Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How Michigan’s licensing laws hinder the disadvantaged
How Michigan’s licensing laws hinder the disadvantaged
Dec 19, 2025 5:15 PM

Proponents of greater government intervention often argue that some freedoms are well worth sacrificing for greater social stability or public health and safety. Such is particularly the case with occupational licensing and other micro-regulations, where the government routinely imposes barriers with the stated aims of “protecting consumers” or “stabilizing industries.”

But while such regulations may overly technical and practical, the cost of the corresponding freedoms is far from abstract. It’s personal—felt in the form of new economic obstacles for the most vulnerable and greater protection for the privileged and well-connected.

In a new short film from the Mackinac Center, we can see some of these costs among a mix of Michigan workers and business owners. From a builder to a hair stylist to a pair of massage therapists, each has either faced fines or suffered unemployment due to excessive licensure restrictions.

For Mike Grennan, a builder with decades of experience, obtaining state licensure wasn’t possible due to a nonviolent criminal conviction in his past. As a result, he’s been unable to accept a wide range of jobs. “If it requires a permit, I can’t be involved with it,” he explains. “Let’s say I want to pick up and move a house. That’s ok. But if I want to demolishthe house, I have to pull a permit.” As a result, he’s simply unable pete and contribute his services.

But the laws aren’t just harming those with criminal backgrounds. For others in the film, es down educational or financial hurdles—struggling to either stay aware of current regulatory policy, afford the necessary schooling, or pass excessive exams that don’t actually pertain to the work at hand.

“For about 20 percent of jobs here in the state of Michigan, people have to have a license in order to work,” explains Jarrett Skorup, author of a recent Mackinac study. “There are about 200 jobs that require a license, and that means educational requirements. It means mandated college degrees. It means fees, continuing education, and all these types of barriers to entry. What we see is as soon as the government requires a license, that immediately means 15 to 30 percent higher prices for consumers. It means petition, and it means a higher recidivism rate—so actually a higher percentage of people returning to prison.”

According to the study, Michigan’s licensure regime “costs the state 125,480 jobs, and ensures citizens pay $10.4 billion annually in higher prices (or about $2,700 annually per household). The state also spends more than $150 million directly on licensing individual occupations.”

Thankfully, just last September, Gov. Rick Snyder took action to remedy some of the issues specific to criminal justice, improving access to occupational licenses and state jobs for those with criminal backgrounds.

“The state licensing bureau will remove a box on occupational licensure applications that asks if the applicant was convicted of a felony,” explains Derek Draplin. “In addition, the governor issued an executive directive ordering state agencies to remove the felony question from initial state employment applications.” Snyder hopes to set an example not only for the state government but for Michigan’s munity. Noting that getting a job is “an essential part of successful re-entry for most prisoners.”

The es as part of a larger effort by the state’s Office of Regulatory Reinvention, which aims “to ensure that Michigan’s regulatory environment is simple, fair, efficient, and conducive to business growth and job creation.”

The real-life consequences of these sorts of quiet regulations can be crippling to economic opportunity and mobility, not to mention our mindsets and imaginations about work and vocation in general. Further, as Skorup demonstrates in the study, such licensure requirements haven’t even proven themselves in the areas they aim to promote—showing no impact whatsoever on improved public health and safety, for example.

The topic of occupational licensing isn’t known for ranking high on the nation’s list of hot-button issues, but if we truly aim to expand opportunity for all, especially the marginalized and disadvantaged, it’s a fight worth waging.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The 5 deep spiritual reasons we love ‘It’s a Wonderful Life’
Over the last century no movie has been more synonymous with the Christmas season than It’s a Wonderful Life. It endures, more than seven decades after its release, because it strikes at least five deep spiritual chords in every human heart. (It bears noting: A copyright lapse allowed this modestly successful movie to e a staple of holiday programming for generations. ) It’s a tale of sacrifice, and choosing well It’s a Wonderful Life chronicles George Bailey’s evolution from a...
Americans are more likely to find their ‘meaning in life’ in money than in faith
What makes your life meaningful? For Christians the answer should be some variation of our faith in God. But if that’s your answer you are distinctly in the minority in the U.S. The Pew Research Center conducted two separate surveys, one that included an open-ended question asking Americans to describe in their own words what makes their lives feel meaningful, fulfilling, or satisfying, and another that gave respondents an opportunity to describe the myriad things they find meaningful, (i.e., faith...
The legacy of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn; The human cost of unemployment, Part I
On this episode of Radio Free Acton, John Couretas, Acton’s director munications, talks with Daniel J. Mahoney, professor of political science at Assumption College, about the legacy of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn in light of Solzhenitsyn’s memoir recently released in English, “Between Two Millstones Book I: Sketches of Exile,” the first of two books in which Solzhenitsyn recounts his exile in the West. Afterwards, reporter Anne Marie Schieber takes us on the first of a three-part series exploring the difficulty of unemployment....
The great exchange: How returning Christmas gifts refutes socialism
“It is more blessed togive than to receive,” according to the scriptures – but so many people will returndisappointing Christmas gifts to the store for an exchange or refund today thatJanuary 3 has sometimes been dubbed “National Returns Day.” While it maydeflate our ego to know that our gift choices do not bring our loved ones thepleasure we had hoped, there are economic, political, and spiritual truthsembedded in this unheralded holiday tradition. Despite the secret guilt and implied ingratitude ofreturning...
Alejandro Chafuen in Forbes: John Locke, Reason, Christianity and Christmas
John Locke is well-known as a philosopher. Perhaps less well-known, though, are the religious convictions that underlie many of his ideas. Alejandro Chafuen, Acton’s Managing Director, International, recently published an article in Forbes describing the influence of Locke’s Christianity on his views of the human person. Locke’s Christianity also shows in his mentaries and his thoughts on the birth of the Savior. Over the course of the last five years, I have been devoting my Christmas article to authors or...
UK govt to investigate global Christian persecution
As the Westcontinues to celebrate the 12 days of Christmas which extend into the New Year,some 215 million Christiansworldwide face violence or repression. On the day after Christmas, the Britishgovernment launched a review of Christian persecution in “key countries” –especially in the Middle East, Asia, and Africa – and to seek ways the UK canhelp those who are suffering. Christianity is on the“verge of extinction in its birthplace,” saidForeign Secretary Jeremy Hunt, who ordered the report. “So often the persecution...
The Acton Institute aims to recognize outstanding doctoral students through Novak Award
The Acton Institute is now accepting applications for the 2019 Novak Award. The deadline to apply is March 15, 2019. The Acton Institute will selected one winner to receive the $15,000 award. The award, named after distinguished American theologian Michael Novak, is open to current doctoral candidates or those who have received a doctorate in the past five years. Applicants should have studied theology, religion, philosophy, history, law, politics, economics or related fields. Strong academic performance is essential and applicants...
A ‘wonderful world’ greets us in 2019
Just after the ball drops in Times Square in New York City, it has e a traditional to follow the singing of “Auld Lang Syne” by playing Louis Armstrong’s “What a Wonderful World.” No song could better capture the prosperous world that greets 2019, writes Philip Booth, Ph.D., in an essay posted today on the Acton Institute’s Religion& LibertyTransatlanticwebsite. Booth relates a number of statistics that show the world has improved and shows signs it will continue improving — before...
Top 10 PowerBlog posts for 2018
As e near to the end of another year, we want to thank readers of PowerBlog for menting, and sharing our posts over the past twelve months. If you’re a new reader we encourage you to catch up by checking out our top ten most popular posts for 2018. #1 — Justice Alito exposes the hypocrisy of liberal double-standards Joe Carter You probably haven’t even heard about it, but yesterday there was an exchange in the Supreme Court that future...
5 Good news stories from 2018 you might have missed
Half the world is now middle class or wealthier For the first time since agriculture-based civilization began 10,000 years ago, the majority of humankind is no longer poor or vulnerable to falling into poverty. By our calculations, as of this month, just over 50 percent of the world’s population, or some 3.8 billion people, live in households with enough discretionary expenditure to be considered “middle class” or “rich.” Population without access to electricity falls below 1 billion In a sign...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved