Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Nun: Abortion-funding stimulus is ‘the faithful answer’ to COVID-19
Nun: Abortion-funding stimulus is ‘the faithful answer’ to COVID-19
Feb 16, 2025 10:09 AM

The Senate passed the “American Rescue Plan” on Saturday without the Hyde Amendment, a legislative rider that protects taxpayers from having to fund abortion-on-demand. However, a prominent Roman Catholic nun has celebrated the $1.9 trillion stimulus package, calling on “every single member of Congress” to vote for it and saying the abortion-funding measure makes strides toward “ending child poverty.”

The current version of the American Rescue Plan contains $414 billion in taxpayer dollars not subject to Hyde Amendment protections, possibly subjecting them to use on elective abortions or insurance plans that cover elective abortions in, e.g., COBRA insurance plans.

“The American Rescue Plan is the faithful answer to those in need,” said Sr. Simone Campbell, executive director of Network Lobby for Catholic Social Justice. She also described the bill as mon good legislation.”

In addition to the domestic abortion funding, the bill “breaks with 47 years of congressional precedent by appropriating over $700 million of global health funds not subject to the Helms amendment, which prohibits taxpayer funding of abortion abroad,” according to the Family Research Council.

It also boosts Title X funding by $50 million which, if Biden repeals the Trump-era Protecting Life in Global Health Assistancepolicy, will e another revenue stream for Planned Parenthood, the nation’s largest abortion provider.

Sr. Campbell’s organization, Network, posted a message on Twitter on Monday to “celebrate” the bill’s passage. “This legislation protects vulnerable people,” Sr. Campbell said.

“I’m so proud of what we plished together,” Sr. Campbell added on Twitter.

Passing the #AmericanRescuePlan is just the beginning of what we must do to #BuildAnew. Child poverty will be cut in half, struggling families will be able to pay their bills and put food on the table, vaccines will reach everyone. I'm so proud of what we plished together

— Sr. Simone Campbell (@sr_simone) March 8, 2021

In addition to being morally and ethically illicit, funding the violation of an unborn child’s unalienable right to life is (thankfully) politically unpopular. More than three-quarters of Americans, including 55% of Democrats, oppose taxpayer-funded abortions overseas, a recent Marist poll found. A majority of Americans, including one-third of Democrats, also oppose government funding of abortions in the U.S., as well.

The Hyde Amendment has guided U.S. abortion policy for more than four decades. Republican- and Democratic-controlled Congresses alike passed the measure, introduced by the late Republican Congressman Henry Hyde of Illinois, each year since 1976. Commonsense restrictions on government spending have attracted a broad bipartisan coalition that has included President Jimmy Carter and, until June 2019, Joe Biden.

“The government should not tell those with strong convictions against abortion, such as you and I [sic], that we must pay for them [sic],” then-Senator Joe Biden once wrote to a constituent. “Those of us who are opposed to abortion[s] should not pelled to pay for them.”

Not only does government funding of abortion force taxpayers to subsidize the intrinsically immoral action of the taking the life of a separate, distinct human being, it also increases the number of abortions performed annually. The laws of economics hold that government subsidies create perverse incentives. When the subject is abortion, taxpayer funds increase abortions.

“The Hyde Amendment has saved a total of 2,409,311 lives” between 1976 and 2020, according to the scholarship of pro-life scholar Michael J. New, visiting assistant professor of political science and social research at the Catholic University of America.

After Hyde, the birthrate among women on Medicaid increased by 13% in states where taxpayers no longer funded abortion. “[O]ne of every nine people born to a mother on Medicaid in a state not funding abortions through Medicaid owes his or her life to the Hyde Amendment,” writes New.

However, Sr. Campbell does not support the American Rescue Plan without reservation. “One critical piece failed to make it to the final version of this bill,” she said on Monday.

Unfortunately, she did not mean the Hyde Amendment; she meant the $15 minimum wage.

“Our Catholic faith calls us to insist that workers be able to support their families adequately on their salaries,” she said.

Yet “employment would be reduced by 1.4 million workers” if the minimum wage reaches $15 an hour, according to a Congressional Budget Office analysis released on February 8.

That’s a lower calculation than a 2019 CBO report on the same legislation, which found a $15 minimum wage would throw up to 3.7 million people out of work by 2025. Those millions would not be able to support their families at all, increasing government dependence – and contradicting Campbell’s stated reason for backing the policy.

Sr. Campbell suffers from mon misconception that the government can simply legislate economic reality. Yet the laws of economics do not yield to legislators’ intentions, whether good or ill. If the cost of labor increases to the point that it erases the employer’s profit margin, he will fire (or not hire new) employees.

Even if the American Rescue Plan lifted people out of poverty, rather than spending future generations further into debt, it would not merit the support of faithful Christians because of its abortion funding.

The Vatican made the moral calculus clear in a 2004 document titled Worthiness to Receive. “Not all moral issues have the same moral weight as abortion and euthanasia,” says the guidance, written by then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, who is now Emeritus Pope Benedict XVI.

It goes so far as to say that a priest or Eucharistic minister “must refuse to distribute Holy Communion to someone” who votes for or “take[s] part in a propaganda campaign in favour” of “civil laws that authorize or promote abortion.” Supporting publicly funded abortions will demonstrably increase the number of abortions.

Sr. Campbell’s proffered reason for supporting the bill is that the legislation offers a way to “take meaningful action to care for our struggling families by raising wages and ending child poverty.” She justifies her support of this legislation, as she did her advocacy for the Affordable Care Act, by saying that government economic interventions benefit “the least of these” – the same passage from Matthew 25 that government-expanding members of both parties invoked when expanding Obamacare coverage.

Her celebration of a bill that funds abortion-on-demand proves that church authorities who do not understand the laws of economics may e willing to sacrifice the least of these in the name of “the least of these.”

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Talking around the turkey: pre-political blessings
Talking politics around the turkey can turn November 26th from a joyful celebration to a daunting day. While the laughing family, gleaming silverware, or perfectly cooked turkey of Norman Rockwell’s Freedom from Want painting is our ideal, reality sometimes looks very different. Advice for how to navigate the day varies from “fight with your family” to tips on how to avoid politics altogether. As I have noted before, part of the difficulty to navigating conversation is that politics has invaded...
The 2020 election was a mess: 4 ways to keep it from ruining your life
The 2020 election pitted a violent leftist movement against a crass, self-centered incumbent who uses the levers of power to benefit himself. The campaign hardly proved inspiring. It also ended up with results that confounded the professional political class and distressed tens of millions of Americans. Days after voters cast their ballots, the presidential race remained undecided, and a nasty legal and PR battle continues to play out. For Catholics and other Christians, the temptation to e agitated, concerned, and...
Pandemic or not, America has the best healthcare in the world
When President Donald Trump fell ill with COVID-19, there was absolutely no contemplation of moving America’s head of state to another country to receive healthcare services. This might be surprising, considering the oft-quoted World Health Organization ranking of our healthcare system at 37th globally. Wouldn’t we want our president to be treated in the country with the very best healthcare? The problem, of course, is that parisons in healthcare often mislead. This was true before the pandemic, but it has...
Even Bernie Sanders opposed the gas tax
As an estimated 50 million Americans plan to travel for Thanksgiving holiday celebrations, politicians across the U.S. and Europe have introduced legislation to increase the gasoline tax. Legislators should listen to an outspoken foe of those taxes: Sen. Bernie Sanders. Gasoline tax revenues, which fell consistently before the COVID-19 pandemic, have gone into a free fall under government-mandated lockdowns. In the U.S., the gasoline tax funds the Highway Trust Fund, which pays for improvements to roads and bridges. But the...
COVID-19 and false narratives of human powerlessness
Victimhood is central to popular analyses of the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. While the scramble for victimhood was central to our political discourse prior to 2020, government bailouts have exacerbated this narrative. Individuals must pete to create the pelling story in order to receive aid. Among those fighting for the spotlight are public school teachers, female university faculty, and the very sympathetic airline executives. Part of the problem is that natural safety networks such as family and the church...
AOC’s blacklist has no place in the workplace
Economists and ethicists agree: A worker should be evaluated by the job he does, not his political views. But the more politicized life es, the greater the chance petent employee will lose his or her job because of his private political views. Politicians like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez propose blacklisting their political foes, potentially including tens of millions of people, over politics. In an Orwellian twist of fate, the best employees may be fired precisely because they perform their job to the...
All work is essential: What COVID-19 teaches us about vocation
In the information age, Americans have tended to elevate certain jobs and careers over others, leading to a general resistance to “blue collar” work and an over-glorification of desk jobs, start-ups, and “creative spaces.” Reinforced by constant cultural calls to “follow our passions” and pursue four-year college degrees, workers have e narrowly focused on a shrinking set of job prospects in sectors like technology, finance, marketing, and activism. Such attitudes have led to an ever-widening skills gap in the trades...
5 ways to talk about politics peacefully
This year, some families have little reason to give thanks, because political arguments have turned the holiday dinner table into a war zone. Friends, even relatives have cut ties with people who don’t share their political perspectives. Too often, flaring tempers quench the spirit of joy and brotherhood that should mark family gatherings. The right way to respond isn’t to refuse to discuss politics and religion. It’s to talk about politics in a way that is worthy of Christians. These...
‘God is always at my center’: Jimmy Lai receives Acton Institute’s 2020 Faith and Freedom Award
Everyone in the global fight for liberty has some item that cultivated his intellectual palate. For Chinese dissident Jimmy Lai, it was a candy bar. As an eight-year-old boy, he worked as a baggage carrier in a railway station in his native mainland China. After he carried the bag of a visitor from Hong Kong, the man gave the future billionaire a piece of chocolate. “It was amazing,” he says. Eating that delectable sweet made him believe “Hong Kong must...
How to give thanks in 2020
Thanksgiving in 2020 seems to be an oxymoron. What good can we celebrate in the year that witnessed an ongoing global health pandemic, an artificial economic crisis, and the largest federal budget deficit in U.S. history? In Thanksgiving, as in life, it helps to step back from the rush of headlines and social media alerts to take stock of the abiding and eternal blessings of everyday life. This is in no way to minimize the disastrous year of 2020. The...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved