Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Four caveats about the Official Poverty Measure
Four caveats about the Official Poverty Measure
Aug 25, 2025 11:57 PM

The U.S. Census Bureau released the official poverty measure (OPM) yesterday. Although the numbers were encouraging, there are at least four caveats that everyone who reads these statistics should keep in mind. Without making these adjustments, we may have an inaccurate picture of poverty in the U.S.

1. The OPM does not include the effects of government welfare programs. As the Census Bureauexplains, “The official poverty definition uses money e before taxes and does not include capital gains or noncash benefits (such as public housing, Medicaid, and food stamps).” Matt Weidinger at AEInoted:

Crucially, the current official [poverty] measure ignores a growing share of spending devoted to reducing the plight of the poor, effectively overstating poverty in the US.

If not addressed, the disconnect between the real conditions facing e households and what is reported in the OPM will only continue to grow—possibly dramatically—given calls by Democratic presidential candidates for rapid increases in benefits that may not be counted under the OPM. Unless the OPM is adjusted, these new benefit proposals would not reduce “official” poverty—or they could even result in its apparent increase if the new, uncounted benefits discourage work among e households and thus reduce earned e counted under the OPM.

TheSupplemental Poverty Measure (SPM), which began publication in 2011, tracks these data.

2. Americans likely underreport their e. Experts have long noted that the e reported on thesurveysthe bureau uses to calculate U.S. poverty “appears to be substantially underreported, especially for categories of e important for those with few resources, and the extent of underreporting has worsened over time.”

3. These data are a snapshot of current poverty. They do not track the rate of persistent poverty, year-on-year. That rate would be significantly lower, due to America’s high level of economic and social mobility – but as it is, we don’t know how much lower.

4. These data do not figure in taxes. CBS Newsreported, “One caveat is that the e figures reflect pre-tax e, which means that any benefits from the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, signed into law by President Donald Trump at the end of 2017, wouldn’t be reflected in the data.” Just as people benefit from the added consumption allowed by social welfare programs, they are penalized by confiscatory tax rates.

For Christians bat poverty, we must first measure it accurately. The best proposal would shift to a consumption-based measure. Barring that, this system is the best one available.

domain.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The Superbowl: The New Day of Solidarity
If there is one day where young and old, Republican and Democrat, black and white, the 99% and the 1%, put down their weapons and disputes, it is on Superbowl Sunday. The game, the ads, the food, and so on, turned Superbowl Sunday into a major spectacle. The spectacle has not gone unnoticed among religious leaders. In fact, as Superbowl viewership has increased to over 100 million in recent years so has the fort about the game and the spectacle....
Belief Without Action: Becoming a Shell of Who You Are
“The Constitution protects your right to believe and worship, not force your beliefs on others.” That’s a response Acton received via Twitter regarding a blog post on the HHS Mandate. This type of statement is a typical one in our society: you can believe whatever you want, but don’t force your beliefs on anyone else. Religious belief and worship should be a wholly private affair; bringing your beliefs into the public square constitutes “forcing” them onto others. In the latest...
Celebrating Liberty During Black History Month
Since the 1970s, Black History Month has been a time to focus on some of the highlights of the black experience in America. In 2009, Jonathan Bean put together a wonderful book recounting the vital role liberty played in the American black experience. In Race and Liberty In America: The Essential Reader, Bean demonstrates that from the Declaration of Independence to the Civil Rights Act of 1964 to the 2007 U.S. Supreme Court decision banning school assignment by race, classical...
The Plan to Save Catholic Schools
In the Wall Street Journal, Cardinal Timothy Dolan explains how Catholic Schools bat falling enrollment while keeping standards high: I have heard from many leaders in business and finance that when a graduate from Catholic elementary and secondary schools applies for an entry-level position in panies, the employer can be confident that the applicant will have the necessary skills to do the job. Joseph Viteritti, a professor of public policy at Hunter College in New York who specializes in education...
Video: The Sirico-Winters Debate on Government’s Role in Helping Poor
On Monday, Jan. 28, The Aquinas Institute for Catholic Thought in Boulder, Colo., hosted its Sixth Annual Great Debate which addressed the question, “Can the free market adequately care for the poor?” Acton President and co-founder Rev. Robert A. Siricoargued for the side of the free market, debating Michael Sean Winters, a writer for National Catholic Reporter. Watch the entire debate here: Can the Free Market Adequately Care for the Poor? from Aquinas Institute on Vimeo. ...
Christians in the New Industrial Economy
The Acton Institute recently partnered with the Christian History Institute to produce the latest issue of Christian History magazine. The issue (which you can download as a free PDF) examines the impact of automation on Europe and America and the varying responses of the church to the problems that developed. Topics examined are mission work, the rise of the Social Gospel, the impact of papal pronouncements, the Methodist phenomenon, Christian capitalists, attempts munal living and much more. Check out these...
So God Made Paul Harvey
Last night millions of young Super Bowl viewers were introduced to one of the most influential conservatives in modern America. And it was done with mercial. Rush Limbaugh is often credited with the dubious honor of bringing conservative talk radio to the masses. And it is certainly true that Rush paved the way for Hannity, O’Reilly, and other pundits by perfecting the three-hour babblefest. But the true pioneer and undisputed king of conservative radio is Paul Harvey, a man who...
The Edict of Milan in the History of Liberty
The Emperor Constantine with his mother Helen, both memorated as saints of the Church. This month marks the 1,700th anniversary of the Edict of Milan. While much debate surrounds the relationship of Church and state in Christian Rome, even key figures like the Emperor Constantine (traditionally considered a saint by both East and West), the Edict of Milan is something that anyone who values liberty, religious liberty in particular, ought memorate as a monumental achievement. While a previous edict in...
The FAQs: Obamacare’s Contraceptive-Abortifacient Mandate
On Friday the Obama administration proposed a rule that it says will appease the concerns religious organizations have about the controversial abortion/contraceptive mandate issued last year by the Department of Health and Human Services. Here’s what you should know about the mandate and the proposed changes. What is this contraception mandate everyone keeps talking about? As part of the universal health insurance reform passed in 2010 (often referred to as “Obamacare”), all group health plans must now provide—at no cost...
Civil Society and Social Eco-System: Seeking Solutions Beyond Market and State
Over at Fieldnotes Magazine, Matthew Kaemingk offers a good reminder that in our social solutions-seeking we needn’t be limited to thinking only in terms of market and state. By boxing ourselves in as such, Kaemingk argues, Christians risk an overly simplistic, non-Biblicalview of human needs and human destiny: When presented with almost any social problem (education, health care, poverty, family life, and so on), today’s leaders typically point to one of two possible solutions—a freer market or a stronger state....
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved