Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Shoeing Horses in Detroit: How Unions Are Hindering A City’s Revival
Shoeing Horses in Detroit: How Unions Are Hindering A City’s Revival
Jul 29, 2026 7:54 PM

Anyone who’s been to Detroit in recent years knows it’s a mess. Acres and acres of abandoned houses, a population decline of 25% in the past 10 years, an astronomical crime rate, and the city is literally leaking money to the tune of some $200 million in two months. Back in March, Gov. Rick Snyder appointed bankruptcy attorney Kevyn Orr as the city’s emergency financial manager, and Orr has just released his report on the city’s financial state.

Before we begin weeping about the death of the Motor City, there are bright spots. Fast Company did a piece in April highlighting entrepreneurs who are taking advantage of low-rent and housing prices and the need for creative work to boost Detroit’s economy. Dan Gilbert is a real estate broker working on filling office space downtown. Andy Didorosi has created a bus service that takes patrons from night-spot to night-spot in safe, fun fortable buses. Alicia George has opened a coffee house, and is optimistic that several new businesses have opened near-by.

Now for the bad news. The city of Detroit is paying a farrier (that’s a person who shoes horses) $56,000 in pay and benefits. Right now, in 2013. Let’s just say that he’s not really earning his pay in today’s downtown Detroit. The Detroit Water & Sewer Department is telling the cash-strapped city they need more employees – union employees. And the city’s unionized teachers? They want to cash in unused sick days for over $14 million.

An independent report said four out of five employees in the bloated department were redundant and discovered a thicket of union regulations driving up costs. plainedthat, due to union work rules, they had to wait to fix pipes until duly authorized “operators” came along first to shut them off.

The Detroit Federation of Teachers, which enjoys rich pay packages (corrected for purchasing power, Michigan teachers are the best paid in the nation, reported the Mackinac Center for Policy Policy), would do the UAW proud. Its employees pay only ten percent of the cost of their insurance premiums. While they take extravagant numbers of sick days or personal days — 8 per teacher — they also cash in on “unused sick days” to the tune of $14.5 million a year….

From 2008 to 2011, health insurance costs for Detroit employees and retirees have jumped 62% to $186 million a year, the Detroit Free Press reported. Pension contributions in that period jumped 140 percent, from $50 million to $120 million.

To fight for their pensation, unions have proven prepared to fight back with any weapon at hand. Appointing emergency financial managers is “just like being in the slave plained Iris Salters, the president of the Michigan Education Association.

Fast food workers are on strike as well, many demanding via a wildcat strike a pay raise to $15 per hour and union representation.

There are a number of things going on here. First, Detroit’s political culture of backroom deals, corruption and crime has to stop. If the city is going to survive, those who serve in leadership positions must be above board regarding everything they do.

Second, the Motor City has to realize it isn’t the Motor City anymore. The auto industry is diversified and no longer localized in Detroit and its suburbs. No one is getting a job out of high school to work “on the line”, figuring they’ll make a healthy living and raise a family on that salary anymore.

Third, the unions have to give in. There isn’t any more money for their demands. Yes, joining a union should be a person’s choice. Yes, unions have a history of protecting workers’ rights. Yes, unions have been a big part of Detroit’s success in the past. Now, they are a stumbling block and they are costing the city too much for too little.

Finally, Detroit needs to see itself as an entrepreneurial playground. There is always opportunity for human creativity and flourishing. Detroit is not a loss. In fact, it can be a shining example of how a city e back after financial catastrophe, if people are allowed the freedom to create businesses, assured that their city will protect their property and that customers will feel safe when patronizing them.

Detroit needs start looking to the free market model of rule of law, opportunity, creativity and sensible planning. Detroit needs to stop shoeing horses.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Farm Subsidies: Sustaining Dependency
Are farmers hooked on pork? Jordan Ballor and Ray Nothstine look at the current battle over farm subsidies. “By encouraging the production of modities, the government is creating a cycle of dependency that undermines entrepreneurial initiative,” they write. Read the mentary here. ...
Stay Green – Stay Married
Via ABC News: In the United States, they found that divorced households spent 46 percent more per capita on electricity and 56 percent more on water than married households did. According to the study, if divorced households could have the same resource efficiency as their married counterparts, they would need 38 million fewer rooms, use 73 billion fewer kilowatt hours of electricity and 627 billion gallons of water in 2005 alone. More: But Raoul Felder, a prominent New York divorce...
Books of Interest: Ashgate and Crossway
I’ve had a number of new book catalogs cross my desk over the last few months. Given the gift-giving season that is upon us, I thought I’d highlight some of the more interesting items from the various publishers. If you share my varied and rather eclectic interests, ranging from scholarly to popular works on a number of subjects, you might find something here you could add to your own Christmas list (although some items are ing for 2008). Today’s post...
Morse on Divorce
Not to belabor the topic of divorce (following Don Bosch’s interesting post from yesterday), but Acton senior fellow Jennifer Roback Morse has a thought-provoking piece on on the perverse incentives of marriage law. She makes several important points, but I am most intrigued by her suggestion that the frequency of bined with the peculiarities of the legal system designed to handle it, has created one of the most invasive areas of American law. The discussion recalls Dr. Morse’s earlier book...
Rev. Sirico on the Romney Speech
The following is a statement by Rev. Robert A. Sirico, president of the Acton Institute, on Mitt Romney’s Dec. 6 “Faith in America” speech: Mitt Romney is right that religion and morality are core convictions in American society. Our freedom depends on this, pletely agree. Without the ability to manage our lives morally, the state steps into the vacuum, both in response to public demand and to serve the state’s own interests in expanding power. But soon after spelling this...
Global Warming Consensus Alert – Parking Crisis!
Add another crisis to the list of problems caused by climate change – a lack of jet parking at small international airports. To be fair, this isn’t a direct consequence of climate change, but it wouldn’t be a problem in Bali, Indonesia right now if not for the big UN climate change shindig that’s going on. Via Newsbusters, a report on the urgent situation: Tempo Interaktif reports that Angkasa Pura – the management of Bali’s Ngurah Rai International Airport are...
What Latin Americans Want
What’s behind the stunning defeat of Venezuela’s President Hugo Chavez in a popular referendum this week? Undoubtedly, he overestimated the appeal of his “21st century socialism” among Latin Americans. A new poll also shows that the most trusted institution in Latin America is not the government — but the Catholic Church. Read the mentary here. ...
A New Credo for the Religious Left
The Institute on Religion and Democracy has issued a background report on the drafting of a new “Social Creed for the 21st Century” by members of the National Council of Churches. As Alan Wisdom and Ralph Webb point out, the “strong ideological tilt” at the NCC (that would be to your left) “contrasts sharply with the careful efforts at balance evident in public policy guidelines produced by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops and the National Association of Evangelicals.” What...
Criminalizing Thought
For those of us who cherish liberty and the freedom we enjoy in the west to engage in spirited debate, stories like this are very disturbing: Up north, the Canadian Islamic Congress announced the other day that at least two of Canada’s “Human Rights Commissions” – one federal, one provincial – had agreed to hear plaints that their “human rights” had been breached by this “flagrantly Islamophobic” excerpt from my book, as published in the country’s bestselling news magazine, Maclean’s....
UPDATED: Mitt Romney — Reassuring Evangelical Voters?
Presidential candidate Mitt Romney is expected to address the topic of his Mormon faith in a speech at the George Bush Library in College Station, Texas, tomorrow. The parisons are being made to President John F. Kennedy, a Roman Catholic, who gave a speech in 1960 to assuage the concerns of American protestants over papal influence in the White House. Kennedy’s speech to the Greater Houston Ministerial Association can be found here. In addition, there is also a link for...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved