Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Audio: Russell Kirk on Lord Acton’s approach to liberty and revolution
Audio: Russell Kirk on Lord Acton’s approach to liberty and revolution
Oct 31, 2025 2:17 AM

This is the eighth in a series celebrating the work of Russell Kirk in honor of his 100th birthday this October. Read more from the serieshere.

Russell Kirk had a profound influence on the conservative mind and movement—offering a rich pelling vision of ordered liberty and cultural imagination necessary to sustain it.

Toward the end of his prolific life and career, Kirk would offer his final public lecture on January 10, 1994, at the Acton Institute in Grand Rapids, MI.The lecture, “Lord Acton on Revolution,” aptly embodies that same legacy, exploring key philosophical tensions and plex historical realities—all with the goal of better understanding and, more importantly, better preserving human freedom, properly understood.

The audio of the lecture can be accessed below. (The lecture can also be found in written form inLord Acton: Historian and Moralist, a recently released collection of lectures and essays, edited by Samuel Gregg.)

Kirk begins the lecture with a series of reflections on Lord Acton’s enduring contributions to our understanding of freedom, expressing great appreciation for Acton’s view that “liberty is the condition of duty, the guardian of conscience,” and that, “It grows as conscience grows. The domains of both grow together.”

Kirk summarizes Lord Acton’s view as follows:

He meant Ciceronian and Christian concepts of liberty—ordered freedom, governed by conscience. He understood, of course, Cicero’s distinction between voluntas and libido: the first is willed freedom, the freedom of the high old Roman virtue; the second is lust, the freedom of unhallowed appetites. And Acton knew, of course, the Pauline truth that “the service of God is perfect freedom.”

Acton understood that power is the ability to do unto other people as one wishes, whether those others so wish or not; while freedom is the ability to withstand arbitrary power. Thus true freedom is the opportunity to make moral choices, and to do one’s moral duty here below. Lord Acton—who never throughout his life suffered under any arbitrary power—detested the absolutist political regimes of earlier centuries and those that remained during his own age.

From here, Kirk steadily transitions from appreciation to critique, focusing on Acton’s views on revolution and its merits as a mechanism for bringing about or maintaining such liberty.

In his early writings, Acton would refer to revolutions as “a malady, a frenzy, an interruption of the nation’s growth, sometimes fatal to its existence, often to its independence,” agreeing with Edmund Burke that the French Revolution was “the enemy of liberty.”Yet Kirk observes a shift in those views over time. “How then did e from time to time mend revolution?” Kirk asks. “Because he thought of political revolutions as bringing about, usually, an increase of freedom.”

The proceeding discussion offers much to consider, with in-depth explorations of key revolutions and Acton’s opinions thereof, from the Puritan Revolution to the English Revolution to the American Revolution—with the arguments ing to their clearest points in his final discussion of the French Revolution.

“Freedom cannot endure except upon the footing of a healthy order—order in the soul, and order in monwealth,” Kirk concludes. “Revolution, after all, is the disruption of order, and therefore extreme medicine.”

Throughout it all, we see those unique Kirkian tendencies at their best: a constant weighing and illuminating of that which so often lies hidden, whether it be defining a more robust ordered liberty or observing the more subtle distinctions between revolutionary and constitutional principles.

Listen to Kirk’s full and final public lecture here.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Christians at the movies
As The Dark Knight sets box office records, and the Acton Institute plunges deeper into the business of film production, it might be an opportune time to revisit the question of Christianity and movies. Scads of ink have already been spilled on the subject, which is of course part of the larger question of the relationship between Christianity and art, upon which many great minds have ruminated. (See, for example, Jacques Maritain on Art and Scholasticism.) On the PowerBlog, besides...
CRC Sea to Sea tour week 6
The sixth week of the CRC’s Sea to Sea bike tour has pleted. The sixth leg of the journey took the bikers from Fremont to Madison, a total distance of 548 miles. The “Shifting Gears” devotional for this week does a good job reminding us of the appropriate relative value of temporal vs. eternal things. “A human being’s life consists not in the abundance of his or her possessions, but in the blessing of loving relationships. May we be shrewd...
The conservative coalition crack-up
Earlier this week the Detroit News reported (HT: Pew Forum) that supporters of Mike Huckabee, former Arkansas governor and Republican candidate for this election’s presidential nomination, would be meeting with representatives of John McCain in the key swing state of Michigan. Among the “battleground” states, Obama holds his largest lead in the polls here in Michigan (RCP average of +3.2). The purpose of yesterday’s meetings was ostensibly to urge McCain to pass over Mitt Romney as a possible running mate,...
Solzhenitsyn and His Critics, cont.
In this week’s mentary, Solzhenitsyn and His Critics, I point to the criticism that has been leveled for many years at the writer who turned out to be not exactly the sort of dissident that many in the West were waiting for. I suspect that much of this antipathy to Solzhenitsyn was based on his promising moral vision, which seems to offend some people. I say: Solzhenitsyn’s critique of modern societies went much deeper than ideology. He drew from a...
Anthony Bradley discusses cultural moral failings
Anthony Bradley has written a thoughtful and mentary titled, “John Edwards is the Real World.” Bradley discusses the moral bankruptcy and sexual infidelity that plagues our culture, and further highlights the seriousness of sin and its consequences. Bradley notes: In the decades e, stories like this will be the American social narrative because Americans are not inculcating virtue in children. Are parents today raising children to be women and men of prudence, courage, justice, and self-control? Or are we raising...
‘Solzhenitsyn, Optimist’
In the Wall Street Journal, Edward E. Ericson Jr. asks whether “this week’s evenhanded obituaries signal merely momentary respect for the newly dead or augur better days ahead for Solzhenitsyn’s reputation.” In “Solzhenitsyn, Optimist,” Ericson observes that the writer “had the last laugh” in his struggle against the Soviets. Solzhenitsyn has described himself as “an unshakable optimist.” On a dark day when one of his helpers had been arrested and interrogated and ended up dead (who knows how?), he could...
Nannyfornia
Writing in the London-based Times, Chris Ayres in e to Nannyfornia” looks at the “frenzy of puritanical edicts from California’s politicians” that cover a host of sins, ranging from transfats to the highly objectionable use of the terms “Mom” and “Dad.” Ayres raises a “disturbing” question: Is Nannyfornia providing us with a glimpse of what Obama’s America might look like? After all, Obama is a classic banner. He recently proposed banning all toys from China. He banned his own staff...
Poetic justice
On an episode of NPR’s Talk of the Nation last month, professor Jay Parini of Middlebury College discussed his role in the criminal justice sentences given to students who were involved in the vandalism of the former summer home of renowned poet Robert Frost. Some of the younger students involved took part in a class on Robert Frost as part of an alternative sentencing plea agreement. As Prof. Parini says, “It’s a sort of unique punishment, talk about the punishment...
Religion & Liberty: David W. Miller update
The feature interview for the Winter issue of Religion and Liberty was Dr. David W. Miller, who at the time served as the Executive Director of the Yale Center for Faith & Culture. With his permission, Dr. Miller has agreed to let us inform our readers that he is taking a new position at Princeton as the Director of the Princeton University Faith & Work Initiative. The Trinity Forum is the only organization with an updated biography mentioning his new...
China’s march against religious freedom
In this week’s Acton Commentary, I make the case that persecution of Chinese Christians has increased since the government’s preparation of the 2008 Summer Olympic Games. Freedom House is really leading the way piling a wealth of information to substantiate China’s recent crack down on freedom and human rights. Jimmy Lai, who was featured in The Call of the Entrepreneur, has a great quote on the makeup of China’s moral failings and its relation to the Olympics. I included his...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved