Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Religious Left’s GMO Antagonism
Religious Left’s GMO Antagonism
Oct 27, 2026 2:53 AM

In Wednesday’s Wall Street Journal, Matthew Dalton reported that the European Union likely will approve a genetically modified organism for only the second time in the past 15 years. The EU is poised to grant E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company permission to grow 1507, a DuPont-developed GMO corn.

DuPont first sought approval in 2001 for 1507 … After positive safety reviews and several decisions by the European Court of Justice criticizing the European Commission for delaying its decision, mission is now close to approving the crop…

The crop ‘meets all EU regulatory requirements and should be approved for cultivation without further delay,’ DuPont said.

1507 corn is resistant to the corn-borer worm, which has been known to devastate crops. Dalton writes that opposition to 1507 and, indeed, all GMOs runs strong throughout the EU. This resistance is echoed in the United States as well. The Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility, for example, has issued repeated shareholder resolutions to DuPont, Abbott Laboratories and other panies that would require panies to label GMOs. The ICCR’s “2014 Proxy Resolutions and Voting Guide” states:

Since 2000, members of ICCR have argued on behalf of consumers’ right to know what’s in the foods they eat, including whether or not those foods are genetically modified. Urging the precautionary principle, they caution against allowing potentially hazardous material into the food supply and support voluntary labeling of GMO ingredients. Because there has yet been no national mandate that GM foods be labeled in the U.S., most Americans have been unknowningly eating them for years.

The above paragraph conflates two separate issues. The first is labeling food derived from GMOs, and the second misleads readers to conclude GMOs are “potentially hazardous material” requiring the exercise of the precautionary principle. As noted by this writer in a previous post, panies to further label foods presents additional costs, which negatively impacts costs to consumers and shareholders. Additionally, GMO labeling frightens uninformed consumers who may forego the purchase of any products so labeled – thereby forcing them to buy more expensive nutrition for their families or, worse, do without the sustenance altogether.

Nowhere in the ICCR’s guide is scientific evidence to support GMO fear mongering, which makes the following assertion a real head scratcher:

ICCR members filed a resolution with Abbott Laboratories asking pany to identify and label genetically engineered crops and organisms in all its products unless long-term safety testing shows that they are not harmful to humans, animals, and the environments.

That’s a mighty tall – if not impossible – order. In the meantime, the religious members of ICCR burnish their credentials as antagonists of corporate America as well as the world’s hungriest people least able to afford non-GMO foodstuffs.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
New Acton commentaries this week
In his mentary, Anthony Bradley tells us that there is a “serious disconnect” in the hip munity that allows rappers to evoke the name of God in thanks while producing music that celebrates evil. Could there be a connection to the declining rate of church attendance in the munity and a shift toward a more “deistic” understanding of Christianity? Based on a new study released by Radio One and Yankelovich, a Chapel Hill-based research firm Dr. Bradley elaborates: The new...
Round-Up: Obama and the faith-based initiative
Here’s a round-up of early reaction (to be updated as appropriate) to Obama’s speech about his proposed future for the faith-based initiative under his administration. Rev. Richard Cizik of the NAE (HT): “Mr. Obama’s position that religious organizations would not be able to consider religion in their hiring for such programs would constitute a deal-breaker for many evangelicals, said several evangelical leaders, who represent a political constituency Mr. Obama has been trying to court. ‘For those of who us who...
The devil is in the details
Research: Wind power pricier, emits more CO2 than thought. ...
And more details…
A follow-up to Marc’s post concerning the feasibility of wind power: The pany here recently conducted an 18-month study on the potential of residential-based wind and solar power under local conditions. Their finding was that the wind turbine failed to meet expectations, the solar panels performed as expected, but neither provided a cost-benefit ration that makes it pelling alternative for most energy consumers. Personally I think there is promise in renewable energy, residentially produced or otherwise, but studies such as...
Acton Institute announces finalists for the Samaritan Award
The 10 finalists for the Samaritan Award were announced last Thursday. This annual award was created by the Acton Institute to honor a highly successful, privately funded charity whose work is direct, personal, and accountable. The finalists for 2008 are: – Citizens for Community Values, A Way Out Program, Memphis, Tenn. – Fresno Rescue Mission, The Academy, Fresno, Calif. – Guardian Angels Homes, Faith in Action, Grand Rapids, Mich. – Lighthouse Ministries, One Stop Care, Lakeland, Fla. – Panama City...
Barack Obama and faith-based initiatives
Barack Obama recently announced that he wishes to expand President Bush’s program of public funding for religious charities. In his latest piece for National Review Online Rev. Robert A. Sirico, president of the Acton Institute, warns us of some of the dangers of federal funding for faith-based charities. Rev. Sirico writes: The lesson of this long history is that if you want to do religiously motivated work in the United States, it is best to do it on your own...
The annotated inbox
A round-up of diverse items of interest, in no particular order: “Iraq to open consulate in San Diego,” (and Detroit). Facing difficulties in reaching the populations of Iraqis in the US, Iraq is planning to open consulates in San Diego and Detroit. “The Bush administration set a goal of admitting 12,000 Iraqi refugees this year.” This rather meager es years after the invasion and after hundreds of thousands of Iraqis have had to flee to other countries for safety. Too...
Review: Civilization IV
It took awhile, but after its release in 2005, the latest installment of the puter game Civilization IV was received warmly by many mentators. Civilization IV, or CivIV for short, was hailed alternatively as “a video game for the ages,” and “a kind of social-sciences chessboard that blends history and logic into a game that demands a long, long attention span.” The basis for much of this regard among even conservatives as “crunchy” as Rod Dreher was a piece in...
Another problem with using corn ethanol as fuel?
The Acton Institute was out in front on the warnings of all the problems associated with using corn ethanol as a fuel source. My article “The Unintended Consequences of the Ethanol Quick Fix” was published in The Christian Science Monitor last July. The United Methodist General Board of Church and Society has uncovered a new problem with corn ethanol. According to the GBCS corn is sacred to indigenous people, thus not appropriate for being used as an energy source. Could...
CRC Sea to Sea tour week 1
The first week of the CRC’s Sea to Sea bike tour is in the books. The first leg of the journey took the bikers from Seattle to Kennewick, a total distance of 319 miles. The first day’s devotional, “Shifting Gears,” sets the stage for the entire trip. Alluding to the biblical exodus of the Israelites from Egypt, we read that God’s people “had to learn dependence instead of independence, freedom instead of slavery, and obedience instead of rebellion.” These are...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved