

Britain in a way, you know, it cuts its own throat. Just from my experience of Britain. It’s, you know, it’s on every level, you know, from your tax right down into every little speck of business. The British government’s policy seems to be, grab as much as you can now, because maybe it’s only gonna last another six months. I know personally for me, there’s no point in me going out and doing a job, doing a show, or doing a TV show or anything, you know. Because in Britain first of all they can’t afford to pay you. And whatever they do pay you is taxed so highly that it ends up that you owe them money. So, you know, why bother working?

But if my tax is cut, then I’d do four times as much work; I’d make four times as much money. They’d take less tax, but they’d make more from me. But they cut their own throat. … That’s Britain. Now in America … more things get done and, you know, it really pays.

Twenty-two years later when Pope John Paul II wrote in Centesimus Annus that “the Social Assistance State leads to a loss of human energies,” he and Harrison were singing off the same page.

The UK’s confiscatory taxes led Harrison to pen the bitingly satirical song “Taxman.” It would e the lead track on the 1966 album Revolver, the first LP to feature more than two songs written by Harrison. It was also the first song he described as “autobiographical.”

The song’s opening lyric – “Let me tell you how it will be / There’s one for you, 19 for me” – was no poetic license. That was The Beatles’ tax bracket.

Then-UK Prime Minister Harold Wilson of the Labour Party introduced a 95 percent “supertax,” which applied to the four lads from Liverpool. “You are so happy that you’ve finally started earning money – and then you find out about tax,” Harrison recounted. “In those days we paid nineteen shillings and sixpence out of every pound (there were twenty shillings in the pound).”

Harrison did e by his economic views from reading Hayek and Mises. He had clawed his way up from a life of poverty in working-class Liverpool to find the government trying to stall his escape.

“They’d been poor boys, who’d worked hard and made money, and now someone was trying to take it away,” according to their accountant, Harry Pinsker. Paul McCartney said the track embodied “George’s righteous indignation at the whole idea of having got here,” only to see the lion’s share of their earnings “removed by force.” Ringo Starr shared Harrison’s outrage that “[i]f we earn a million, then the government gets 90 per cent and we get 10,000.”

Their frustration came, not from the position of greedy stars trying to “hoard” their wealth, but disadvantaged youths struggling to escape poverty and desperation.

“Taxman” satirized the mindset of mitted to wealth redistribution: “Should five percent appear too small / Be thankful I don’t take it all.” It parodied UK taxes on sales, transit, even the death tax.

However, the song created some internal dissension, “Something” the band already had in surplus by 1966. John Lennon remembered that when Harrison “called to ask for help” with the lyrics, “I didn’t want to do it; I just sort of bit my tongue and said OK.” Reportedly, Lennon advised that the background singers mention “Mr. Wilson” and “Mr. Heath” (Conservative Party leader Edward Heath).

Despite their philosophical quarrels, the end result pleased almost everyone. Some music critics see “Taxman” as the beginning of the musical experimentation that would characterize the band’s later years. Its message remains so powerful that, to this day, some economics professors use its lyrics to teach the adverse impact of high marginal tax rates.

The UK learned from Harrison’s plea. Margaret Thatcher reduced the top tax rate to 40 percent, touching off a national economic renaissance. However, current Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn, and his top economic adviser John McDonnell, have proposed higher taxes and celebrated the postwar tax rates lambasted by Harrison, justifying the move as a way to help the poor.

“I would argue that taxation can be a vehicle for distribution for wealth. It can be a way of giving an opportunity to people,” Corbyn said.

George Harrison’s ments should remind us that efforts to “soak the rich” only make the path from rags to riches slicker for society’s most vulnerable. And they discouraged one of the greatest musical geniuses of his time from producing four-times as many songs to add to his immense legacy.

Perhaps his sweet Lord saw that Harrison already had an embarrassment of riches.

Beatles arrive in the United States, at JFK airport on February 7, 1964. Public domain.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Global Warming Consensus Alert: “Most Evidence Suggests the Contrary”
“Global warming doesn’t matter except to the extent that it will affect life — ours and that of all living things on Earth. And contrary to the latest news, the evidence that global warming will have serious effects on life is thin. Most evidence suggests the contrary.” The quote is from Dr. Daniel Botkin, professor emeritus in the Department of Ecology, Evolution, and Marine Biology at the University of California, Santa Barbara. I guess we can add him to the...
Belgium No More?
If you haven’t been following this story, now might be a good time to look into it – Belgium may be dividing into two separate entities sooner rather than later, with Brussels possibly ing an independent city-state in the process: Belgium is the host country for the EU project, and the bureaucrats in Brussels are terrified that the epicenter of European anti-nationalism may be about to break apart due to national differences. Also, free-market-oriented Flanders, where 60-percent of the population...
Sixteenth Century Society 2007
I’m preparing to travel to Minneapolis later this week to present a paper at the annual conference of the Sixteenth Century Society, which is a major academic society focusing on the study of the early modern period. I’ll attempt to blog from the conference as I have opportunity and there is information of relevant interest to the PowerBlog audience. Posted after the jump is my tentative schedule, including which sessions I’ll be attending (full conference program is in PDF form...
Gandalf in Brussels?
French president Nicholas Sarkozy has mended the formation of a “Council of the Wise,” which would have the task of “elaborating proposals for the future development of Europe.” A recent survey by the Bertelsmann Foundation finds a lot of support for the idea in France, the UK, and Germany. I suppose there are various ways to read this. One, hinted at by the survey story linked above, is that people in the EU are uneasy about the direction Europe is...
Francis Asbury & The Rise of American Methodism
Francis Asbury was so well-known in early America that letters addressed to “Bishop Asbury, United States of America” were delivered to him. During his life, Methodist Bishop Asbury (1745-1816) is said to have preached well over 16,000 sermons and traveled nearly 300,000 miles on horseback alone. The explosion of Methodism in the United States after the American Revolution, and during the Second Great Awakening is well documented in the history of the church. When Asbury arrived in the colonies, Methodists...
Top 50 Catholic High Schools Announced for 2007
Today the Acton Institute announced it fourth annual selection of theCatholic High School Honor Roll, the best 50 Catholic secondary schools in the United States. The purpose of the Honor Roll is to recognize and encourage excellence in Catholic secondary education. It is a critical resource for parents and educators that honors those schools that excel in three categories: academic excellence, Catholic Identity, and civic education. To see a list of the top 50 schools, as well as lists of...
The Religious Left and Class Warfare
In my three and a half years as a student at Asbury Theological Seminary, I encountered more anti-capitalist rhetoric than I may have experienced in my entire life up to that point. Before Asbury, I attended a state and secular university, Ole Miss, where socialist propaganda was largely out of fashion. Acton President Rev. Robert Sirico is quoted in a new piece titled, “The Religious Left, Reborn” by Steven Malanga. The article appears in the autumn issue of City Journal....
Is Benedict XVI “The Green Pope”?
Kishore Jayabalan, the Director of Acton’s Rome office, took to the airwaves this morning on Relevant Radio’s Morning Air program to discuss recent media speculation about Pope Benedict XVI’s statements on the moral responsibility of Catholics to care for creation. Does this make Benedict “green”? Or is this simply a continuation of long-standing Vatican policy dating to the pontificate of John Paul II and prior? Kishore answers those questions and sheds light on how the Holy See approaches environmental issues...
Who’s Afraid of Free Trade?
In answer to the query in the headline of this week’s Acton Commentary, “Who’s Afraid of Free Trade?”, I submit the following: the ecumenical movement. Note the following news item from Ecumenical News International: Church groups mount week of action to transform global trade Geneva (ENI). Faith groups have joined activists around the globe in calling for fair, equitable and just trade policies while urging churches to join a Trade Week of Action that seeks to promote alternatives to the...
Are Public Schools a Bad Investment?
Besides my two years of living abroad in Egypt, I spent my entire elementary and upper school existence in the public schools. My experience with the public schools in Hawaii and Mississippi were rather atrocious. To read one experience I encountered in the public schools in Hawaii, check out this Acton blog post. Mississippi has a wonderful and generous culture, and the people have strong values. In fact, I love Mississippi. The state’s public schools, however, could often be described...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved