Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
Debating Birthright Citizenship
Debating Birthright Citizenship
Aug 25, 2026 4:46 PM

  In recent weeks as a new presidential administration took power, legal and policy experts have hotly debated both the prudence and the justice of birthright citizenship. Does the Fourteenth Amendment require granting American citizenship to everyone born on these shores? Or does that interpretation of the citizenship clause go too far? In this symposium, two Law Liberty contributors dive into the thorny questions of constitutional interpretation at the heart of this important debate.

  

Swearing in of new US citizens_KRH7HA

  Feb 13, 2025 The Forgotten Meaning of the Citizenship Clause Amy Swearer Birthright citizenship was never the original intent of the Fourteenth Amendment’s framers.

  

Naturalization_Ceremony_in_the_Meeting_room_in_Faneuil_Hall_Government_Center_Boston_Massachusetts

  Feb 13, 2025 The Originalist Basis of Birthright Citizenship Michael D. Ramsey Birthright citizenship is the only logical interpretation of the Fourteenth Amendment originalism allows.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
Whats Next in Iran?
  Editors note: This is the first essay in a symposium on the Iran War and Americas role in the Middle East.   The US-Israeli war against Iran was fought for unclear purposes, with a vague strategy, towards an ambiguous end. That does not mean it contributed nothing to US interests. The world is safer with a weaker Iranian regime whose nuclear...
Government by Settlement
  In his piquant memoir, Streetwise, Lloyd Blankfein, former CEO of Goldman Sachs, shares an arresting anecdote about the administrative state. The SEC sued Goldman for allegedly misleading investors about the risks of mortgage-backed securities. Blankfein considered the suit meritless but settled for $550 million. “You can’t litigate against your regulator. It’s like a Star Trek episode: an alien controls the...
Humanity Lost in Space
  Americans are falling in love with Project Hail Mary, a movie about an astronaut who finds himself alone at the end of the universe, with perhaps no hope of ever returning among mankind. He then has to figure out how to save mankind in very difficult circumstances, by his wits and his technical know-how. A man a lot like the...
After the Flood in Minnesota
  Journalist Jane Jacobs coined the term “cataclysmic money” to describe a sudden, large investment into a neighborhood. It is in the precise sense of “deluge” or “flood” that she means the word, inviting us to imagine spigots of public or private money looming ominously over urban America, poised to rain torrents of dollars on the just and unjust alike. “This...
Thinking in Crisis
  “Thinking is always in crisis.” Thus observes the narrator of Ian McEwan’s most recent novel, What We Can Know. Set in the year 2119, the novel focuses on its narrator-protagonist who teaches English literature at the British University of the South Downs. The proud British Isles have shrunk to an archipelago of minor islands during the “Inundation of 2042,” and...
The Social Wealth of Nations
  July 4, 2026, marks the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence and the colonists’ claim to “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.” The year 1776 also recalls a quieter but significant anniversary. Adam Smith published An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, giving the modern world a language for thinking about markets, productivity,...
An Egalitarian Faith?
  Even before 1776, American liberty and equality were expressed in church and civil covenants and compacts, like the 1620 Mayflower Compact. Alexis de Tocqueville makes much of such covenants and compacts in Democracy in America, arguing that religion lies at the core of American character and sustains the American experiment in democracy. Christianity, in his view, is especially well-suited to...
William Blakes Daddy Issues
  The social circle of the painter Joshua Reynolds was remarkable even by the clubbable standards of Georgian London. Goldsmith, Fox, and Garrick were chums. Boswell dedicated a book to Reynolds. Edmund Burke executed his will. Having revolutionised British art education by founding the Royal Academy of Arts, he died in 1792, knighted and rich as a hog. He lives on...
Allegiance, Birthright, and Citizenship
  When the Supreme Court, on April 1, heard arguments about birthright citizenship in Trump v. Barbara, the justices focused on jurisdiction. The Fourteenth Amendment provides: “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.” The extent of birthright citizenship thus turns...
It Has Never Been About Freedom
  Editors Note: This is the second essay in a symposium on the Iran War and Americas role in the Middle East. You can read the first essay here.   “To the great proud people of Iran, I say tonight that the hour of your freedom is at hand.” So spoke President Donald Trump when he announced the commencement of Operation Epic...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved