Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The Russian Revolution’s rebellion against spirit and man
The Russian Revolution’s rebellion against spirit and man
Jul 1, 2025 5:21 AM

As we reflect on the impact of the Russian Revolution on its 100th anniversary, we’re bound to hear routine admiration of its goals and ideals, even among those who duly recognize the violence and oppression that followed.

It’s mon refrain, whether made by college professors or garden-variety Bernie Sanders activists: Socialism has not been tried and found wanting; it has been found difficult and not tried. Indeed, even those who oppose such a system are plicit in this sort of thinking, arguing that “socialism would be wonderful if only it were realistically sustainable.”

But would it? The destruction munism wrought in the 20th century includes horrors that we cannot ignore. But even if do, are the underlying “ideals” all that admirable to begin with?

Would the world be all that beautiful if we were to fully imagine “equality” and “worker’s rights” through a filter of top-down materialistic power and control? Would humans be all that happy or fulfilled if we were to relish in losing our freedoms (as socialism requires) and fully embrace our lives as worker bees in an efficient hive — as “useful” cogs in a mindless machine?

Even if it “worked,” is such a fantastical world something we could actually call “utopia”?

Alas, to indulge in such fantasies not only requires a rebellion against human reason and the laws of economics. It requires a rebellion against humanity itself.

“Communism is not a beautiful ideal that was corrupted by bad people,” writes economist Art Carden. “A few minutes of reflection and serious thought reveal it as a blood-soaked attempt to snuff out the things that make us human. Socialism didn’t fail because it is an ideal of which we aren’t worthy. Socialism failed because it is internally incoherent and structurally unsound.”

If we let the lofty levelers have their way, we will inherit a world where humanity is robbed of its dignity and originality, discouraged from creativity and innovation, and restrained from the collaboration and relationship found in free and open exchange (not to mention freedom of religion, speech, press, and so on). Even if such a system were to be filled with morally superior know-it-alls and somehow achieve material prosperity, it would still be a society of serfs, submissive to their overlords’ enlightened plans for social “equity,” and thus servile in all the areas where God created us for active stewardship.

God created us in his image for specific purposes, blessed with unique gifts and capable of remarkable reflection and revelation that transpires across economic life — through creativity and innovation, yes, but propelled by the love that’s spent and lent through service and sacrifice and relationship. These are the features of humanity that ought to be leveraged, channeled, and unleashed, and it is precisely these features which socialism seeks to control, suppress, or forbid.

Authentic social harmony is impossible without them, and thus, when the planners attempt their pet subversions, we ought not be surprised when the world correspondingly turns into a cold cultural vacuum at best and a death-ridden Soviet gulag at worst.

We are constantly told munism or socialism could succeed “if only men were angels,” but such a refrain would do better to replace “angels” with “ants” or “robots” or “machines.” For whatever it is that angels do, following the materialistic demands of human despots is likely not high on their lists.

This is the reality of what the Russian Revolution and the many others like it sought to reduce us to: mere material beings, destined to be programmed and positioned according to missar-designated functions, geared and refined and maneuvered as servile engines in someone’s arbitrary vision of morally supreme equilibrium. This is not what we were made to be, and any “ideals” or “desired ends” that pretend otherwise ought to be defined accordingly — as debased and corrupt from the beginning.

We are fortunate to live in a society where human freedom is cherished and unleashed and has largely prevailed. But the resistance of the revolutions of yore still remains — against reason, against spirit, against man. Rather than romanticize these rebellions by praising them for their “idealism,” let’s romanticize the truth about human destiny, and get about embracing it.

Image: Public Domain

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Pope Francis Owes Weapons Makers an Apology
For such a humble and unassuming man, Pope Francis certainly has a gift for fabricating unnecessary controversy. Last week he released an encyclical that condemns free markets and man-made global warming. But that was rather pared to an even more controversial statement this week. As reported by Reuters, Francis said, It makes me think of … people, managers, businessmen who call themselves Christian and they manufacture weapons. That leads to a bit of distrust, doesn’t it? Unfortunately, this isn’t the...
Jean Marie’s Abundant Harvest
“For as the soil makes the e up and a garden causes seeds to grow, so the Sovereign Lord will make righteousness and praise spring up before all nations.” -Isaiah 61:11 Jean Marie owns a restaurant and farm in southern Rwanda. After his first year in business, he worked with Urwego, a local micro-finance partner with HOPE International, to secure a loan to purchase more animals and improve his land’s fertility. Today, he employs 8 people, supports 11 orphans, and...
Supreme Court: Yes, Of Course the Fifth Amendment Applies to All Property
“The Fifth Amendment applies to personal property as well as real property,” wrote Justice Roberts in a Supreme Court rulinghanded down earlier this week. “The Government has a categorical duty to pay pensation when it takes your car, just as when it takes your home.” You might be thinking, “Was that ever in doubt?” The answer is apparently yes—at least it was by the federal government since the time of FDR’s New Deal. During theNew Deal era, Congress gave the...
Doug Bandow: Laudato Si Misses the Problem of Politics
Doug Bandow, member of the Advisory Board of the Acton Institute and a Senior Fellow at the Cato Institute, discusses the problem of politics with regard to Pope Francis’ recent encyclical. In Calling on Government, Laudato Si Misses the Problem of Politics by Doug Bandow In his new encyclical, Laudato Si, Pope Francis challenges “every person living on this planet” to adopt a new “ecological spirituality.” But his economic and policy prescriptions are more controversial than his theological convictions. Indeed,...
The Pope’s Climate Confusion
In The American Spectator today, Ross Kaminsky critiques the economics behind Laudato Si’ and suggests that the pontiff’s ideas may do more harm than good. Let’s be clear: The pope is no fan of capitalism, of the rich countries of the northern hemisphere, or of economic rationality. His desire to help the poor of the world is undoubtedly sincere but his policy inclinations are so poorly informed — both in terms of science and economics — that if implemented they...
Religious Left Shareholder Activists Climb Aboard the Laudato Si Bandwagon
The release last week of Pope Francis’ Laudato Si unleashed a heaven-rending chorus of hallelujahs from the religious left. The activist shareholder investors in the choir loft, those affiliated with the Interfaith Center for Corporate Responsibility, were no exception. No sooner had the ink dried on the paper on which the encyclical’s printed than ICCR members hauled out the hyperbole. For example: Nora M Nash, OSF: Laudato Sii (Be Praised) will rise up and the cry of Mother Earth will...
The Human Side of the Greek Crisis
“With the Greek welfare state on the skids, the Church has stepped up,” says Dylan Pahman in this week’s Acton Commentary. Many Orthodox parishes have ministries to help those hit by the economic crisis, still struggling six years later. With negotiations between Greece and its “troika” creditors dragging out like a soap opera with no ending, the economic indicators aren’t providing much cause for optimism. According to Standard & Poor, as of 2014 Greece’s GDP has shrunk to 75% what...
Kishore Jayabalan reacts to the eco-encyclical on EWTN
Kishore Jayabalan, director of Istituto Acton in Rome, appeared on EWTN News Nightly last week to talk about the environmental encyclical and the pope’s emphasis on personal virtue and Christian stewardship. On Thursday, mented that the poor will actually be hurt if people consume less, highlighting the need to connect sound economics to poverty alleviation plans: And on Friday, he discussed the pontiff’s emphasis on personal responsibility and virtue, which he said sets Francis apart from most environmentalists: ...
Acton Audio & Video Roundup: Acton University and Laudato Si’
It’s been a busy week for the Acton Institute, with Pope Francis’Laudeto Si’arriving in the middle of our biggest conference event of the year, Acton University. As a result, there is a bounty of media for Acton supporters to enjoy this week. Here’s a review, in case you missed anything. Let’s start off with Acton University: All four evening keynote speeches are available for your viewing pleasure on our YouTube channel. I’ve embedded the addressdelivered last Wednesday by Gregory Thornbury,...
Fr. Michael Butler: An Orthodox Christian Perspective on Laudato Si
Fr. Michael Butler offers insight on the recent encyclical from an Orthodox Christian perspective at Acton University 2015: ...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved