Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How Michigan’s licensing laws hinder the disadvantaged
How Michigan’s licensing laws hinder the disadvantaged
Feb 11, 2026 12:04 PM

Proponents of greater government intervention often argue that some freedoms are well worth sacrificing for greater social stability or public health and safety. Such is particularly the case with occupational licensing and other micro-regulations, where the government routinely imposes barriers with the stated aims of “protecting consumers” or “stabilizing industries.”

But while such regulations may overly technical and practical, the cost of the corresponding freedoms is far from abstract. It’s personal—felt in the form of new economic obstacles for the most vulnerable and greater protection for the privileged and well-connected.

In a new short film from the Mackinac Center, we can see some of these costs among a mix of Michigan workers and business owners. From a builder to a hair stylist to a pair of massage therapists, each has either faced fines or suffered unemployment due to excessive licensure restrictions.

For Mike Grennan, a builder with decades of experience, obtaining state licensure wasn’t possible due to a nonviolent criminal conviction in his past. As a result, he’s been unable to accept a wide range of jobs. “If it requires a permit, I can’t be involved with it,” he explains. “Let’s say I want to pick up and move a house. That’s ok. But if I want to demolishthe house, I have to pull a permit.” As a result, he’s simply unable pete and contribute his services.

But the laws aren’t just harming those with criminal backgrounds. For others in the film, es down educational or financial hurdles—struggling to either stay aware of current regulatory policy, afford the necessary schooling, or pass excessive exams that don’t actually pertain to the work at hand.

“For about 20 percent of jobs here in the state of Michigan, people have to have a license in order to work,” explains Jarrett Skorup, author of a recent Mackinac study. “There are about 200 jobs that require a license, and that means educational requirements. It means mandated college degrees. It means fees, continuing education, and all these types of barriers to entry. What we see is as soon as the government requires a license, that immediately means 15 to 30 percent higher prices for consumers. It means petition, and it means a higher recidivism rate—so actually a higher percentage of people returning to prison.”

According to the study, Michigan’s licensure regime “costs the state 125,480 jobs, and ensures citizens pay $10.4 billion annually in higher prices (or about $2,700 annually per household). The state also spends more than $150 million directly on licensing individual occupations.”

Thankfully, just last September, Gov. Rick Snyder took action to remedy some of the issues specific to criminal justice, improving access to occupational licenses and state jobs for those with criminal backgrounds.

“The state licensing bureau will remove a box on occupational licensure applications that asks if the applicant was convicted of a felony,” explains Derek Draplin. “In addition, the governor issued an executive directive ordering state agencies to remove the felony question from initial state employment applications.” Snyder hopes to set an example not only for the state government but for Michigan’s munity. Noting that getting a job is “an essential part of successful re-entry for most prisoners.”

The es as part of a larger effort by the state’s Office of Regulatory Reinvention, which aims “to ensure that Michigan’s regulatory environment is simple, fair, efficient, and conducive to business growth and job creation.”

The real-life consequences of these sorts of quiet regulations can be crippling to economic opportunity and mobility, not to mention our mindsets and imaginations about work and vocation in general. Further, as Skorup demonstrates in the study, such licensure requirements haven’t even proven themselves in the areas they aim to promote—showing no impact whatsoever on improved public health and safety, for example.

The topic of occupational licensing isn’t known for ranking high on the nation’s list of hot-button issues, but if we truly aim to expand opportunity for all, especially the marginalized and disadvantaged, it’s a fight worth waging.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Utopias Denied: Arthur Koestler’s Darkness at Noon at 75
Arthur Koestler (1905-1983) “In the world of literature,” says Bruce Edward Walker in this week’s Acton Commentary, “perhaps only Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn did more to expose the lies and cruelty of 20th century totalitarianism.” What makes Darkness at Noon such an enduring artistic work is Koestler’s firsthand knowledge of his source material. Indeed,Darkness at Noon is an imaginative effort, but unlike The Gladiators – set in the first century B.C. and detailing the failed slave revolution led by Spartacus – and...
How Christianity created the free society
While many Christians have undermined human liberty, says Samuel Gregg, the Director of Research for Acton, a new book of essays shows just how much of our contemporary freedom we owe to the Christian church, Christian thinkers, and Christian practice rather than liberals and liberalism. Any discussion of freedom and Christianity quickly surfaces the numerous instances in which Christians have undermined human liberty. Reference is invariably made to the various Inquisitions, the witch trials conducted by Puritans, forced conversions, and...
Candidates must address school-to-prison pipeline
Given the overpopulation of American jails and prisons, it would stand to reason that both Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump be pressed to explain how they would dismantle the unfortunate relationship between low-performing schools and the criminal justice system. Last February, The American Bar Association (ABA) released a report in the school-to-prison pipeline. According to the ABA, the pipeline is a metaphor for how the issues in our education system facilitates students leaving school and ing involved in the criminal...
Are libertarians too anti-pollution?
“There are no solutions,” says economist Thomas Sowell. “There are only trade-offs.” Sowell’s claim is especially true when es to the issue of pollution. We have no solution that will allow us to eliminate all pollution, so we are forced to make trade-offs, such as exchanging a certain level of pollution for economic growth. What would happen, though, if we allowed our political presuppositions to determine which side of the tradeoff we must always choose? That’s the question at the...
Economic growth lifted another hundred million people out of extreme poverty
The number of people living in extreme poverty continues to decline, notes a report released yesterday by the World Bank. In 2013, the year of the prehensive data on global poverty, an estimated 767 million people were living below the international poverty line of $1.90 per person per day. This is a decrease of about 100 pared with 2012. The decline is primarily attributed to the reductions in the number of the extreme poor in South Asia (37 million fewer...
Which religious tradition is most conducive to economic freedom?
There are many factors that account for a country’s economic freedom (or lack thereof), but one ofthe most overlooked is the role of religion. Can economic freedom be explained by religion, independently ofpolitical institutions? That’s the question researchers at an economics think-tank in Germany attempted to answer. Their findings: Weinvestigate whether religion affects economic freedom. Our cross-sectional dataset includes 137countries averaged over the period 2001-2010. Simple correlations show that Protestantism isassociated with economic freedom, Islam is not, with Catholicism in...
‘You are the spring that puts all the rest in motion’
By Jacques Reich (undoubtedly based on a work by another artist) – Appletons’ Cyclopædia of American Biography, 1900, v. 5, p. 438, Public Domain, “You are the spring that puts all the rest in motion; they would not stir a step without you.” John Wesley (1703–1791) was talking about the slave trade and was impugning the buyers and owners of slaves as equally culpable as those who captured and sold them, those who “would not stir a step” without buyers...
Love is the Truth
This ad perhaps captures Deirdre McCloskey’s observation that “love runs consumption” better than anything I have yet seen. Coca Cola – What Goes es Around from THE APA on Vimeo. And embedded in Jack White’s song are some rich theological insights. For more on the backstory for the song and the ad, check out this piece at the Consequence of Sound. ...
Explainer: What you should know about the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) trade accord
In the recent presidential debate, Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton disagreed on nearly everything. But there is one thing they both oppose: the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP). Here is what you should know about the agreement and why it matters in the election. What is the Trans-Pacific Partnership? Five years in the making, the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) is a trade agreement between the United States, Australia, Canada, Japan, Malaysia, Mexico, Peru, Vietnam, Chile, Brunei, Singapore, and New Zealand. The twelve countries...
New book explores compatibility of Christianity and freedom
A new collection of essays titled Christianity and Freedom: Historical Perspectives edited by Samuel Shah and Allen D. Hertzke explores the ways that Christian beliefs and institutions have made contributions to the freedoms that are cherished by both Christians and non-Christians today. Acton Director of Research, Samuel Gregg, recently gave his analysis of this new collection of essays in a book review published at Public Discourse. Gregg begins his review by recognizing that while Christians have played a huge role...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved