Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
Of Markets and Morality
Of Markets and Morality
May 9, 2025 11:09 AM

The great mantra of this prevailing culture of self-absorption is tolerance: If only everyone, everywhere, and under all circumstances could only be tolerant, we are assured, what a wonderful and peaceful world it would be. This kind of illiberal faith, this chic toleration, is so intolerant as to assert the truth claims of orthodox Judaism and Christianity. The problem with this arrogance (which always fails to see its own arrogance) is that it presumes that the Jewish and Christian reliance on the use of faith to apprehend some truths diminishes the importance of the mind, and hence, man himself.

This modern, liberal mindset begins by rejecting revelation, but in the course of its intellectual trajectory it must undermine not merely Biblical truth-claims but any claim to know truth. It does so to allow the individual to impose himself and his opinions on the world, creating God and others in his own image rather than shaping his views according to reality.

Theistic agnosticism in this way easily proceeds to moral agnosticism, and eventually, when it has run its course, one emerges as an epistemological agnostic–unable to assert knowledge of anything with certainty. All of this, then, is an attack on man, his capacity for choice, his dignity, and his intellect. It is an attack on the prerequisite for all intellectual and moral progress–and it is done in the very name of progress. It is an attack, eventually, upon human life itself exactly to the extent that it relativizes morality and virtue.

Ironically, this whole approach ends up destroying tolerance itself. Pluralism is not a beige, lukewarm man of undefined verbiage–a blended mixture of mild opinions calculated never to offend. It is vivid in hue, robust in texture. The roots of pluralism and tolerance are not found in a valueless agnosticism that holds to nothing in particular, or everything in general, but emerges within a certain stance to which people mitted, while accepting boundaries to its enforcement.

Defenders of genuine liberty stand opposed to the nihilistic subjectivism of our age. We desire to build a society based upon the truth about man and God. Yet, one area of confusion that the advocates of the free economy must avoid making is the temptation to either idolatrize the market economy, or to suppose that virtue is something that can be enacted by politicians and implemented by bureaucrats.

Of itself, the market and the technological advances that result from it, lack a telos–a proper end or purpose toward which this development is oriented. That end or purpose depends upon the human person who initiates economic actions, and who himself has absorbed from somewhere a sense of moral purpose. The market and technology lack the logic to tell us who we are and what we ought to do. For that we must look elsewhere: to the texts of Scripture, to God’s love and action on behalf of those created in His likeness and image.

The market and technology give us the how–and this how is critically important–for without it life would be burdensome and difficult. Earth would be unable to sustain the abundance that provides for human well-being and prosperity. But while the free market is necessary in providing the how of technological progress, it is to the Scriptures that we must look to discover the ought of our lives; to answer the perennial questions: How ought, then, we to live? What is the purpose, the value, and the end of our society, our homes, and our lives?

To separate the how from the ought is to create economic and moral chaos–it is to either place human life at the disposal of economic, technological, and emotional whim, or it is to e so heavenly minded we are no earthly good. We are called to e good servants in the culture of life. This requires us to master both our world and our moral lives, and live as dignified sons and daughters of the God of Life.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
Why God Doesnt Heal Every Sickness? (James 5:13
  Why God Doesn’t Heal Every Sickness, Disease, and Illness   By Chris Russell   Is anyone among you suffering? Let him pray. Is anyone cheerful? Let him sing psalms. Is anyone among you sick? Let him call for the elders of the church, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord. And the prayer...
A Hardened Heart
  A Hardened Heart   By: Michelle Lazurek   Jesus replied, 'Moses permitted you to divorce your wives because your hearts were hard. But it was not this way from the beginning.'Matthew 19:8   The year 2020 was one of the most challenging years for my marriage. Not only did COVID profoundly impact our lives, including the lives of our church, but also work...
Liberalisms Bleak Future?
  Robert D. Kaplan is one of America’s most prolific and important writers. Presidents have consulted his books, and as anexpert in geopolitics, he is a member of both the Pentagon’s Defense Policy Board and the Chief of Naval Operations Executive Panel. Astonishingly, Kaplan publishes a book most years and his latestWaste Land: A World in Permanent Crisis contends that the...
AI and Our Aging Population
  In a 2021 speech on Italy’s birth rate crisis, Pope Francis referred to the situation as a “demographic winter that is cold and dark.” As global birth rates decline and populations age, societies face economic and social challenges, but the rapid rise of Artificial Intelligence (AI) could transform this crisis, potentially offsetting labor shortages—but not without new risks. At the...
Signs of Jesus’ Return
  Saturday, April 5, 2025   Signs of Jesus’ Return   “Later, Jesus sat on the Mount of Olives. His disciples came to him privately and said, ‘Tell us, when will all this happen? What sign will signal your return and the end of the world?’” (Matthew 24:3 NLT)   The Jerusalem temple was a magnificent structure, one the Jewish people were exceedingly proud...
What the New Right Gets Right
  The biggest political event for conservatives in the last decade was Donald Trump’s slow trip down the escalator. But maybe the second biggest was the swift rise of what’s often been called the “new right.”   Though that collection has been understood as a hodgepodge of populists, nationalists, neo-mercantilists, post-liberals, and Catholic integralists, the components have been connected by a frustration...
Real Friends Show Up
  Real Friends Show Up   This devotional was written by Doug Fields   One who has unreliable friends soon comes to ruin, but there is a friend who sticks closer than a brother. —Proverbs 18:24   As a pastor, I’ve come alongside my share of people who have experienced grief, tragedy, and loss. Typically, in a situation where one is hurting and/or grieving,...
Legalism Threatens Our Rule of Law
  Associate Justice Neil Gorsuch is a rarity of a judge, and not only because he is principled, learned, and seven years an incumbent of the Supreme Court of the United States. He is also literate, funny, and imaginative—which is unusual, especially for a black-robed power. And he has written another book to prove it.   Over Ruled: The Human Toll of...
Unveiling the Buried Stories
  Socialism and antisemitism are two malign phenomena that have been surging in the West of late. We rarely think to connect these two things, but in fact, they do intersect in important ways. Economic inequality has fueled resentment and a resurgence of socialist ideas. Many in the West, especially younger generations, feel squeezed by rising prices, the myth of wage...
Federalist Solutions to AI Regulation
  Policy analysts often worry about the possibility of states stifling AI innovation by passing a patchwork of complex and even conflicting legislation. By way of example, SB 1047, a bill in California dictating the development of leading AI models, evoked concerns that a couple dozen Golden State legislators could meaningfully bend the AI development curve without input from the rest...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved