Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How God makes a loaf of bread
How God makes a loaf of bread
Aug 14, 2026 1:37 PM

Economist Russ Roberts has produced a charming new video, “It’s a Wonderful Loaf”,that reveals the “hidden harmony that is all around us.” In the animated poem, Roberts looks at the “seemingly magical ways” that we anticipate and meet the needs of each other without anyone being in charge.

While the poem is helpful in seeing the hidden order in markets, it’s missing a key explanation. Roberts claims this order is not designed but just “emerges” by the actions of humans:

Order’s everywhere. Yet we humans too create it

It emerges. No one intends it. No one has to orchestrate it.

It’s the product of our actions but no single mind’s designed it

That’s partially correct—it wasn’t designed by humans. Humans may set individual prices but it was God who designed the price system as a means of coordinating human activity for the purposes of human flourishing.

God knows and cares about what may seem like trivial issues (such as whether you can obtain bread) and has provided a way for our neighbors to help meet those needs.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
No, Jesus was not a socialist
The resurgence of socialism in America, especially among the young, seems to be based on a widespread form of wishful thinking and historical ignorance. Most people who support Bernie Sanders, for instance, do not realize that most of his ideas have been tried already—and discarded as unworkable. Similarly, many Christians who support Sanders don’t realize that for centuries socialism has been considered patible with Christianity.Since the mid-1800s every Catholic pontiff—from Pius IX to Benedict XVI—has forthrightly condemned socialism. Protestants don’t...
Do you feel a Draft?: Freedom, Virtue, and Military Conscription
LastDecember Defense Secretary Ash Carter announced he would lift the military’s ban on women serving bat, a move that allows hundreds of thousands of women to serve in front-line positions during wartime. “This means that as long as they qualify and meet the standards, women will now be able to contribute to our mission in ways they could not before. They’ll be able to drive tanks, give orders, lead infantry soldiers bat,” Secretary Carter said at a news conference. Today,...
Religious Shareholder Activists: Enemies of Debate
From the time your writer opted to publicly proclaim his policy opinions in a variety of forums that are privately funded, he has incurred estrangement from ideologically opposed friends and family members, as well as receiving threatening emails and even frightening phone calls plete strangers. From the above experiences, it was easy to glean progressives can be very nasty (comments I receive often remark negatively on my choice of eyewear). Most tellingly, however, presume to know the private funding sources...
Young Socialist Hearts, Old Conservative Heads, and Correctly Attributed Quotes
In the recent Iowa Caucus, young Democratsfavored the socialist Bernie Sanders by a margin of six to one, while older voters went overwhelmingly for the more traditionally progressive Hillary Clinton. The support of an old socialist by young voters and socialism should remind us of that old quote . . . you know the one, the one by . . . Churchill? When es to citing famous quotations, a good rule of thumb is to attribute any unknown saying either...
This is No Time to Panic
Today is the official start of the primary season, which which means it’s also the time when many people officially shift into political panic mode. A lot of usare in a panic, fearing that Western civilization — or at least America’s future — is at stake and that something must be done quickly to avert disaster. But what Americans really need is to to heedthe advice of Greg Forster: Don’t panic. With all due respect to baseball, panicking is America’s...
A Lesson in Capitalism from JS Bach and a Penniless Swami
What do we care about? How does the economic system affect our purpose in life? How can it enhance our purpose? Those are the questions Arthur Brooks, president of the American Enterprise Institute, tackles in his presentation before the Aspen Institute. ...
Does capitalism reduce violence?
It’s been said before, but it’s certainly worth saying again. Not only does the free market lead to material wealth, but it reduces violence. On a recent episode of the podcast “Question of the Day,” co-host Stephen Dubner reads a question from a listener: Why haven’t humans evolved as a species away from aggression? Dubner and James Altucher deal with the question in a rather roundabout way. Altucher points out that, really, aggression has dropped for as long as we’ve...
Lessons of the Flint Water Crisis
“As all the media attention attests, the sad story of Flint is not limited to itself,” says Kishore Jayabalan in this week’s Acton Commentary. “The entitlement mentality is like a drug ruining not just American cities but spreading to the country as a whole. The entitlement mentality is like a drug ruining not just American cities but spreading to the country as a whole.” As a native of Flint, Michigan, I am very saddened by the contaminated water crisis that...
The Goo-Goo Chorus of Silence
George Soros just donated another $6 million to Democratic Party presidential candidate Hillary Clinton’s Super Political Action Committee, raising the total the billionaire has contributed thus far to her 2016 campaign to $7 million. Liberals and progressives who can be counted on to hyperventilate every time the Koch brothers drop a dollar into a Salvation Army drum haven’t made a peep. They’ve also been remarkably silent on other donations to Clinton’s Priorities USA SuperPac, including $5 million from Haim Saban...
What Kuyper Can Teach Us About Trump and the ‘Third Temptation’
Liberty University president Jerry Falwell Jr. recently stirred up a bit of hubbub over his endorsement of Donald Trump, praising the billionaire presidential candidateas a “servant leader” who “lives a life of helping others, as Jesus taught.” For many evangelicals, the disconnect behind such a statement is more than a bit palpable. Thus, the critiques and dissents ensued, pointing mostly to fortable co-opting of Trump’s haphazard political proposals with Christian witness. As Russell Moore put it: Politics driving the gospel...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved