Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The Problem of ‘Giving Back to the Community’
The Problem of ‘Giving Back to the Community’
Oct 17, 2026 2:25 AM

A recent ad on our munity radio station here in Boise spoke of a business sponsor’s practice of “giving back to munity.” This is done, of course, by sponsoring the radio station and other similar causes. As a fan of the station in question, I’m grateful for such local sponsors, and I’m grateful that they give to munity in that way. There is, however, a problem – not with the practice, but with the way we describe it. The phrase “giving back to munity” belies a deep misunderstanding of the nature of business.

The picture that seems to be assumed is that most of the time, through its everyday work, the business is in fact taking from munity. Then, from time to time, it chooses to “give back” to the munity. At a superficial level this language makes sense: most of the time it is customers – members of munity – who are giving money to the business, while the business is then giving money back through its charitable donations. But this misses the fact that the business – if it is successful – is always giving to munity. A profitable business, conducted with integrity, is not taking from munity at all; indeed, its profits are nothing more or less than indicators of the value that munity has received from the business.

This is more than a technical matter. Business is a means by which we do good for others: not merely by making money and then giving some of that money away, but by the very conduct of the business itself. Business gives: by organizing the labor of others and thereby making it more productive, by seeking out the desires of munity, by meeting those desires through creativity and effort. And this is a deeply spiritual matter. Business is a vocation, a calling from God, by which we serve and benefit munity in which we live.

So, I’m grateful for the local pany that is supporting munity radio station. But they’re not giving back to munity something they had previously taken. To say so is to denigrate the true nature of the business vocation. Rather, they are giving even more, giving beyond what they have already given through their productive contribution to munity in the industry.

Nick Smith is an alumnus of several Acton programs and lives with his wife and four children in beautiful southern Idaho, where he serves as pastor of the United Reformed Church of Nampa.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Books offer stability, renewal of American ideals
The written word serves as a landmark set by our forefathers. Being in the presence of books both old and rare has a way of making us look at them with fresh eyes. Read More… Long after we’ve all passed on, how will future generations remember us? One answer: books. Certainlythere will be landmarks and buildings and other memorabilia that help our descendants understand our society as it exists today, along with the people who helped shape it. But there...
University of Hong Kong demands Tiananmen Square Massacre memorial statue be forcibly removed from campus grounds
The Pillar of Shame has stood as a memorial to the lives lost during the Tiananmen Square Massacre for 24 years. Its removal is another sign that the Hong Kong government will not tolerate dissent even in the form of memory. Read More… The University of Hong Kong requested that members of a prominent but now-disbanded social rights group remove from campus grounds its famous statue, the Pillar of Shame, which pays tribute to victims in Beijing’s violent crackdown during...
God doesn’t need your good works (but your neighbor does)
What can the “great theologian of vocation” teach us about the meaning of calling in an individualistic age? Read More… In modern America, our view of vocation has e increasingly narrow and individualistic, focused only on economic action and our own preferred paths to self-actualization. As David Brooks explains in his book The Road to Character, vocation is now mostly imagined as a journey of self-discovery and wish fulfillment, a way to satisfy inner longings so we can put up...
Free trade with China is still good for us all
Despite pushback from both left and right, free markets should always be supported, because they free people to live out their potential—even in despotic regimes like China’s. Read More… Doug Irwin in his seminal book Free Trade Under Fire points out that Democrats and Republicans have historically vacillated on free trade. The Democratic Party of the late 19th century up until World War II was the party of trade liberalization when Republicans consistently voted for high tariffs. From the 1950s...
Rising to the challenges of ‘so-so automation’
If we assume a chaos narrative, humans have little hope peting with our petitors. But through the lens of God’s creative design, humans e protagonists in a bigger, more mysterious story of economic abundance. Read More… Fears about job loss and human obsolescence continue to consume the cultural pounded by ongoing strides in artificial intelligence and machine learning. The job-killing robots are almost at the door, we are told, mere moments away from replacing the last traces of human inefficiency...
Six former Next Digital employees to be tried in Hong Kong High Court to face possible life sentences
Moving the cases of six senior Next Digital employees to the High Court is another signal that the Hong Kong government will seek ultimate punishment for any journalist or business it deems in violation of its extreme, anti-freedom National Security Law. Read More… The deliberate shredding of Hong Kong’s democratic ideals continues as the case against six former employees of Next Digital and its subsidiary Apple Daily is to be transferred to the Hong Kong High Court, where guilty verdicts...
Hold internet companies responsible for content on their platforms, not just the government
The alternative to holding panies like Facebook liable for third-party content on their sites is a regulatory machine that poses a far greater threat to free speech than self-monitoring. Read More… Frances Haugen’s recent whistleblower testimony regarding Facebook will only stoke the fires of the battle heating up in courts and legislatures over provisions originally addressed in Rule 230 of the Communications Decency Act. Limits placed by private panies on individuals and organizations have raised an alarm on both ends...
Civil rights leader pleads not guilty to charges related to Tiananmen Square Massacre vigil
Even the memory of the massacre has e a threat to Hong Kong and Chinese authorities, as they crack down on mass attendance at public vigils. Read More… The former vice chair of a now-disbanded civil rights group,​​ the Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China, which also organizes the annual Tiananmen Square vigil, pleaded not guilty to charges of inciting others to take part in this year’s banned vigil. Chow Hang-tung, representing herself, appeared in...
Next Digital headquarters raided by Hong Kong government
pany Next Digital has had its financial records seized in Hong Kong’s latest move to stifle an independent press and pro-democracy activism Read More… Clement Chan Kam-wing, an inspector appointed by the Hong Kong government, raided the headquarters of Next Digital pany in a search and seizure of financial records on Sept. 28 as part of an investigation into pany. The raid came a day after the Hong Kong Eastern Magistrate authorized a search warrant of Next Digital on suspicion...
Hong Kong government petitions to dissolve Next Digital Media Group
The dissolution of Next Digital is a devastating blow to freedom of the press and pro-democracy activism in Hong Kong Read More… On Sept. 29, the Hong Kong government, led by financial secretary Paul Chan Mo-po, petitioned the court of First Instance to push for the folding of Next Digital Media Group. Although the power to liquidate the 40-year-old firm is already granted by the Companies Ordinance, Chan argued that shutting the doors of the pany is also in the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved