Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The Problem of ‘Giving Back to the Community’
The Problem of ‘Giving Back to the Community’
Jul 30, 2026 2:07 AM

A recent ad on our munity radio station here in Boise spoke of a business sponsor’s practice of “giving back to munity.” This is done, of course, by sponsoring the radio station and other similar causes. As a fan of the station in question, I’m grateful for such local sponsors, and I’m grateful that they give to munity in that way. There is, however, a problem – not with the practice, but with the way we describe it. The phrase “giving back to munity” belies a deep misunderstanding of the nature of business.

The picture that seems to be assumed is that most of the time, through its everyday work, the business is in fact taking from munity. Then, from time to time, it chooses to “give back” to the munity. At a superficial level this language makes sense: most of the time it is customers – members of munity – who are giving money to the business, while the business is then giving money back through its charitable donations. But this misses the fact that the business – if it is successful – is always giving to munity. A profitable business, conducted with integrity, is not taking from munity at all; indeed, its profits are nothing more or less than indicators of the value that munity has received from the business.

This is more than a technical matter. Business is a means by which we do good for others: not merely by making money and then giving some of that money away, but by the very conduct of the business itself. Business gives: by organizing the labor of others and thereby making it more productive, by seeking out the desires of munity, by meeting those desires through creativity and effort. And this is a deeply spiritual matter. Business is a vocation, a calling from God, by which we serve and benefit munity in which we live.

So, I’m grateful for the local pany that is supporting munity radio station. But they’re not giving back to munity something they had previously taken. To say so is to denigrate the true nature of the business vocation. Rather, they are giving even more, giving beyond what they have already given through their productive contribution to munity in the industry.

Nick Smith is an alumnus of several Acton programs and lives with his wife and four children in beautiful southern Idaho, where he serves as pastor of the United Reformed Church of Nampa.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Rev. Sirico: Pope’s Trip To U.S. As Pastor, Not Policy Wonk
Just weeks before Pope Francis sets foot on U.S. soil, he’s all ready a sell-out in many places he’ll be visiting. And the media is trying to get a handle on just what the pontiff will be talking about while he’s here. In The Detroit News today, Melissa Nann Burke talks to some Washington insiders, regarding the pope’s time there. Guests of Michigan’s 16-member delegation for the Sept. 24 address include Paul Long, head of the Michigan Catholic Conference; Martin...
These Prisoners Are Finding Purpose Through Welding (And So Could You)
With the rise of the information economy, many millennials have steered clear from blue-collar jobs and manual labor, often prodded by their parents to pursue a “real education” and “a better life. As folks like Mike Rowe have only begun to highlight, such attitudes have led to a serious skills gap in the trades, one thatappears to hold steadyeven in the face of record unemployment. Yet despite these cultural shifts, such work does indeed provide significant value to the economy...
Cultural Task #1: Crucify Our Incipient Darwinism
One of the long-running mistakes of the church has been its various confinements of cultural engagement to particular spheres (e.g. churchplace ministry) or selective “uses” (e.g. evangelistic conversion). But even if we manage to broaden the scope of our stewardship — recognizing that God has called us to pursue truth, goodness, and beauty across all spheres of creation — our imaginations will still require a strong injection of the transformative power of Jesus. When we seek God first and neighbor...
Free ebook: ‘On Christians and Prosperity’
Acton’s latest monograph, On Christians and Prosperity by Rev. James V. Schall will be free as an eBook until midnight on Thursday. To download your free copy, visit . In this work, Schalldiscusses poverty and economic prosperity, including the Christian calling to contribute to human flourishing and care for the poor. To get a glimpse of what this monograph is all about, you can read the Acton Commentaries, “How do we help the poor?” and “The moral dimension of work”...
Creative Destruction as an Anti-Casino
In 1942, economist Joseph Schumpeter coined the term “creative destruction” for the process of incessant product and process innovation mechanism by which new production units (jobs, businesses, industries) replace outdated ones. Schumpeter said this process was the “essential fact about capitalism.” This essential fact is also one of the essential reasons people oppose capitalism. Creative destruction sounds wonderful when it’s replacing things like rotary phones with iPhones and typewriters with puters. Unless, that is, you’re in business of making typewriters...
How Misunderstanding the Role of the Supreme Court Erodes Liberty
How did the framers of the Constitution seek to preserve liberty and protect against tyranny? Many Americans would say that to protect the individual and minorities against the tyranny of the majority, the Founding Fathers added the Bill of Rights and gave the power to enforce those rights to the Supreme Court. But as Robert George, professor of jurisprudence at Princeton University, explains, that answer is wrong—dangerously wrong—and has led to an overall reduction in freedom. ...
The Francis-Trump Populist Nexus
Populism makes for strange bedfellows, says Kishore Jayabalan in this week’s Acton Commentary. “Take Pope Francis and Donald Trump, for instance. They are certainly populists of very different sorts, but there is one issue that unites them – both are harsh critics of economic globalization.” Francis does explicitly and by name what Trump does implicitly and in practice. In fact, they seem to derive much of their popularity precisely because they attack free markets as an enemy of the people....
Laudato: ¿Si or no?
Since the publication of the encyclical Laudato Si by Francis, a long-unheard rumble has been growing across the world public opinion. He is an expert in making himself heard, so we might as well rest it as it is, because Francis would be pleased. Our readers, however, are used to our fixing troubles, so we will once again meet the subjective claim of the market. The Laudato Si embraces three aspects: a theological aspect, an economic aspect, and a scientific...
On the Ten Commandments and the United States
The Supreme Court of the state of Oklahoma has approved to bring down the Ten-Commandment monument. Such decision entails an opportunity for us to ponder once again on the relation between Christianity and classical Liberalism. We have repeatedly claimed that individual rights from the Anglo-Saxon tradition are of a Judeo-Christian, origin and that due to this, the US Declaration of Independence is fully coherent when asserting that God has endowed all men with the certain unalienable rights, among these are...
7 Figures: The Changing Geography of Poverty
A new Pew Research Center analysis of U.S. Census Bureau data shows how the geographic distribution of the poor has changed since the “war on poverty” began in 1960. Here are 7 figures you should know from the report: 1. The nation’s official poverty rate has declined over the past half-century, from 22.1 percent in 1960 to 14.5 percent in 2013. 2. In 1960, half (49 percent) of impoverished Americans lived in the South. By 2010, that share had dropped...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved