Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Nanny-state nationalism is a threat to parental rights
Nanny-state nationalism is a threat to parental rights
May 5, 2025 9:06 PM

On a recent episode of this Fox News show,Tucker Carlson called on Congress to ban smartphones for children.

Those who assume Carlson is still a conservative might be confused by his abandonment of limited government and his embrace of a nanny-state policy. But this latest call for government to intervene in the lives of Americans is in keeping with Carlson’s drift from conservatism to nationalism—a shift that is ing mon on the right side of the political spectrum.

Because it is tied to specific nations, nationalism takes on a variety of forms. But what they share mon, as David Koyzis explains in histheological definition of nationalism,is that they’re a form of political arrangement in which the people deify the nation, viewing their nation as the Savior that will protect them from the evil of being ruled by those who are different from them.

There are two main aspects of this definition that need to be clarified. First, most people have a natural fear of “being ruled by those who are different from them.” This in itself is not necessarily wrong. Where it es problematic is when we exclude people from our county or from taking positions of leadership because of such benign factors as ethnicity rather than ideology. Second, nationalists trust the nation-state—or rather the nanny-state—to be their Savior and protect them from all forms of evil. This requires an inevitable shifting of rights and power from the people to the government.

Because the movement tends to focus on issues such as immigration and protectionism, we tend to associate nationalism with external threats. But that is merely the outer layer of nationalism. There is an inner core that is similarly focused on having the state protect us from ourselves in ways that are unnecessary for ordered liberty and antithetical to moral freedom.

What separates nanny-state nationalism from other movements that believe in reasonable regulation, such as conservatism, is the impetus to infantilize the public. Notice how Tucker says “in real life it’s just too difficult” for parents to limit their children’s smartphone use. Not only are the children helpless to do anything about the problem, their parents are equally helpless to manage what is going on in their own home.

For nanny-state nationalists like Tucker, the protective role of the nation-state is not limited to threats at our borders. For them, the government should have a nearly unlimited say in how we manage any affairs that might harm the deified nation. Nationalists are willing to sacrifice the God-given rights of parents because government leaders (assuming, of course, they too are nationalists) know what is best for us.

There is a concept in political science known as the horseshoe theory that claims the far left and the far right, rather than being at opposite and opposing ends of a linear political continuum, closely resemble one another, much like the ends of a horseshoe. That certainly appears to be true for nanny-state nationalists who seem to be closer to nanny-state progressives than they are to conservatives or libertarians.

Conservatives and libertarians spent most of the twentieth century opposing left-wing statism. While that is likely to continue, it appears we will also be forced to spend the twenty-first century opposing forms of right-wing statism like populism and nationalism.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Landmark Human Trafficking Case Concludes With $14 Million Settlement
While sex trafficking gets a lot of attention in the media, labor trafficking is actually mon. It largely affects middle-aged men, most of whom are looking for ways to support themselves and their families. Often faced with overwhelming poverty, these men make ill-informed and risky choices, hoping that what they are being told by potential employers is true. In a landmark case, a Gulf pany, Signal International, has been ordered to pay $14 million in damages to men they had...
Hostility Towards Religion Continues To Grow In America
Liberty Institute, a legal organization in Plano, Texas, has released the report, “Undeniable: The Survey of Hostility to Religion in America, 2014 Edition,” featuring more than 1,300 cases of religious hostility, persecution and/or Constitutional violations of rights in the United States. According to the report, Hostility to religion in America is still growing. Because religion is so vital to a free and well-ordered society, our goal is to expose and document this growing hostility to help Americans confront and reverse...
Economic Freedom Isn’t Enough
We know that, for economies to thrive, people must be free to start their own businesses without taxing regulations, that free trade must be the de facto means of doing business, and that cronyism and corruption must be eradicated. But that’s not enough. At the Institute for Faith, Work & Economics, blogger (and former Acton intern) Elise Amyx says we have to have human flourishing as well. Economic freedom is only ponent of human flourishing. We should think about it...
7 Figures: Statistics on Global Christianity
Each year the International Bulletin of Missionary Research lays out in summary form an annual update of significant religious statistics. Here are seven sets of figures based on their latest report: 1. Global population by religion: Christians – 2.38 billion; Muslims – 1.7 billion; Hindu – 1 billion; atheists – 136 million; Jews – 14 million. 2. Membership by 6 ecclesiastical megablocs: Catholics – 1.2 billion; Protestants – 441 million; Independents – 407 million; Orthodox – 280 million; Anglicans –...
Death And Redemption In Ukraine
Bohdan Solchanyk was not a materialistic young man. He did not seek worldly pleasures, but rather took delight in his studies, his fiancee, his faith. What Bohdan wanted -what they both wanted – was live in the Ukraine with dignity and freedom. Bohdan’s dream died last week at a peaceful protest against the government, where he and 80 others were “brutally shot and killed by government snipers in the central square of the capital of Ukraine, as the world’s TV...
Women and the Academy Awards
Patricia Arquette’s passion is fabulous, says Elise Hilton in this week’s Acton Commentary, but she’s wrong on economics: Ms. Arquette’s passion is fabulous, and I’m sure that’s what makes her a great actor. But she’s wrong on economics. The “women make 23 cents less than men” canard is far less accurate than Arquette thinks it is. Women are more likely to work part-time, to choose careers that pay less but offer more flexibility in scheduling (such as teaching) and often...
Why is NYC Discriminating Against Churches?
New York City owns almost 1,200 public school buildings that sit empty on nights and weekends. To earn some extra e, the city rents out the empty schools to tens of thousands munity groups for any meetings that might be of interest to munity: Boy Scouts, drama clubs, labor unions senior citizen groups, etc. In 2011 alone, the NYC issued over 122,000 permits for using the schools. But there is one group that is forbidden from using the facilities: churches....
Worldwide Flight From Family Is Killing Us
In the 1970s, Paul Ehrlich tried to warn us: human beings were in trouble. We were reproducing so rapidly, Ehrlich opined, that millions of us would soon be starving. Ehrlich got one thing right: we are in trouble. But he pletely wrong about overpopulation. Today, just the opposite is true. There aren’t enough of us human beings. And a lot of people are seriously disinterested in making more. Nicholas Eberstadt calls this the “flight from family.” All around the world...
How Churches Can Protect the Poor Against Predatory Lending
Near the top of the list of things I despise panies that take advantage of the plight of the poor and desperate. But just above that on my list is something I hate even more: being poor and desperate. That’s why I loathe payday panies that charge usurious interest rates—and why I’m not yet ready to see them abolished. Here’s how payday lending works. If you have a job (and pay stub to prove it), a payday pany will allow...
Keeping The Poor Impoverished And Incarcerated
While payday loans can help some people out of a financial jam, they tend to prey on the poor and create a usury situation. Now that same predatory financial monster is moving into a new territory: bonds, courts fees and fines. Take the case of Kevin Thompson, a 19-year-old who was fined for speeding and failure to renew his license. Although he had a job, he could not afford to pay the $810 fine the court handed down. What happens...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved