Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How not to think clearly on faith and economics
How not to think clearly on faith and economics
Nov 8, 2024 7:01 AM

‘A view of Blanchard Hall in Wheaton College’ by Liscobeck Public Domain

Mark Labberton, President of Fuller Seminary, recently addressed a meeting of Evangelical leaders held at Wheaton College and has released a reconstruction of his remarks. It is an interesting address which spends four paragraphs explicitly addressing questions of economics and economic policy.

This section begins by rightly noting that, “It is very hard to read the Bible and ignore God’s heart for the poor and the vulnerable.” In the Catholic tradition there has been a sustained reflection on this issue using the language of a preferential option for the poor (See ‘The Poor as Neighbors: Option & Respect’) and Labberton’s call for Evangelicals to reflect in a similar way is most e.

When Labberton later states, “Long before free market capitalism had developed, the God of Israel, the God revealed in Jesus Christ, was shown to bend toward mercy, with justice for the poor.”, there is potential for confusion.

While the preferential option for the poor is indeed an essential and distinct part of the Christian tradition it is wrong to paint it in opposition to free markets. Last week I sought to outline an argument for the essential consonance of the broadly liberal tradition, including free market economics, with the Christian tradition (See ‘Is economics an ideology?’). Just as the preferential option for the poor is the product of the sustained reflection of Christians on their scripture, tradition, and experience so too are free markets and the institutions, ethics, and law which undergird them (See Sources in Early Modern Economics, Ethics, and Law for a rich sampling of this tradition).

The maintenance of the important distinction between the preferential option for the poor as an ethical imperative and markets as an essential institution of a just social order keeps us thinking clearly and from making the sorts of mistakes that I believe Labberton makes in his concluding paragraph on economics,

When white evangelicals in prominent and wealthy places speak about what is fair and beneficial for society, but then pass laws and tax changes that create more national indebtedness and elevate the top 1% even higher—while cutting services and provisions for children, the disabled, and the poor that are castigated as disgusting “entitlements”—one has to ask how this is reconciled with being followers of Jesus. plexities of social support for the vulnerable in our society certainly can and should be debated, but when the instigators of change are serving elite interests and disregarding the 99%, it is very hard to recognize the influence of the gospel narrative passion, let alone justice.

It is difficult to evaluate this paragraph without knowing about which particular laws or tax changes Labberton is referring to. National indebtedness is certainly not something to be pursued for its own sake and I am not aware of any law or tax policy that pursues it as such. Christians have long struggled with and reflected on questions of credit and under which circumstances and when it is morally justified (See On Exchange and Usury and On Righteousness, Oaths, and Usury). What is clear is that a simple acceptance or rejection of the use of credit as such is unwise.

Similarly I am unaware of any law designed explicitly to enrich the ‘1%’. Samuel Gregg, the Acton Institute’s Director of Research, has rightly condemned the injustice of ‘Crony Capitalism’ which,

… involves dislodging the workings of free exchange within a framework of property rights and rule of law—what is generally understood to be a free market. These arrangements are gradually replaced by “political markets.”

This is a perennial problem which early free market theorists fought against (See ‘The Law’) and continue to analyze (See ‘Rent Seeking’).

Labberton acknowledges that, plexities of social support for the vulnerable in our society certainly can and should be debated…”, but uses very loaded and hostile language to describe critics of the current welfare state. It should be noted that our largest entitlement programs, Social Security and Medicare, are not means tested and flow not only to the poor but to the ‘1%’! Poverty is plex social problem and bringing the marginalized towards the center of our social, religious, and economic life requires the pairing of our good intentions with sound economics (See ‘Redistribution’).

Economics should be the concern of serious Christians but Labberton’s address brings more heat than light to the issue. For some light I would heartily mend Victor Claar and Robin Klay’s Economics in Christian Perspective: Theory, Policy and Life Choices.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
What Will Your Religious Liberty Cost You? Obamacare Edition
We know freedom isn’t free. And apparently, we are now going to find out exactly how much our religious freedom is going to cost. Matthew Clark at Charisma News says that “refusal to violate your faith” under Obamacare is going to cost you…a lot. If you value your faith;if you are one of the millions of Americans who believe that abortion pills cause the destruction of innocent, God-given human life; if you are an employer who believes that being forced...
Are Human Beings Simply A Collection Of Body Parts?
There is nothing simple about Bl. John Paul II’s writings, and yet, his work collectively called the Theology of the Body offers a remarkable chance to reflect on the unique creation that is man. In modern culture, we see humanity reduced to a collection of parts (a lung to transplant, a womb to be rented) or as an instrument to be used (for lust or for slavery.) The human body has e “treachery”, as George Orwell notes in 1984, not...
‘Tea Party Catholic:’ The Necessity of Faith and Liberty
Fr. C John McCloskey, research fellow at the Faith and Reason Institute, recently reviewed Sam Gregg’s Tea Party Catholic at the National Catholic Register. In “Life, Liberty and Faith,” McCloskey says, “Gregg builds an argument for free economy and human flourishing that is a must-read, regardless of your political affiliation or whether you are Catholic or a serious Christian concerned about the rapidly diminishing religious liberty in the United States.” McCloskey points out at the book focuses on the only...
Creation and the Heart of Man: ‘Orthodox and not Libertarian’
Today at Ethika Politika, Alfred Kentigern Siewers reviews Creation and the Heart of Man: An Orthodox Christian Perspective on Environmentalism, Acton’s recent Orthodox Christian social thought monograph by Fr. Michael Butler and Prof. Andrew Morriss. Siewers offers a nuanced and critical review, being well-read in the literature himself, and ultimately es the monograph as a missing voice in the broader conversation of Orthodox Christianity and creation care. Siewers writes, [I]n its introductory opening chapter, the authors clearly set forth their...
Mamas, Don’t Let Your Babies Grow Up To Be Newspaper Reporters. Let ‘Em Be Actuaries and Optometrists and Such.
What’s the deal with actuaries? Whenever a new list of the best jobs piled—like the rankings by Career Cast—they are always near the top of the list. What could really be so great about interpreting statistics to determine probabilities of accidents, sickness, and death, and loss of property from theft and natural disasters? And why have I never actually met an actuary? Are their jobs so exceedingly awesome that they don’t take time to associate with non-actuaries? Anyway, here are...
‘Empty Labels’ In The Catholic Realm
Carl E. Olson, in an editorial entitled “Catholicism and the Convenience of Empty Labels,” says that many who write and discuss all things Catholic get lost in “fabricated conflicts” which lack context. Pope Francis, depending on who is speaking, is a darling of the “liberals” or a stalwart “conservative.” Suffice to say, the die has been cast for many journalists, and thus for their readers, when es to framing stories about the good Pope Francis and the evil “right-wingers” who...
How Would You Like An ‘Affordable Healthy Food Act?’
The government is now in the health care business. Trans fats may be on their way out, and New York is trying to tell us to stop buying buckets of soda to drink. Can you imagine a land of the “Affordable Healthy Food Act?” Jacqueline Isaacs can. Imagine with me, a hypothetical world where a politician was running for the office of President of the United States on the platform that everyone deserved a healthy diet. Not so far-fetched of...
Does Church/State Separation Apply To Black Churches?
According to World News Daily the federal government has enlisted black church denominations to enroll people into Obamacare. Enroll America, a Washington-based nonprofit staffed in part by ex-Obama presidential campaign workers, is leading the enrollment campaign which saw just over 100,000 people “sign up” in October. Jessica Kendall, director of outreach for Enroll America, calls the task of signing up America’s uninsured the “largest enrollment effort that has ever been done in our history.” Her group is working with a...
Samuel Gregg on Pope Francis and Latin American Political History
Carl E Olson, editor of The Catholic World Report, recently wrote an article addressing the perception of Pope Francis by media members outside the Catholic Church. He says: Many in the American media, however, have already made up their minds: yes, the new pope is “liberal”, and that supposed fact is a big problem for those “conservative” bishops who keep harping about fringe issues such as the killing of the unborn, sexual immorality, the familial foundations of society, and the...
Where Is All That ‘Dark Money’ Coming From?
Your writer possesses well-meaning friends forever vigilant in my best interests. Most recently, one such kind soul sent an email alerting me to the dangers of so-called “dark money” in the political process. Believing himself on the side of the angels – and fully onside with activist nuns, priests and other religious – my friend sought my assistance in the fight against “evil” corporations participating in the political process. So I got the following in my inbox. And all I...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved