Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
What ‘The Profit’ teaches us about ethics and enterprise
What ‘The Profit’ teaches us about ethics and enterprise
Dec 16, 2025 11:34 PM

I’ve written before on howtelevision can be a powerful tool for illuminating the deeper significance of daily work and the beauties of basic trade and enterprise. Shows like Dirty Jobs, Shark Tank, Undercover Boss, and Restaurant Impossible have used the mediumto this end, and today at The Federalist, I reviewa newcontender inthe mix.

CNBC’s The Profit is arguably the best reality show currently on television. Starring Marcus Lemonis, a Lebanese-born American entrepreneur and investor, each episode highlights an ailing businesses in desperate need of cash, care, and wisdom.

By the end,we get a remarkableview into the types of struggle, pain, glory, and redemption that occur across countless businesses every single day.

The show countersa host of false stereotypes about business, three of which I highlight in my piece. But onethat is perhaps more popular andpernicious than all is the notion that business and is necessarily driven by greed and selfishness.

On the contrary, I argue,selfishness kills and service prospers:

Each episode reminds us that, contrary to the popular Gordon Gekko caricatures, in business as in the rest of life, greed and selfishness kill and service and sacrifice prosper. The first shall be last, and so on.

Greed and selfishness are notfeaturesof economic action; they are features of human nature. Although they may at times be funneled to achieve temporary and personal gain, more often they prove damaging and poisonous to long-term economic success. In most of the panies on “The Profit,” it es clear quite quickly that greed and selfishness are primary drivers of the failure. Many of these entrepreneurs have gone to great lengths to stroke their own egos and self-affirm their illogical designs, even when all signs tell them to stop. Blind idolatry to human desire is, in fact, the most dangerous poverty trap.

WithSwanson’s Fish Market, the deal (and thus, the business) goes rapidly downhill when the owners refuse to give up their prized BMW and boat, even though they’re so financially strained that their own employees aren’t getting paid. WithWorldwide Trailers, financial losses mount each year because one owner prefers a particular house in a particular posh city that only makes sense for her and her selfish preferences. WithSkullduggery, a toy manufacturer, the owners’ arrogance and petence is embarrassingly clear, yet, even when given chance after chance, they drift back to their self-destructive habits and ideas, and in the end, even manage to exploit Lemonis for personal gain.

But although there are plenty of failures to observe, in many cases, we see these attitudes and behaviors transform for the better.

In the episode on Michael Sena’s Pro-Fit (now renamed Tina and Michael Sena’s Pro-Fit for related reasons), the owner is a self-absorbed trainer who can’t see beyond his self-image and the damage it’s doing to his business and marriage. By the end, we see a change of heart, and both are renewed in turn.Indeed, in many ways it wasthe survival of thebusiness itself that forced the change to happen when things looked bleak.

We will always confront thesestruggles and temptations, in businessas in the rest of life. It’s a battle of which we ought to be aware.But thanks to countless entrepreneurs, owners, and employees across the economic order, service and sacrifice aremuch mon than we think.

Thanks to Lemonis and CNBC, that’s a tale that’s being told.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Listening to Eastern Christianity through the ‘Melody of Faith’
Armenian Orthodox theologian Vigen Guroian’s The Melody of Faith (2010) seeks to provide an introduction to the basic dogmas of Eastern Christianity, harmonizing various Eastern Christian traditions (and making significant mention of a few Western ones) through continual reference to their writings, to their icons, and especially to their hymnody. The book, however, makes no claim to “constitute a systematic account of the Christian faith in the Germanic style of rational academic theology” (xi). Instead, Guroian muses, It may be...
How Comfy Are Faculty Lounges
In the opening scenes of the classic movie version of Thorton Wilder’s play “Our Town” the narrator tells us that the newspaper boy we are watching toss papers onto the porches nearby will go on to college — an ivy league college I recall — but is sent to Europe during WWI and dies. “All that education for nothing,” he laments. Naomi Riley has written another book about academia. The large type on the book jacket reads “The Faculty Lounges”...
Achieving Real Budget Reform
John Boehner recently stated, in the debt-ceiling talks, that “We’re going to continue and renew our efforts for a smaller, less costly and more accountable government,” which most Americans agree with in principle. However, citizens say that keeping benefits the same for the three big programs, Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid, is more important than taking steps to reduce the budget deficit by a margin of 60 pared to 32 percent for Social Security, pared to 31 percent for Medicare,...
Jayabalan on Austerity and the Italian Budget
Kishore Jayabalan, Director of Istituto Acton in Rome, was interviewed by Vatican Radio to discuss the Italian budget. Italy has a large budget crisis, and if it isn’t resolved, it may face serious financial problems similar to those experienced by Greece. Lawmakers in Italy have begun working on austerity measures, which was the topic of Jayabalan’s interview: “Austerity is fairly important for the Italian economy,” says Kishore Jayabalan, the director of the Rome office of the Acton Institute. But he...
More Comfy Lounges…
There were ments ments ments following my recent “Comfy Faculty Lounges” contribution. In the Wall Street Journal, the author of the book I was reviewing makes her own case regarding tenure and teaching versus research. “At a recent conference where I spoke on collective bargaining in higher education, one professor questioned (and others in the room also fussed about) my right to speak on the subject without—she was incredulous—a Ph.D.! I might ask why a degree in medieval literature or...
Red-Winged Menace
Grand Rapids has been the focus of national attention over the last week or so, most recently for the services surrounding the passing of former First Lady Betty Ford. In the midst of loss and mourning, there’s some cause for levity. See, for instance, this local news story that is getting some coverage around the country, “Angry bird attacks during Ford services.” I myself have been a victim of this red-winged menace! Some of you may have heard that one...
Catholic Social Teaching and the Federal Budget
Both the religious right and left have weighed in during the heated federal budget battle as Congressman Paul Ryan’s proposed budget has seen its fair share of support and criticism from many religious leaders. In a recent article appearing in Our Sunday Visitor Congressman Ryan explains how he used Catholic social doctrine to help draft his proposed budget opening up with his views on it should be utilized by politicians: Catholic social doctrine is indispensable for officeholders, but there’s a...
Class Warfare Not the American Solution to Budget Deficit
Two weeks ago, President Obama ventured courageously into the debt crisis debate with soak-the-rich proposals aimed at the usual panies,” “hedge fund managers,” “millionaires and billionaires,”—and a new enemy, “corporate jet owners.” That phrase may have tested well with focus groups, but economists and pundits weren’t duped. The imprudence of a new punitive tax on a segment of the country’s manufacturing industry was immediately mocked up and down the Twitterverse, and longer arguments have since been made. There’s also the...
Budget Hero
This is a fun, little online game from the American Public Media group called “Budget Hero.” It is described by the organization as follows: Budget Hero seeks to provide a values- and fiscal-based lens for citizens to examine policy debates during this election year. Partisan messages tend to cloud the real issues at play during campaigns, and most candidates are loath to attach detailed financial impacts to solutions which make up their platform. Budget Hero provides an interactive experience involving...
Who is My Brother’s Keeper?
Back in February 2008, then candidate for president Barack Obama addressed a crowd at a General Motors Assembly Plant in Janesville, Wis. He said, …I am my brother’s keeper; I am my sister’s keeper– that makes this country work. It’s what allows us to pursue out individual dreams, yet e together as a single American family. E pluribus Unum. Out of many, one. It is ironic that Obama preached a “we’re-in-this-together” economic philosophy yet three years later, Main Street is...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved