Home
/
Isiam
/
Politics & Economics
/
A new Middle East under Obama?
A new Middle East under Obama?
Jun 16, 2025 12:10 PM

  Even though Barack Obama has been elected the 44th president of the United States, there are some in the Middle East who believe his policies towards the region will differ little from those of his defeated Republican rival, John McCain.

  Al Jazeera asked a number of people in Egypt, the Arab world's most populous country, whether Obama would bring change to the US presidency.

  Abdel-Rahman Hussein, journalist

  "There is an apathy among Egyptians regarding the US election because many say it makes no difference who wins. The US will always pursue the same policies in the region.

  Even with a Democratic win in the White house, it is American - and almost by default Israeli - interests which will always come first.

  The fulcrum of American policy in the region is support for Israel above all else, and both parties unequivocally adhere to that.

  Additionally, as opposed to Great Britain where the divide between left and right has become less pronounced in recent years, the American political spectrum has always been more centrist.

  One position both candidates straddled quite comfortably is their staunch support for Israel.

  Obama's promise to the American Israeli Public Affairs Committee (Aipac) that Jerusalem will remain the "undivided" capital of Israel does not bode well for the future of the peace process which is currently proposing East Jerusalem as the capital of a future Palestinian state.

  Nevertheless, Jewish and pro-Israel groups remain skeptical about Obama and feel he is merely paying lip service to secure the election, so again it is difficult to surmise exactly how it will pan out."

  Jen Zaki Hanna, university professor

  "Unfortunately, I do not believe that Obama will have significantly different foreign and financial policies.

  I considered the one person who could have brought about real change in the Middle East, to be Ralph Nader.

  Nader dissected the real problem with America's financial policies - that being the unfettered control of the transnational corporations and their lack of respect for human rights and environmental rights at home and globally.

  Unfortunately, every time Nader tries to enter the presidential race he is called a spoiler for the Democrats. This just goes to shows me, and I believe others around the world and in the Middle East, that the Democrats and Republicans are one and the same.

  Perhaps Hillary Clinton was the lesser of the two evils than Obama who has changed his mind multiple times on issues such as Iraqi troop withdrawal.

  Both parties will always be loyal first and foremost to Israel as a necessary ingredient to US foreign policy and according to most Middle Easterners it has always meant one thing: there will be no progress on Israeli-Palestinian peace.

  There has yet to be a Democratic or Republican party in the US which has demonstrated a real significant move on a two-state solution.

  I do not think things will change now."

  Yousef Gamal il Din, broadcast journalist with NileTV

  "There is also ... a belief that the foreign policies of both candidates do not really vary much.

  The debates did not highlight key differences that will help regional problems in the Arab World, Afghanistan, Sudan, Lebanon, Iraq and Palestine.

  My impression from talking to Egyptians who are well-read in international affairs and business is that they perceive McCain to be hawkish (more so than Obama) and that his policies would have been less-suitable for Arab interests.

  Obama appears to be better for our region, but the key word here is appears.

  The Middle East would look different under Obama but it will be difficult to judge because the rhetoric during the campaign does not necessarily translate into decisions or policies once the candidate reaches the White House.

  Once candidates are confronted with certain realities in the White House or realities that emerge later on, they may have to adapt their policies. The international arena is very dynamic, things change very quickly.

  It is difficult to accurately predict US foreign policy."

  Ahmed Samy, marketing analyst

  "Israel won't be that happy that Obama won because they might not trust that he would fully back them, even though he has said before that he would fully support them.

  As for the Middle East, not much would change with Obama in office.

  The situation in the region might stay the same or get a bit better or put on hold till the following elections.

  The American people are the only ones to benefit if Obama wins.

  Now Obama being the first black president in America is a history-making event; if he stays in office the full term, that is good. But if he gets assassinated or something like that, then it will be a tragedy."

  Ahmed Kafafi, author

  "An Obama win doesn't mean so much to me because whoever comes to power will never dare to change certain basics in the US foreign policy and assuming there will be any, those will be slight changes that would never reverse the situation in the Middle East.

  I do not think Egypt and the Middle East will look any different; there is a fear that things will move from bad to worse. The financial crisis has peaked and the wealth of the Middle East is the only way out for the US.

  Egyptians see the US as working for its own interests and is a big supporter of Israel. For them the US is a big power that will never ever work for their interest, so it doesn't matter if Obama or McCain is in power."

  PHOTO CAPTION

  A US soldier rides his bicycle in a sandstorm in Camp Taji, northwestern of Baghdad.

  Source: Aljazeera.net

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Politics & Economics
Pakistan agriculture could take up 2 yrs to start flood recovery
  Pakistan's agriculture industry -- a pillar of the economy -- could take up to two years to start recovering from floods, the Asian Development Bank (ADB) said on Monday.   ADB and the World Bank are assessing the damage caused by one of Pakistan's worst natural disasters.   Philip Erquiaga, director general...
Report slams Pakistan drone strikes
  New information on the Central Intelligence Agency's (CIA) campaign of drone strikes in northwest Pakistan directly contradicts the image the Barack Obama administration and the CIA have sought to establish in the news media of a program based on highly accurate targeting that is effective in 'disrupting al-Qaeda's plots' against...
UN: DR Congo troops committing rape
  Government soldiers in the DR Congo have attacked and raped women in villages where rebels already committed mass rape this summer, a high-level UN official has said.   UN peacekeepers in the Walikale territory have reported that army troops are committing "rapes, killings and lootings," Margot Wallstrom, the special representative for...
Forced abortions for Chinese women
  China's one-child policy leads to an estimated 13 million reported abortions every year, with many of those ordered by the authorities enforcing the system.   Al Jazeera's Melissa Chan gained access to a hospital in the southeastern city of Xiamen, where she found one mother in a terrible condition.   Xiao Ai...
US military suicide rates surge
  For John Helfert, the problems started with the mortar shells screaming into the Abu Ghraib prison compound, the explosions sending furious shock waves.   "You don't feel like there is any place to go," said Helfert, then a Marine lance corporal in an infantry unit at the infamous prison. "You are...
UK troops face 90 new claims of abuse in Iraq
  A specialist team appointed by the government to investigate claims of abuse by British troops in Iraq has received 90 complaints involving 128 Iraqi civilians. The files, relating to allegations between March 2003 and July 2009, have been sent to Geoff White, a former head of Staffordshire CID, who heads...
UN 'failed' DR Congo rape victims
  UN troops failed 242 women and children who suffered a mass rape attack in the eastern Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), a top UN peacekeeping official has said.   Congo hosts the largest and most costly UN peacekeeping mission in the world, but the mass rape attacks happened just 30km from...
From Balfour to Obama
  On November 2, 1917, Lord Arthur Balfour, the then British foreign secretary, promised to create a homeland for the Jews in Palestine. Known as the Balfour Declaration, the document became the first stepping stone towards the 1948 establishment of the state of Israel.   Palestine was still under Ottoman rule when...
UN warns of global refugee crisis
  Conflicts are leading to new era of near permanent refugee populations, the head of the United Nation's refugee agency has said.   Antonio Guterres also said rich countries are only willing to take a fraction of those forced to flee by drawn-out warfare, especially in Afghanistan and Somalia.   "As a result...
UN: Mass rapes on Angola-DRC border
  More than 650 women and girls have been raped during mass expulsions from Angola to the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) in the past two months, according to a body of the United Nations.   Many of the victims said they were locked up and tortured for several weeks while they...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved