Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
Private Property and Public Good
Private Property and Public Good
Aug 18, 2025 5:40 AM

From the beginning of human history, humans have exercised dominion over the material world. ponents of nature (other than persons themselves) are resources that can be rightly used, and in some instances used up, for the benefit of persons. Through their use of things, people cause much of the material world to e property: that is, material morally tied in a special way to a particular person or persons.

However, the human dominion over the subhuman world is more basic than property. This does not mean, however, that things should be owned mon. The point of associations and mon enterprises is the flourishing of each of its individual members—that is what constitutes the flourishing of the group. Moreover, if people are to flourish, then they need to make choices and to act. This includes their choices and actions concerning the use of things. For this reason, in those fields of human activity where individuals or groups can facilitate human flourishing through the private possession and use of things, then it is just for them to do so. This includes economic activity.

The question of how earth's resources are to be used for the benefit of all is left to people to work out rationally together. The principle mon use means that any arrangement of the possession of things by individuals is to be seen as a means of mon use. For this reason, in using those goods people should consider the exterior things that they legitimately possess not only as their own, but mon in the sense that their possessions should benefit not only themselves but others as well. We can say, then, that any person's earthly good is his in the sense that he owns it, but not in the sense that he alone may use it; for insofar as he does not need it to satisfy his own needs, others should be able to use it to satisfy theirs.

Private ownership of property is the normative means by which the principle mon use is realized. For one thing, private property is essential for the development of self-reliance. Secondly, private property helps us express and develop our personalities. When we own things, we can choose to use them to express our concern for others, be it by giving people gifts or by investing in productive, job-creating industries. Thirdly, private ownership or the prospect of private ownership creates incentives for people to contribute in a wider way to the society around them. It encourages people to work, to be entrepreneurial, and to create wealth for themselves and others. Lastly, private property allows people to give direct expression of their genuine responsibility for themselves and for others.

To these moral justifications for private property, we may add the three reasons given by Aquinas to explain why appropriation of property to particular owners is morally licit and even necessary. First, individuals tend to shirk responsibilities that are nobody's in particular, and people tend to take better care of what is theirs than of what mon to everyone. Second, if everyone were responsible for everything, the result would be confusion. Third, dividing things up generally produces a more peaceful state of affairs, whilst mon things often results in tension. Individual ownership—understood as the power to manage and dispose of things—is then justified.

Aquinas did, however, insist that the use of things is a different matter. In regard to use, one is not justified in holding things as exclusively one's own ( ut proprias ) but should rather hold them mon, in the sense that, after one has satisfied one's own needs and those of one's families, one ought to use the surplus in ways that benefit others.

Sometimes this can mean literally giving something we own to people in need, the use of which results in the consumption of the good. But to share the use of one's goods with others does not necessarily presuppose that the giver discontinues his own use or ownership of that good. A person's use of his house, for example, to shelter someone in need may not actually be a case of assisting with his superfluous goods. Rather, this is an instance of a person sharing a good essential for one's own well being without giving up one's ownership of the good.

Of course, there are virtually no individuals who, having satisfied their basic needs, bury their extra wealth in the ground. Invariably, they choose to invest it. This investment is sometimes in businesses that employ people and create more wealth, which is then further invested. Sometimes it is in banks, which give others access to the capital resources they need as the material basis for their own flourishing.

To this extent, banks are one of those associations that allow people to judiciously fulfill their obligations to use their surplus wealth for mon good and thus, the flourishing of other people. As noted by Antoine de Salins and François Villeroy de Galhau, “the savings of some are used to finance the investment needs of others, in the hope that this financial circuit will play its part in attaining an optimal financial growth.”

This article was excerpted from the ing monograph Banking, Justice, and the Common Good by Samuel Gregg. It can be ordered from the Acton Institute online at acton.org.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
The Age of Trivial Panic
  America seems to be buffeted by a host of existential crises. For starters, there is the (always) looming specter of climate change, the dramatic loss of an industrial base and uncertain transition to a digital economy, mass migration prompted by warfare and failed states, a dismal demographic forecast, and renewed racial unrest wrought by identity politics. Small wonder that we...
3 Ways to Dwell in the Love of Jesus This Valentines Day
  “Surely your goodness and love will follow me all the days of my life, and I will dwell in the house of the Lord forever.” Psalm 23:6 (NIV)   God is in relentless pursuit of your heart.Whether or not you feel loved in this season, you are. Love is who He is.   God’s love is active as the waterfall, crashing against...
4 Questions to Ask When Listening for Gods Voice (Jeremiah 29:12
  4 Questions to Ask When Listening for God's Voice   By Cara Joyner   “Then you will call on me and come and pray to me, and I will listen to you. You will seek me and find me when you seek me with all your heart. I will be found by you,’ declares the LORD.’” – Jeremiah 29:12-13.   One of the...
Countering Digital Deception
  Digital tools have completely revolutionized online commerce, mostly for the better. Gone are the days of one-size-fits-all product offerings and static storefronts. Modern online businesses thrive by responding to customer needs at an individual level. Using massive databases of historical browsing and shopping data, companies construct detailed consumer profiles, which they then deploy to create online shopping experiences tailored to...
Words Will Never Hurt Me
  Saturday, February 8, 2025   Words Will Never Hurt Me   “In the same way, the tongue is a small thing that makes grand speeches. But a tiny spark can set a great forest on fire.” (James 3:5 NLT)   Have you ever seen a roast? I’m talking about the comedy performance, not the cut of beef. A roast is when several comedians...
Fill Your Prescription
  Fill Your Prescription   This devotional was written by Jim Liebelt   Do not conform any longer to the pattern of this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind. Then you will be able to test and approve what God’s will is – his good, pleasing and perfect will. —Romans 12:2   One day, after not feeling well for some...
Is Marriage Counseling Worth It?
  Crosswalk Couples Devotionals: Is Marriage Counseling Worth It?   By: Vivian Bricker   Plans fail for lack of counsel, but with many advisers they succeed.(Proverbs 15:22)   Once a couple is married, they might hear many friends and family members tell them about marriage counseling. While many people believe marriage counseling is only when your marriage is struggling, marriage counseling can be helpful...
Performative Constitutionalism
  In the waning days of his presidency, Joe Biden put out a statement declaring that “the Equal Rights Amendment is the law of the land.” That came as a surprise to many, since the last state to ratify the amendment was Indiana in 1977, and the last state to pretend to ratify it was Virginia in 2020.   The Equal Rights...
Islam, Orientalism, and Jewish Life
  I was glad to read the review of my new book, The Islamic Moses, in Law Liberty, penned by Dr. Jeffrey Bristol. I was also glad to see that he praised at least half of the book, where I explored the religious connections between Judaism and Islam. Yet he also raised several criticisms of the other half, where I examine...
How to Endure the Worst of Trials
  How to Endure the Worst of Trials   By Kelly Balarie   Bible Reading:   “Fight the good fight of the faith. Take hold of the eternal life to which you were called when you made your good confession in the presence of many witnesses.” – 1 Timothy 6:12 NIV   Have you ever noticed that, as a culture, we glorify mountaintop moments but...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved