Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
Parallel Universes
Parallel Universes
Sep 5, 2025 1:15 AM

  Cosmology is a subject that is far too difficult for me. For example, I find it impossible to understand the idea of the Big Bang, let alone the idea that there might be two or more universes. The nearest I can come to understanding the latter is the commentary I see on the Internet regarding the American election. There, people seem to live in parallel universes, where perceptions seem hardly to be about the same subject matter.

  Here, for example, are two commentaries taken from readers’ responses to articles about the election. They seem indicative not just of a difference of opinion—for example, over the correct policy regarding farm subsidies—but a gulf in world outlooks of almost religious intensity. The first implies that a Republican victory would be the end of constitutional rule. The commentator characterises two candidates:

  One was a convicted criminal awaiting sentencing in one matter and trial in three others, including inciting a mob to overthrow an election. The other was a prosecutor and a life long public servant with a distinguished record. Voting for the former was a vote against the founding principles of American democracy. Voting the other way was the only responsible thing an American could do if they believe in it.

  The second describes the victory of the Republicans in more or less the same, but opposite, apocalyptic terms:

  Looks like a solid rejection of leftists’ ideas and a failed coup by the Democrats to install a far left candidate.

  On this view, a victory by the Democrats would not have been merely electoral: it would have installed a regime of a completely new kind, alien to and destructive of the Constitution.

  This dichotomy of opinion seemed to be universal. No one said, “On the one hand … but on the other.” Of course, people who see the world in dimensional rather than categorical terms generally do not take as quickly to the keyboard as those who conceive of politics as the contest between St. John the Baptist and Mephistopheles. Apart from anything else, their message would be longer and, in times of reduced attention span, would almost certainly remain unread. We like strong emotions, and a Manichean soundbite viewpoint provides them.

  Were elections always as socially divisive? The record of electoral politics in all countries teems with mutual insult, gross exaggeration, lying, bad temper, vandalism, mudslinging, and fights, only for everything to return to much as usual shortly afterward: as if the election had, in fact, been more a letting off of steam than an existential conflict, or at least mere shadow boxing.

  The extremity of many people’s reaction to the electoral result in America suggests that the hold of the agreed rules of the game on their minds and imagination has loosened.

  This last election, however, seemed to have a different quality from the others, almost apocalyptic for both sides, as if the end of the world would come if the other side won. It divided families that had previously enjoyed good relations; at best, many subjects had to be avoided in order to preserve some kind of domestic or family peace, for opinions come prepackaged and the slightest slip might reveal that the person making it was of the other, evil side.

  Mutual incomprehension, with each side holding to alternative facts—by no means an absurd expression in the context of political opinion, in the formation of which preponderant weight may be given to facts not mentioned or acknowledged by the other side, even when they are facts—and unable to see how any decent person could have an opinion that differed from his or her own, was the order of the day.

  Perhaps what was more important was the staying power as well as the depth of the incomprehension. We are very far from the spirit of W. S. Gilbert’s humorous lyric, in which Private Willis sings:

  I often think it’s comical

  How Nature always does contrive

  That every boy and every gal

  That’s born into the world alive

  Is either a little Liberal

  Or else a little Conservative!

  Here, politics is conceived of as a game, or at worst, a competitive sport, rather than an existential Manichaean struggle.

  When politics is a kind of game or sport, it does not follow that nothing serious can be at stake. In our adversarial legal system, lawyers are, in a sense, playing a game: they do not necessarily believe in the case that they are presenting, but rather are presenting the best case that they can on behalf of their clients. The element of sparring in the law does not mean, however, that nothing serious is at stake. The contest is one within accepted rules, and without acceptance of those rules, mere anarchy would be loosed upon the world.

  The extremity of many people’s reaction to the electoral result in America suggests that the hold of the agreed rules of the game on their minds and imagination has loosened. I cannot say how representative they are, but there were videos of people, especially young people, reacting histrionically to the election result, as if they had lost an entire family (though I think that there was something bogus about the emotion expressed). They seemed to have forgotten, or no longer believe, that in a system such as the American, no victory is permanent or cannot be undone or in part reversed later, by means of peaceful change of government. It was as if a pendulum had been replaced by a steel pole set in concrete. They reacted more as if there had been a military coup than an election—though if there had been, they would no doubt have been more circumspect in expressing themselves in the way that they did. They were, in essence, guilty of bad faith. 

  The talk of a second civil war seems from the outside to be grossly exaggerated. A period of constant but more than usual bitter sniping, legal and rhetorical, is far more likely. But when those who do not like the result of an election talk not of opposition to the government, which is perfectly normal, but of resistance to it, one senses a crisis of legitimacy, which the United States is far from alone in experiencing. Legitimacy is not merely a question of having followed the rules, but of having a belief in the legitimacy of the rules themselves, even, or especially, when you do not like the result when they have been followed.

  When both sides of a political divide think of the other not as the champion of differing policies, but as an existential threat to the political system itself, conflict, even if it remains purely in the verbal sphere, is bound to become more acute. There is a resultant overemphasis on what divides rather than a recognition of what unites; demagoguery is both its cause and its consequence.

  I hope that this is a passing distemper.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
Preserving the Human in Planet of the Apes
  Wonders are many, and none is more wonderful than man. – Sophocles   “I cant help thinking that somewhere in the universe there has to be something better than man.” So ponders astronaut George Taylor (played by Charlton Heston) in the 1968 original Planet of the Apes. Decades later, in an interview promoting Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes, co-leads...
Being Taught by the Holy Spirit
  Being Taught by the Holy Spirit   Weekly Overview:   As believers, we’ve been given the Holy Spirit as a Helper, Teacher, Friend, and seal for the promised inheritance of eternal life with God. His presence, guidance, and wisdom in our lives are our greatest gifts while here on earth. Through him we have access to direct connection with our heavenly Father....
Lowering the Temperature
  The scene was shocking, to be sure. But sadly, it wasn’t surprising.   In fact, one might be forgiven for wondering at the fact that more bullets haven’t been flying at political rallies. You don’t have to look far on any social media outlet to find people salivating at the prospect of a politics of enmity and blood. And these are...
The Church Is Here to Stay
  Weekend, July 13, 2024   The Church Is Here to Stay   And let us not neglect our meeting together, as some people do, but encourage one another, especially now that the day of his return is drawing near. (Hebrews 10:25 NLT)   The first one ever to use the word church was not the apostle Paul. Rather, it was Jesus Himself. He...
A God Who Freely Pardons (Isaiah 55:7)
  BIBLE VERSE OF THE DAY:“Let the wicked forsake their ways and the unrighteous their thoughts. Let them turn to the Lord, and He will have mercy on them, and to our God, for He will freely pardon.” –Isaiah 55:7   A God Who Freely Pardons   by Lynette Kittle   Who deserves to be pardoned? When it comes to presidential pardons and the...
Learning from Europe’s Mistakes
  When Thomas Sargent won the Nobel Prize in Economics in 2011, the title of his Prize Lecture was “The United States Then, Europe Now.” In the lecture, Sargent compared the then-ongoing European Sovereign Debt Crisis (or “Eurozone Crisis”) to the sovereign debt crisis state governments faced during the Panic of 1837.   Now, 13 years after the European Debt Crisis, state...
‘We Praise You that Trump Is Gonna Be All Right’
  Evangelical leaders and politicians offered prayers for former president Donald Trump and thanked God for sparing his life following a shooting at a campaign rally in western Pennsylvania on Saturday.   Thousands of supporters joined a prayer call hosted by America First Policy Institute, hours after a bullet fired toward Trump grazed his right ear while he spoke before a crowd...
El Salvador’s Prisons Have Never Been Fuller. But Ministry to the Incarcerated Has Never Been More Strapped
  In just over two years, El Salvadors government has sent 80,000 people to prison. With over 111,000 people incarcerated, the country has the worlds highest proportion of people behind barsone inmate for every 56 people.   The current situation stems from a zero-tolerance policy toward the gangs that once proliferated in the country. Salvadoran gangs are considered transnational crime organizations responsible...
5 Ways to Encourage Your Man
  5 Ways to Encourage Your Man   By Heather Riggleman   “Let us hold fast the confession of our hope without wavering, for he who promised is faithful. And let us consider how to stir up one another to love and good works, not neglecting to meet together, as is the habit of some, but encouraging one another, and all the more...
J.D. Vance, the VP Pick for a Party Made in Trump’s Image
  Donald Trumps first running mate, Mike Pence, appealed to conservative evangelical voters by offering what Trump lacked: political experience, a pro-life record, a steady demeanor, and outspoken Christian faith.   Two presidential elections later, Trumps 2024 pick for vice president, J. D. Vance, appeals to conservatives by being like the former president: a fellow political newcomer, a populist, and a fighter...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved