Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How the $15 minimum wage accelerates community decline
How the $15 minimum wage accelerates community decline
Mar 28, 2026 3:15 PM

As Congress debates the specifics of yet another stimulus bill, President Joe Biden and Sen. Bernie Sanders continue to push for the inclusion a $15 federal minimum wage – a policy that is only likely to prolong pandemic pain for America’s most vulnerable businesses and workers.

As if to confirm such fears, large corporations like Amazon and Walmart have been quick to voice their support for the increase. “It’s time to raise the federal minimum wage,” writes Amazon’s Jay Carney, boasting of their decision to increase wages in 2018. “We believe $15 an hour is the minimum anyone in the U.S. should be paid for an hour of labor. We also believe it’s good for business.”

But while it may be “good for business” for Amazon, such an increase will pose significant challenges for others, particularly smaller businesses and those operating in low-cost states. According to one study, “Roughly half the minimum-wage workforce is employed at businesses with fewer than 100 employees, and 40% are at very small businesses with fewer than 50 employees.”

According to the latest analysis from the Congressional Budget Office, the proposed Raise the Wage Act would eliminate an estimated 1.4 million jobs while increasing the federal deficit by $54 billion over the next 10 years. This doesn’t even account for the indirect ways such a policy is likely to drive automation, squeeze consumers with higher prices, and reduce gross domestic product.

As Timothy Carney explains in The Washington Examiner, it’s yet another example of “regulatory robbery,” wherein government and large corporations collaborate together to diminish opportunity and economic diversity. For those truly concerned about the roots of economic inequality and the pressing problems of poverty, this is a leading problem.

“Amazon and other giant corporations often lobby for costly labor regulations and mandates in order to kill petitors,” Carney writes. “Uber has recently argued that states should require all panies to provide medical and disability coverage for injuries incurred on the job, and Walmart was an early supporter of Obamacare’s employer mandate in health insurance.”

There are many reasons to oppose such an increase. By taking a one-size-fits-all approach to prices, we ignore their functional role as signals for service. In doing so, we diminish our ability to specialize and imagine new possibilities and partnerships across the economic order.

But given the decline of munities and the particular economic problems of the pandemic, the collusion among large corporations makes the destruction all the more painful and perverse. At a time when online shopping and fast-food behemoths are booming – and independent retailers and restaurants are struggling to survive – such an approach gets things backwards with remarkable precision, working to erode economic diversity and accelerate decline where help is needed most.

As Carney explains, the fruits will not be purely “economic” in nature. By using the government to kick “Main Street” businesses when they’re already down, our government is poking at things far more profound than mere “jobs,” “wages,” or static little storefronts:

So the corner store that somehow has survived the pandemic and decades petition from Amazon may pay a local college student $7.25 an hour to stock shelves. If you outlaw that job, you may help Amazon, but you also hurt that college student and that mom and pop. What’s more, you hurt munity.

Brick-and-mortar stores on Main Street draw people to Main Street. When people walk up and down Main Street, they bump into neighbors, they stop in at the coffee shop. Their children run into other children. These unplanned and serendipitous encounters are the building blocks of munities.

The car-centric, inhuman sprawl caused by Robert Moses, Walmart, zoning laws, and yes, Amazon, makes it easier for most people (those with cars and who don’t have car-seat-aged children) to shop and harder for others (those without cars and who have to buckle the baby, unbuckle, and rebuckle, re-unbuckle, et cetera). It has also munities by reducing how much people know their neighbors.

For those who claim that these policies are designed to help the “little guy,” the irony abounds.

To be clear, such policies have also proved disastrous for employees of large corporations, as well as businesses in high-cost metropolitan areas like Seattle. What more damage might they achieve in areas that face greater vulnerabilities? The possibilities for unseen negative effects are virtually endless.

Some would argue that these risks are mostly due to other “outside forces” — globalization, automation, and innovation — and in many ways they are. But it’s one thing if a business closes due to natural forces, based on authentic prices and petition among freely operating enterprises and institutions. It’s quite another when such disruption is unnecessarily forced or accelerated by the hands of the federal government.

As the cheers of Amazon and Walmart make clear, this is not “creative destruction,” properly understood. This is cronyism of a certain sort, and our most munities are in the crosshairs.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Did Perón inspire Pope Francis on economics?
In a recent article published for The Catholic World Report Samuel Gregg highlights some similarities between Pope Francis and the former president of Argentina, Juan Perón. Gregg asks: “Does a long-deceased Latin American populist provide us with insight into Pope Francis?” Juan Perón served as the president of Argentina from 1946-1955, while Pope Francis was just a teenager, and again from 1973-1974. According to Gregg, the economic views of this potentially influential leader on Pope Francis are: “best described as...
A humble case for freedom
Are people smart enough to run their own lives? Probably not. Are other people smart enough to direct everyone else’s lives? Definitely not. So if no one is smart enough, what then can we do? “Individually, we may not know much,” says Steven Horwitz, “but together, with the right institutions, we can learn from each other and, collectively, know a lot.” The justification for human freedom is not that we are so smart that we can manage our own lives...
Unemployment as Economic-Spiritual Indicator — July 2016 Report
Series Note: Jobs are one of the most important aspects of a morally functioning economy. They help us serve the needs of our neighbors and lead to human flourishing both for the individual and munities. Conversely, not having a job can adversely affect spiritual and psychological well-being of individuals and families. Because unemployment is a spiritual problem, Christians in America need to understand and be aware of the monthly data on employment. Each month highlight the latest numbers we need...
What Eric Whitacre’s ‘virtual choir’ teaches us about globalization and community
The rise of globalization and the expansion of trade are continuously decried for their disruptive effects, particularly as they apply to munity.” Indeed, our strides in global connectedness have e at a local cost, with the small and familiar being routinely replaced by the big and blurry, the intimate with the superficial, and so on. The shift is real and widespread, but it needn’t be the framework of the future. Disruption is sure to continue as collaboration expands and innovation...
5 Facts about nuclear weapons
The current presidential election has once again brought to the fore a question we ask every electoral cycle: Which candidate can be most trusted with nuclear weapons? The consideration given that question, though, is rather modest relative toits importance. Indeed, for those who are concerned about ordered liberty there are few questions more important than who should be in charge of the most powerful arsenal of weapons on earth. We are giving a single individual unprecedented control over weaponry that...
What Christians should know about the time value of money
Note: This is the latest entry in the Acton blog series, “What Christians Should Know About Economics.” For other entries inthe series seethis post. The Term: Time Value of Money What It Means: The time value of money (TVM) is the concept that because of potential earning capacity, money available at the present time is worth more than the same amount at a future time. Why It Matters: Would you rather receive $100 today or $100 one year in the...
Rediscovering the beautiful
“An emphasis on the need for practical use is beneficial when applied to goods in the market, so as to meet the ever changing demands of the consumer,” says Caroline Roberts in this week’s Acton Commentary. “But the value of some goods cannot be reduced to a selling price.” One such good is beauty. Although the market has a role to play in the creation of beautiful things, this essential good can only be fully realized through the work of...
Samuel Gregg asks, ‘what causes terrorism?’
“[W]hen the center of the global economy is the god of money,” Pope Francis stated recently in an interview, “[t]errorism grows.” Curious about the Pope’s somewhat economistic explanation for Islamist terrorism,Samuel Gregg asks, “do factors such as economic poverty and greed really function as major causes of Islamist terrorism?” He recently wrote an article for the Stream examining this. The available research on this question, Gregg points out, suggests not. As he summarizes: In short, terrorists generally aren’t economically poor...
Globalization, Brexit, and virtue in the world of finance
In a recent interview with MercatorNet, Samuel Gregg explains why the integration of markets is not in itself a bad thing. Gregg starts out by explaining why Brexit does not contradict economic globalization, but why it is actually beneficial to the global economy. Hey says: But Brexit is also patible with economic globalization. Economic globalization is rendering trade blocs such as the EU increasingly irrelevant. Britain now can choose to trade freely with whoever it wants, instead of waiting for...
Working overtime or working less?
Earlier this year the Obama administration announced the publication of a new Department of Labor rule updating and expanding overtime regulations (here’s an explainer article on what it is and means). There are numerous ways to show how this policy which was intended to help workers will actually hurt them. But sometimes the best way to make a point is with an illustration. Prager U has a new video that shows how this regulation can prevent people from ing salaried...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved