Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Social media make us JUMP to false conclusions
Social media make us JUMP to false conclusions
Apr 29, 2026 1:19 PM

Mike Solana, the vice president of the Founders Fund, has written pelling account of the social consequences of the dominance of social media as a means munication in this digital age titled, “JUMP.” The title is based on a schoolyard legend from his youth: “Back in elementary school a ‘scientific theory’ hit the playground that blew my mind: [I]f every person in China jumped at the same time, their impact would knock our planet off its axis and the world would end.”

Solana notes that such a scheme was merely a flight of youthful fancy when he first heard it, but now new technologies have emerged to make such an apocalyptic coordination possible:

Today, almost half the global population is connected to the internet by the puting smartphones that live in our pocket. That’s 3.5 billion people … Ubiquitous mobile internet dramatically increased our immersion in media, but ubiquitoussocial mediadramatically increased the speed at which ideas travel and, perhaps more significantly, deeply socialized the dynamic.

Information, disinformation, and narratives now spread globally between billions of people at the push of a button. Solana observes this did indeed occur, for good or for ill, with the COVID-19 pandemic:

There are two reads on how we reacted to the pandemic. First, thank God for the internet. We acted rapidly, shut the world down, and saved tens of millions of lives. In 1918, when the Spanish flu emerged, the speed at which we shut down civilization was not even possible throughout most of the densely populated, undeveloped world. But a hundred years ago, even across the United States and Europe, information was far more difficult to catalogue, to track, and to share. People were cautious. Millions died. The second read on our reaction to COVID-19 is we should never have shut the world down. We didn’t understand the virus, and we still don’t. Now our economy teeters on the brink of global depression, which may itself precede any number of horrors from famine to war. Hundreds of millions could die. The question of how we should have acted, and how we should act for some future, hypothetical pandemic, will undoubtedly consume pundits for years. But neither frame on global paralysis is nearly as important as the fact that it was possible. An idea is now capable of almost immediately crippling the world. There is only one question that should be consuming us today:

What else is possible?

We are now beginning to learn what else is possible with widespread civic unrest in the United States, fueled by videos and rumors circulated over social media. Narratives have emerged about very real problems of policing in the United States entirely unmoored from the actual experience of the vast majority of police and citizens alike. America’s sordid history of slavery and racial conflict has been weaponized into a narrative rewriting America’s founding in the pages of the New York Times and turned into readily sharable social media “content.” The sharing of private correspondence on social media has led to a staff revolt at the New York Times and the disintegration of the board of the National Book Critics Circle.

As Solana points out, this is a recipe not merely for potential end-of-the-world apocalyptic disaster but a steady stream of more chronic local and national disasters:

Short of any kind of truly global, meme-induced disaster, there is the potential for as many personal- or national-scale disasters as can be imagined. The danger, at every scale, is large numbers of people acting rapidly and emotionally on information they just received. The information will almost certainly, by the very nature of new information, be plete or inaccurate. Individuals are now routinely targeted by massive, online mobs, sometimes millions strong, after doctored or plete information is shared with the malicious intent of evoking such reaction.

How do we act responsibly in this context? We must begin by turning to the study of the scriptures and the study of ourselves as the Apostle James counsels:

Where do the conflicts and wheredo the quarrels among e from? Is it not from this, from your passions that battle inside you?You desire and you do not have; you murder and envy and you cannot obtain; you quarrel and fight. You do not have because you do not ask;you ask and do not receive because you ask wrongly, so you can spend it on your passions (James 4:1-3).

We must battle the technology-fueled crises of our time with the ancient piety and technique bequeathed to us by our religious traditions. To emerge from this crisis of institutions and government, we must first govern ourselves.

Crider. CC BY 2.0.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
More Health Care Reform
Since it appears the health care reform debate isn’t going away any time soon (and, just maybe, has moved in a positive direction from where it started several months ago–e.g., one of the most dangerous proposals, the public option, is itself in danger), we’ll keep pressing the issue. Two recent articles of interest: David Goldhill in The Atlantic. Outstanding exposition of the dysfunctions of American health care and which policies will ameliorate rather than exacerbate them. It’s imperative that we...
The Parched Wilderness of Socialized Medicine
Published today on the Web site of the American Enterprise Institute: Some numbers are highly significant in the Bible. The Israelites, for example, wandered in the desert for 40 years. Moses spent 40 days on Mount Sinai when he received the Law. Jesus went into the wilderness for 40 days and nights. These are periods often associated with probation, trial, or even chastisement before the Lord. Now we have “40 Days for Health Reform,” a massive effort by the Religious...
Book Review: How to Argue Like Jesus
I recently finished How to Argue Like Jesus (Crossway, 2009) by Joe Carter (The Evangelical Outpost, First Thoughts) and John Coleman. I would have loved to have had this book to assign during the 13 years I taught position and rhetoric. So many of my fellow evangelicals think rhetoric is a dirty word, as in “That’s just a bunch of rhetoric.” But as this primer makes clear, Jesus was a master of rhetoric, a master of principled persuasion. Happily, How...
Prioritized Giving
There’s more evidence that amidst the economic downturn people are ing more careful and intentional about the kinds of charities they fund. We’ve seen that those likely to continue to flourish are those that have cultivated a “family-like” connection with their donors. Often more local charities do well in this kind of climate. And, of course, the focus of the charity matters, too. Robert J. Samuelson reports (HT: Theolog) that charitable giving was down $308 billion in 2008, and will...
A Public Choice Primer
Amity Shlaes, a senior fellow in economic history at the Council on Foreign Relations, has an excellent primer on public choice in the August 3 edition of Forbes, “The New PC.” Shlaes is also the author of the 2007 book, The Forgotten Man: A New History of the Great Depression. Shlaes, who will be featured in the ing issue of Religion & Liberty, writes, “Government reformers view themselves as morally superior, but that is an illusion. They are just like...
Patients and Doctors
In an Acton Commentary this week, I argue that a critical piece of prehensive and meaningful reform of the health care system must include malpractice litigation (tort) reform. Part of what makes this so urgent is that the litigious climate in which we live has eroded the doctor-patient relationship. In “Patients and Doctors: Partners not Adversaries,” I write that “patients are less inclined to trust doctors whom they believe are ordering tests and procedures out of a desire to protect...
Jaffa on How Marx May Win After All
This from a new mon Knowledge interview with Harry Jaffa: The society of the future is one in which the moral distinction that is based upon the Judeo-Christian and Greek traditions will dissolve. We are moving into a Communist world; we are moving into the world that Marx wanted without knowing it and without having the kind of revolution that Marx predicted and thought was necessary. For example, the President always talks about our values. What does [President Obama] mean...
The Future of Photojournalism
NPR profiles 'Afghan Girl' (1984) photographer Steve McCurry: 'McCurry's work has been featured in nearly every major magazine around the world, and he is undoubtedly one of the best living photographers in his field.'We’ve done a lot of thinking here at the PowerBlog on the future of journalism in a digital age. A recent piece in Forbes by Leo Gomez brings into focus (ahem) the question of digital innovation and it’s influence on photojournalism. In his August 24 “Digital Tools”...
Acton Commentary: Imagine You Are a Doctor
Hunter Baker examines the push for the “public option” — the creation of a government backed insurance system — as part of health care reform in mentary. Baker takes an interesting approach at examining the push for a public option by dropping his readers into the life of a doctor, articulating the stress and sacrifice of the job: Imagine that you are a physician. You have made it through four years of college on a steady diet of biology, chemistry,...
Acton Commentary: The New Mortgage Fraud — Kick ’Em When They’re Down
The mortgage fraudsters are back, but this time they’re preying on people struggling to keep their homes out of foreclosure. In mentary, Kelsey VanOverloop looks at how the “Foreclosure e-on works and what homeowners can do to avoid the serious consequences of dealing with an unethical lender. VanOverloop describes the fraudulent schemes: Today’s mortgage fraudster preys on the vulnerable, those who have run out of options and are desperate for help. They seek out people known to have fallen on...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved