Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
HHS Lawsuit, Round Two: Healthcare.gov ‘Fail’
HHS Lawsuit, Round Two: Healthcare.gov ‘Fail’
Jan 31, 2026 1:09 PM

A new lawsuit against the federal government has been filed regarding the HHS mandate. The Williams family (father Joseph III, sons Joseph IV and Mark) own Electrolock, an electrical and thermal pany based in Ohio. The Williams family, as Catholics, believe the government’s mandate to provide abortions, artificial birth control and abortifacients to their employees as part of health care violates their religious liberty.

According to The Thomas More Law Center, the family decided to give employees money so that they could shop for their own health care at the government’s health care exchange, Healthcare.gov. However, things did not go as planned:

[I]n an effort to promising their religious beliefs plying with the HHS Mandate, the Williams Family initially paid each of their 43 employees several thousand dollars so the employees could purchase their own health insurance through the government Exchanges.

When employees began to have problems with the Exchange website, the Williams Family had to respond to plaints and the serious concerns of their employees who were facing loss of health care, frustration with the flawed government website, and the decision to look for other employment that did provide healthcare. The Williams Family wishes to continue providing the quality healthcare that it has provided to its employees for the last several years in accordance with their Christian Stewardship and Catholic Beliefs. At this point, with the HHS Mandate being the law of the land, the only way this can be done is by seeking relief from the courts.

Then, the family attempted to organize a health care plan for their employees on their own.

In a final attempt to provide for their employees in good conscience, the Williams Family has organized a self-insured employee health plan which they are seeking to implement. However, since the plan excludes abortion, sterilization, contraception, abortifacients and related education, the Williams Family requires an injunction from the court in order to implement the plan without penalties, which would exceed $1.5 million dollars per year.

This past Wednesday, Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius testified before a mittee regarding the problems with the Healthcare.gov website. When asked how many people had signed up, she replied, “We have no reliable data about enrollment, which is why we haven’t given it to date.” Meanwhile, CBS News reports that registration numbers are very low:

The website launched on a Tuesday. Publicly, the government said there were 4.7 million unique visits in the first 24 hours. But at a meeting Wednesday morning, the war room notes say “six enrollments have occurred so far.”

By Wednesday afternoon, enrollments were up to “approximately 100.” By the end of Wednesday, the notes reflect “248 enrollments” nationwide.

President and Chief Counsel of The Thomas More Law Society stated,

Despite all of the political and media focus on the problems created by Obamacare and its dysfunctional healthcare website, we must not lose sight of the fact that the HHS Mandate violates our first and most sacred freedoms—freedom of religion and conscience. And in this regard, all Americans, not just Catholics or Protestants, must be concerned. Americans cannot remain indifferent to the fact that one of our most fundamental rights under our Constitution is under attack. This is why TMLC has thus far filed ten Federal lawsuits on behalf of both Catholics and Protestants challenging the HHS Mandate.”

Read “Healthcare Website Failures Force New HHS Mandate Challenge” at ThomasMore.org.

[product sku=1007]

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Global Warming Consensus Alert: Points for Honesty
Normally, I’m not a huge fan of Congressman John Dingell. But on this issue, I have to at least give him points for honesty: Democrats took over Congress vowing to make global warming a top priority, and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi planned to notch a quick victory with a bill that was long on political symbolism and cost, if short on actual emissions reductions. Standing in her way has been Mr. Dingell. Much to the speaker’s consternation, the powerful chairman...
Journal of Markets & Morality, Volume 10, Issue 1
This issue of the Journal of Markets & Morality features a scholia translation of Cardinal Cajetan’s (1469-1534) influential treatise On Exchanging Money (1499). Cajetan is the author of the officially mentaries on the Summa of Thomas Aquinas, which are easily available in the magnificent Leonine edition of this magnum opus. He is even more famous as the papal legate whom Leo X (1513-1521) dispatched to Germany in a futile effort to bring Martin Luther back into the Roman fold. Economic...
The Weekly Standard, AFR, and “The Call of the Entrepreneur”
Sonny Bunch reviewed “The Call of the Entrepreneur” and discussed the significance of the American Film Renaissance (AFR) in The Weekly Standard. His article is titled, “The Right Stuff: Conservatives decide if you can’t beat Hollywood, join it.” In his piece, Bunch discussed the goals of AFR: AFR has been hosting film festivals across the country since 2004, but the Hubbards hope to set up permanent shop in Washington and push the festival into the mainstream. Jim Hubbard says he...
David (McCarty) vs. Goliath
Well…except Goliath is mostly a good guy too– and he’s the one putting rocks in the air– and David got beat in this case by the government. From yesterday’s (Louisville) Courier-Journal, Charlie White and Sara Cunningham report on the stand-off between homeowner David McCarty and the local Wal-Mart under construction in Lebanon, KY. Complying with a court order, a Central Kentucky man yesterday ended his sit-down protest a few feet from a blasting site — part of the construction of...
Fair Trade’s Faded Facade
The Free Exchange blog at (HT) concludes a long and thoughtful post on fair trade, specifically in response to this recent NYT article, “Fair Trade in Bloom,” by wondering: And how does this affect coffee supply? If a premium is available for fair-trade coffee, shouldn’t other growers enter the market to take advantage of it until the price of coffee is bid down to market levels, leaving total producer take–baseline coffee price plus premium–where it stood before? Such a scenario...
Saving Secular Society
I used to have more regular and extensive interaction with people whose worldviews were starkly different from my own. That’s not so much the case anymore, so it’s good to be reminded occasionally that some people live in different worlds that are sometimes hard prehend. That happened today when I came across an announcment for a conference, “The Secular Society and Its Enemies.” In the strange universe in which the conference’s organizers live, “The world is finally waking up to...
‘The Idolatry of the Porn Worldview’
The folks over at the Reformation21 blog, produced of the Alliance of Confessing Evangelicals, have a great discussion going about the spiritual, cultural, and pastoral implications of pornography (here, here, and here). The first post takes up the Naomi Wolf article, “The Porn Myth,” which also occasioned in part my reflections on the pornification of culture in general and technology in particular. Carl Trueman aptly wonders (in the second post), Could it be that pornography is the ultimate free market...
‘Call of the Philanthropist’
The new issue of Philanthropy Magazine features a cover story on Frank Hanna, vice chairman of the Acton Institute board of directors, and winner of the 2007 William E. Simon Prize for Philanthropic Leadership. The story is titled “Call of the Philanthropist,” a play on Acton’s Call of the Entrepreneur documentary, which features Hanna prominently. The lengthy profile by Christopher Levenick offers insights into Hanna’s philanthropic activities and his philosophy of giving. Rev. Robert Sirico is quoted extensively, as are...
Abandon SCHIP: Big Government Returns
The mammoth Congressional expansion of SCHIP is such a bad idea, even the normally big spending President Bush vetoed the bill. I wrote a piece titled, “Abandon SCHIP: Big Government Returns,” which is now available on the Acton Website. The political posturing concerning the program has reached a troubling level. Supporters are using using kids as props to usher in socialized medicine and government expansion. But one of the main problems with the bill is the regressive characteristic of the...
Human Events on “The Call of the Entrepreneur”
Erika Andersen reviewed the “The Call of the Entrepreneur” for Human Events in a piece titled, “Entrepreneurship Preserves Life as We Know It.” The Call premiered last week to DC audiences at the E Street Cinema, as part of the Renaissance Film Festival. In her article Andersen noted the international interest in the film: Though it initially seems like the tale of the American dream, “The Call of the Entrepreneur” is an international story and is now being translated into...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved