Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
We are not the center of the universe
We are not the center of the universe
Feb 12, 2026 4:59 AM

Review of Russ Roberts' How Adam Smith Can Change Your Life – An Unexpected Guide to Human Nature and Happiness (Portfolio, October 2014) Hardcover, 272 pages, $27.95.

Adam Smith is conventionally thought of in a very specific manner: He is the "father of economics," the man who gave birth to the very idea that self-interest is a good thing and that seeking profits was among the most socially productive endeavors a man could undertake. But what many people are unaware of is that Adam Smith was also a moral philosopher and social psychologist (and one of the greats). In fact, it was his Theory of Moral Sentiments that first brought Adam Smith to fame, not his Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations. Russ Roberts of Stanford University's Hoover Institution seeks to remind us of this in his latest book, How Adam Smith Can Change Your Life.

The book's subtitle – An Unexpected Guide to Human Nature and Happiness – hints at the two themes of this book: 1) why are humans good to each other and 2) how can we apply these insights to our own lives and be happier? The answer to the es from what Smith calls the "impartial spectator." This spectator is an imagined figure with whom we converse that exists outside of our situation and is able to accurately assess the morality of our decisions and actions. The major insight here is that we are not being judged by God or by our own principles when we act, but rather by an imagined fellow human being looking over our shoulder.

Roberts provides several contemporary examples of this to illustrate the point – when presented with an opportunity to steal something and get away with it, many of us still refuse to do so. In fact, we may wander the store in search of a cashier to pay for an item. One answer that monly given is that God is always watching and would know if you sinned against your fellow man. While true, Smith's point is that you are also watching, and you do not like stealing. As Roberts says, " … as you mitting the act, you imagine how an outsider, an impartial spectator of your crime, would react to your moral failure. You step outside yourself and view your actions through the eyes of another."

This spectator goes further than this, though. He also "speaks to us in the voice of humility, which reminds us that we are little and the world is great." We as human beings tend to believe that, because we are the center of our own universe, we must therefore be the center of the universe. Roberts calls this "The Iron Law of Me." Stated simply, I think more about myself than I do of you, or anyone else. The impartial spectator, by virtue of being a person separate from us, serves to remind us that there are other people in the world who matter just as much as we do. We are not the center of the universe.

The second theme of this book is a sort of self-help book on how to be happy. In this respect, this book is quite simply amazing. Roberts reminds us that Smith says that we all "naturally desire, not only to be loved, but to be lovely." Unpacking this simple sentence, Smith is saying that we all want to be appreciated, desired, and praised. We want people to take us seriously and pay attention to the things that we say, to want our presence, and to enjoy pany. Second, we want to be worthy of being loved honestly by "being respectable, honorable, blameless, generous, and kind." In other words, we want to have a good reputation – a good rapport, if you will. But how do we do this?

Again, we can turn to the impartial spectator. Roberts recalls the story of Bernie Madoff and his investing strategy. For years, people touted Madoff as a financial genius, but inside, Madoff knew that he was a fraud or to put it in Smithean terms, while thousands of people loved Madoff, he knew that he wasn't lovely. His inner self, the one that the impartial spectator could see clearly, did not match his outer self. The tension between our inner self and our outer self, Roberts says, transforms that undeserved love into a harsh reminder of how we have failed to be lovely.

So the answer lies in keeping our inner self in line with our outer self. This can be difficult because while we are capable of understanding our own actions better than anyone else, we are also capable of deceiving ourselves better than anyone else. Roberts moves on to discuss how best to earn love – through fame and fortune or wisdom and virtue? While many of us love the rich and famous, that love is short and fleeting. It is better, Smith says, to be loved for being wise and virtuous. In addition to being longer lasting, it is earned by being lovely to those you know well rather than zealously pursuing the love of those you do not know at all.

The impartial spectator is clearly a powerful figure and discerner of character, but where do his e from? Roberts describes Smith as saying that, at a minimum, we must behave "appropriately," which means that we must meet the expectations of those around us. In this sense, "appropriateness" is not an objectively defined set of behaviors but is instead contextual. This is not to say that there are no higher truths, but Smith seems to be concerned more with the day to day affairs of man amongst men. In this, the impartial spectator understands both your own motives and beliefs as well as the contextual standards of behavior that are unique to your current location and acts to judge you accordingly.

Roberts concludes the book with one piece of advice – love locally, trade globally. This piece of advice and understanding its implications is invaluable for everyone in today's society, and so I wholeheartedly mend this book to everyone. But I would especially mend this book to students of economics, who have a tendency to forget the limits of pure economics.

David J. Hebert teaches in the Department of Management at Ferris State University in Big Rapids, Mich.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
A French Economist in the Pampas
  The country was broke when Javier Milei took office in December 2023 as President of Argentina. He came to office with the support of more than 56 percent of voters, offering a libertarian vision of economic policy embodied in the promise of dollarizing the economy, something the majority of voters understood and appreciated.   Dollarization, however, was not the path taken...
Our Embedded Liberalism
  Scott Nelson’s review of The Roots of Liberalism might leave one to wonder whether smart people should bother to read my book. “The overly analytical reader … will search in vain for evidence of liberalism’s older intellectual tradition.” Again, I prefer “stories, anecdotes, and literature to a rigidly intellectual analysis.”   What Nelson omits to mention is that I devote one...
Democracy from the Bottom Up
  Americans fetishize voting. Granted, exercising the right seems an important act of democratic citizenship, and denial of the franchise typically accompanies the denial of a whole range of civil rights and liberties. But our focus on voting, and especially national horse-races whose conclusions result from the plebiscite, too often distracts us from the real work of citizenship, which is studious...
Why We Need Gardeners
  In modern liberal democracies, progressivism and conservatism are usually considered antagonists. Upon closer inspection, though, both names are historically and lexicographically wrong. As I argued in my last book, there is a crying need to reimagine the two casts of mind at the heart of modern politics, even if neither corresponds precisely to any major political party.   No one has...
A Prayer for Comfort When Grief Feels Overwhelming
  A Prayer for Comfort When Grief Feels Overwhelming   By Rachel Wojo   Bible Reading   Praise be to the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Father of compassion and the God of all comfort, who comforts us in all our troubles so that we can comfort those in any trouble with the comfort we ourselves receive from God. -...
The Jury Trial Right in Discrimination Cases
  For over a decade, one of the hottest fronts in the culture war has been the most unnecessary. So-called “wedding vendor cases” now include not only conscientious florists and photographers but also nuns operating parochial schools, churches running colleges, and charitable ventures facilitating adoption. The scenario always plays out the same. The service provider happily serves all people, regardless of...
Unanswered or Intentional?
  Unanswered or Intentional?   By Megan Conner   Bible Reading   “Now a man named Lazarus was sick. He was from Bethany, the village of Mary and her sister Martha… Now Jesus loved Martha and her sister and Lazarus. So when he heard that Lazarus was sick, he stayed where he was two more days… After… he went on to tell them, “Our...
Freeing State Courts from SCOTUS
  In his recent forum essay on nullification, Mark Pulliam distinguished between true nullification laws—those in which a state claims that it can refuse to obey federal laws that the state deems to be contrary to the Constitution—and laws that are merely statements of disagreement or vows of non-cooperation. This is an important distinction because the states are under no constitutional...
Be On Your Guard and Don’t Be Unfaithful
  Be On Your Guard and Don’t Be Unfaithful   By: Vivian Bricker   “‘The man who hates and divorces his wife,’ says the Lord, the God of Israel, ‘does violence to the one he should protect,’ says the Lord Almighty. So be on your guard, and do not be unfaithful”(Malachi 2:16).   Growing up, most of my friends had divorced parents. Out of...
Living Fully Known
  Weekly Overview:   We live in the reality that there is both light and darkness around us at all times. This world has both good and evil, right and wrong. As believers we must grow in both our acceptance of this reality and our pursuit of the light. We must allow God to mold and shape us into those who rid...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved