Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
As Venezuela Crumbles, Will America’s New ‘Socialists’ Pay Attention?
As Venezuela Crumbles, Will America’s New ‘Socialists’ Pay Attention?
May 7, 2025 4:03 PM

The Venezuelan economy is buckling under the weight of its severe socialist policies, and even as its president admits to a nationwide economic emergency, the government continues to affirm the drivers behind the collapse,blaminglow oil prices and global capitalism instead.

This was supposed to be the dawn of “21st-century socialism,” as the late President Hugo Chavez proclaimed over 10 years plete with the right tweaks and upgrades to its materialistic, mechanistic approach to the human person. “We have assumed mitment to direct the Bolivarian Revolution towards socialism,” he said, “and to contribute to the socialist path, with a new socialism…which is based in solidarity, in fraternity, in love, in justice, in liberty, and in equality.”

Alas, with a shrinking economy, booming inflation, violent outbreaks, and empty food shelves, “21st-century socialism” is feeling mighty nostalgic in all the wrong ways.

In the years before Chavez, the country was inbetter shape than muchof the continent. Now, thanks to the temptations of centralized power, the arrogance of centralized planners, and a series of faux upgrades to age-old bad ideas, the nation is crumbling. The oil prices simply served as the messenger.

Over at The Atlantic, Moisés Naím and Francisco Toro offer a striking summary of the situation, including a range of stirring stories and reflections.For them, this is far morethan a mere blip in market fluctuation:

Developing countries, like teenagers, are prone to accidents. One pretty much expects them to suffer an economic crash, a political crisis, or both, with some regularity. The ing from Venezuela—including shortages as well as, most recently,riots over blackouts; the imposition of atwo-day workweekfor government employees, supposedly aimed at saving electricity; and an accelerating drive torecall the president—is dire, but also easy to dismiss as representing just one more of these recurrent episodes.

That would be a mistake. What our country is going through is monstrously unique: It’s nothing less than the collapse of a large, wealthy, seemingly modern, seemingly democratic nation just a few hours’ flight from the United States.

As for why all of this has happened, the reasons are varied plex. But as Naím and Toro explain, the core problems are primarily a result of top-down control and mismanagement:

It’s not that the country lacked money. Sitting atopthe world’s largest reserves of oilat the tail end of a frenzied oil boom, the government led first by Chavez and, since 2013, by Maduro, receivedover a trillion dollars in oil revenuesover the last 17 years. It faced virtually no institutional constraints on how to spend that unprecedented bonanza. It’s true that oil prices have since fallen—a risk many people foresaw, and one that the government made no provision for—but that can hardly explain what’s happened: Venezuela’s garish implosion began well before the price of oil plummeted. Back in 2014, when oil wasstill trading north of $100 per barrel, Venezuelans were alreadyfacing acute shortagesof basic things like bread or toiletries.

A case in point is the price controls, which have expanded to apply to more and more goods: food and vital medicines, yes, but also car batteries, essential medical services, deodorant, diapers, and, of course, toilet paper. The ostensible goal was to check inflation and keep goods affordable for the poor, but anyone with a basic grasp of economics could have foreseen the consequences: When prices are set below production costs, sellers can’t afford to keep the shelves stocked. Official prices are low, but it’s a mirage: The products have disappeared.

From here, we are led to the tangible heartbreak, including stories ranging from widespread hunger to poorhealthcare to the surprisingly serious problem of toilet-paper theft. We should pray forVenezuela:not only that they would find immediate relief, but that this grand,failing social experiment would cease.

So what might we learn from such a situation?

Althoughthe problems we face in the United States are distinct in their scope and scale, given the current crop of presidential candidates and the popularity they’ve enjoyed thus far, we would do well to pause and exude some caution toward “upgrades”such as these.

Bernie Sanders is at the top of thishill, of course, what with hisfull and shameless embrace of so-called “democratic socialism” (sound familiar, Hugo?). Regardless of itspeculiar and ill-fitted definition, we see an appetite to accelerate thosesame drivers of the Venezuelan collapse: trigger-happy price fixing, massive social programs, manipulations to currency, nationalization ofcorporations and industries, and the rest.

The logical conclusions of all of this havecolored recent history with big,darkstrokes, filling plenty of gulags and graveyards in the process. But for those not paying attention, it’s now on display once again.

Will Bernie’sleague of converts pay attention?

The hard lessons munism and socialism were learned long ago, but as we remember theirbrutal byproducts, let’s also resist these attempts to add “21-century” frosting to base authoritarianism, wherever and however it sprouts.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
‘Men, Some Say, Are Just Passé’
Christina Hoff Sommers, of American Enterprise Institute, takes on the idea of men being obsolete. Civilization now needs empathy, social intelligence, emotional knowledge – right? And that’s where females excel. So do we still need men? ...
What’s Wrong With Common Core? Let Teachers Tell You
I taught high school for a number of years, but as a religion teacher, I escaped most of the trials and tribulations my fellow teachers went through annually as new teaching methods were rolled out. Even private school teachers seem to get a new set of rules each year: teach this way, not that; use these techniques, not those. However, few teaching restrictions seem to be as questionable as Common Core. What about teachers? What are their thoughts on Common...
The Greatest ‘Privilege’ In America? Get Married, Stay Married
There is a lot of talk about “privilege” in our nation: white privilege, the privilege of the “1%,” privilege of living in one school district versus another. Yet, the greatest “privilege” in America is hardly ever mentioned. It’s a privilege that creates happy, healthy, smart kids, a privilege that helps ensure economic stability for everyone involved, a privilege that keeps our neighborhoods and cities safer and more productive. It’s marriage. (I was going to say “mah-widge” and give a Princess...
The Fortunate Son’s Secret to Success
It ain’t me, it ain’t me, I ain’t no senator’s son, son It ain’t me, it ain’t me, I ain’t no fortunate one, no “Fortunate Son” – Creedence Clearwater Revival What do Al Gore, George W. Bush, Mitt Romney, Barry Bonds, Peyton and Eli Manning, Aage Bohrs, and Michael Douglas all have mon? Each of them reached the same level of success as their fathers in a petitive field. We like to think that the U.S. is a meritocracy, a...
Video: Rev. Robert A. Sirico Interviewed on Argentinian Television – Poverty, Politics, and Pope Francis
Acton Institute President and Co-Founder Rev. Robert A. Sirico was in Argentina last week for Acton’s conference in Buenos Aires on Christianity and the Foundations of a Free Society, which is part of a series of Acton conferences being held around the world on the relationship between religious and economic freedom. While he was there, he was interviewed on Infobae.tvand spoke about the problems of poverty that Argentina is struggling with, and also addressed the relationship between Pope Francis and...
In Aleppo, Syria’s Christians See Assad Regime as Last Hope for Survival
A columnist for Al-Monitor who writes under the pseudonym Edward Dark visited Siryan Adeemeh, or Old Siryan, an elevated area in the regime-controlled west of Aleppo, the largest city in Syria. Dark wanted to “gauge the sentiment” of this area, which he describes as a working-class neighborhood home to Christian Arabs of several denominations and also inhabited by a sizable Muslim and Kurdish population. “It’s one of the few areas of Aleppo where churches outnumber mosques, munal relations had always...
P.J. O’Rourke Addresses the Supreme Court, References Full House, Gilmore Girls, and The Avengers
An amicus brief is a learned treatise submitted by anamicus curiae(Latin for “friend of the court”), someone who is not a party to a case who offers information that bears on the case but that has not been solicited by any of the parties to assist a court. The amicus brief is a way to introduce concerns ensuring that the possibly broad legal effects of a court decision will not depend solely on the parties directly involved in the case....
How Pollution Permits Help Reduce Pollution
A key way to reduce pollution is to provide a mechanism that allows some firms to pollute as much—or even more—than they normally would. That idea may sound ridiculous—reduce pollution by allowing pollution?—but it’s been proven to be a surprisingly effective means of cleaning up the environment. In 1990 amendments to the Clean Air Act were added which included market-based incentives to reduce pollution, such as “emissions permits” for certain pollutants. As Robert W. Crandall explains, These are, in effect,...
The Loneliness of the Fortunate
“Rembrandt The Hundred Guilder Print” by Rembrandt – www.rijksmuseum.nl: Home: Info. Licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons. “No, those who labor and are heavy-laden do not all look the way Rembrandt drew them in his ‘Hundred Guilder’ picture—poverty-stricken, miserable, sick, leprous, ragged, with worn, furrowed faces. They are also found concealed behind happy-looking, youthful faces and brilliantly successful lives. There are people who feel utterly forsaken in the midst of high society, to whom everything in their lives seems...
Video: 60 Minutes Looks at ISIS Destruction of Christianity in Iraq
“60 Minutes” correspondent Lara Logan interviewed Iraqi Christians for a report that aired March 22. There will be mercial embedded at the start off the video, but just get past it. Logan’s interview, and the images of the destruction wrought by ISIS, vividly illustrate what this persecution means for more than 125,000 of Iraq’s Christians who have abandoned homes, villages and churches in the face of this barbaric assault. She interviewed Nicodemus Sharaf, archbishop of the Syriac Orthodox Church in...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved