Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Four caveats about the Official Poverty Measure
Four caveats about the Official Poverty Measure
Aug 12, 2026 1:01 AM

The U.S. Census Bureau released the official poverty measure (OPM) yesterday. Although the numbers were encouraging, there are at least four caveats that everyone who reads these statistics should keep in mind. Without making these adjustments, we may have an inaccurate picture of poverty in the U.S.

1. The OPM does not include the effects of government welfare programs. As the Census Bureauexplains, “The official poverty definition uses money e before taxes and does not include capital gains or noncash benefits (such as public housing, Medicaid, and food stamps).” Matt Weidinger at AEInoted:

Crucially, the current official [poverty] measure ignores a growing share of spending devoted to reducing the plight of the poor, effectively overstating poverty in the US.

If not addressed, the disconnect between the real conditions facing e households and what is reported in the OPM will only continue to grow—possibly dramatically—given calls by Democratic presidential candidates for rapid increases in benefits that may not be counted under the OPM. Unless the OPM is adjusted, these new benefit proposals would not reduce “official” poverty—or they could even result in its apparent increase if the new, uncounted benefits discourage work among e households and thus reduce earned e counted under the OPM.

TheSupplemental Poverty Measure (SPM), which began publication in 2011, tracks these data.

2. Americans likely underreport their e. Experts have long noted that the e reported on thesurveysthe bureau uses to calculate U.S. poverty “appears to be substantially underreported, especially for categories of e important for those with few resources, and the extent of underreporting has worsened over time.”

3. These data are a snapshot of current poverty. They do not track the rate of persistent poverty, year-on-year. That rate would be significantly lower, due to America’s high level of economic and social mobility – but as it is, we don’t know how much lower.

4. These data do not figure in taxes. CBS Newsreported, “One caveat is that the e figures reflect pre-tax e, which means that any benefits from the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, signed into law by President Donald Trump at the end of 2017, wouldn’t be reflected in the data.” Just as people benefit from the added consumption allowed by social welfare programs, they are penalized by confiscatory tax rates.

For Christians bat poverty, we must first measure it accurately. The best proposal would shift to a consumption-based measure. Barring that, this system is the best one available.

domain.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
A Moral Foundation for Entitlement Reform
Entitlement reform cannot succeed by eliminating dependence, says Adam J. MacLeod. Instead we should aim to promote healthy dependencies. In his address, Obama placed entitlement programs in perspective, observing that many people fall on hard times through no fault of their own. “We recognize that no matter how responsibly we live our lives,” he said, “any one of us at any time may face a job loss, or a sudden illness, or a home swept away in a terrible storm.”...
Sour Milk and Apple Cores: Families Left Out Due to Obamacare
Obamacare – or the Affordable Care Act (ACA) – is meant to give everyone in America the best access to the best health care. But things aren’t looking so good. As we get closer to its onset, it’s ing clear that there will be fall-out. Employers (especially small-to-medium size businesses) are looking for ways to handle the onslaught of costs Obamacare will bring; one way is to offer healthcare ONLY to employees, leaving employee families out of luck, and insurance....
Free Book: ‘Judaism, Law & The Free Market: An Analysis’
For a limited time, the Acton Book Shop is offering a book by rabbinical scholar Dr. Joseph Isaac Lifshitz for free: Judaism, Law & The Free Market: An Analysis. Acton released this title at an academic conference late last year, and in it, Lifshitz examines the Jewish treatment of themes such as property rights, social welfare, charity, petition, and concepts of order. There are three ways to download this title. Click here to download this title as ePub. Click here...
The McDouble and the Minimum Wage
The protests organized by labor organizations to advocate for an increase in the minimum wage have garnered attention, most recently from the NYT, which editorialized in favor of such moves. Over at Think Christian, I weigh in with an attempt to provide some more of plex context behind the moral evaluation of such mandates. In the piece, I’m really less interested in the plight of current-minimum wage workers relative to those who might e minimum-wage workers with an increase, those...
Accepting Applications for an ‘Intellectual Retreat’
Looking for a great opportunity to expand your intellectual capacity? We are still seeking applicants for two ing Liberty and Markets conferences: Religion and Liberty: Acton and Tocqueville and Evaluating the Idea of Social Justice. Co-sponsored by the Acton Institute and Liberty Fund, Inc., these conferences offer an excellent opportunity for networking and discussion within a small group environment, with an average faculty/participant ratio of 1:3. Both conferences are free and include single-occupancy lodging, meals, nightly hospitality, book gifts, and...
Does Legalizing Prostitution Reduce Child Sex Slavery?
Would legalizing adult prostitution decrease the demand for child sex slaves? That’s the curious argument made by one of my favorite libertarian economist. Donald J. Boudreaux , a professor of economics at George Mason University, recently wrote: If men can legally buy sex from women 18 years of age or older, men will have less demand to patronize children. And sex entrepreneurs will have less incentive to ‘supply’ children. With all prostitution being illegal, those who demand as well as...
A conflict of Christian visions: Gen. 1-2 vs. Gen. 3 Christianity
There are two prominent schools of thought within conservative Protestant circles that continue to clash over what Christianity is about because their starting prise different biblical theological visions. I use the word “prominent” here because I fully recognize that there are other more nuanced voices in the Christian diaspora. No “binaries” or “false dichotomies” are intended here. This is simply a distinction between the two dominant voices in a choir of others. One begins by constructing an understanding of the...
Christians Need a Holistic Definition of Poverty
To adequately address the problems of the lowest economic class, Christians must agree on a holistic definition of poverty that includes relational and spiritual elements. The best solutions for alleviating poverty, if not eradicating it, will involve collaborations among institutions that can address poverty in many different ways. World Vision president Rich Stearns says that poverty is a plex puzzle with multiple inter-related causes.” As a result, the best solutions (and indeed, there are many) will “help munity address their...
Do the Poor Vote for More Welfare?
A popular saying (often misattributed to Alexis de Tocqueville) states that a democracy can only exist until the voters discover that they can vote themselves largesse from the public treasury. If this is always the case then we should expect the poor to vote themselves even more welfare payments. However, as Dwight R. Lee explains, the desire for transfers that others will pay for has almost no effect on people’s voting behavior: This argument that a significant financial gain from...
Sushi, Surfing, and Food Stamps
It’s no secret that the number of people receiving food stamps in the U.S. has exploded in the past few years. Not only is it easier than ever to get food stamps, the government actively recruits people to sign up. Is there waste? Are your tax dollars being used wisely? Fox News thinks not. In a recent series called “The Great Food Stamp Binge”, reporter John Roberts spent some time with a young, healthy surfer in California. His reason for...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved