Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Today is Lord Acton’s 188th birthday. His philosophy should guide our next two centuries
Today is Lord Acton’s 188th birthday. His philosophy should guide our next two centuries
Jul 6, 2025 3:20 AM

Acton’s vision is the liberal vision, a vision of a society that is beyond the state. It sees individual souls above the state and that God rules it all through his providence. Acton’s vision is still worth defending and offers hope to us now in thesepolarizedand troubled times.

Read More…

Today, January 10, 2022, is Lord Acton’s 188th birthday. This difficult era ofa global pandemic,a crisis in institutions, andcivil unrestseems a strange time to look back on the life and legacy of a Victorian historian of ideas—but, asLord Acton himself remarked, “if the Past has been an obstacle and a burden, knowledge of the past is the safest and surest emancipation.” The freedom of the historian is the freedom to look beyond our own times to see the root causes of our current crises. The historian of ideas in particular isuniquely positioned to show us a path forwardthrough a crisis of institutions. “The history of institutions is often a history of deception and illusions; for their virtue depends on the ideas that produce and the spirit that preserves them, and the form may remain unaltered when the substance has passed away,” he wrote.

Many of the most contested and contentious questions of our social life are centered on the nature of liberty, a problem Lord Acton spent his life as a historian seeking to understand. Hebelieved that “no obstacle has been so constant, or so difficult to e, as uncertainty and confusion touching on the nature of liberty.”

Questions of the properresponse to the COVID-19 pandemic,civil upheaval,burgeoning public debt,corruption, andresurgent socialism and nationalismcan only be answered in the context of a proper view of freedom and responsibility. This proper view is at the center of Lord Acton’sdefinition of liberty: “By liberty I mean the assurance that every man shall be protected in doing what he believes his duty, against the influence of authority and majorities, customs and opinion.”

This notion of liberty as the unfolding of the idea of the dignity of the human person and his rights of conscience in history and politics is deeply Christian. With roots in the Hebrew prophets of old and the classical tradition, it isrevealed in its fullness in Jesus Christ:

The Stoics could only advise the wise man to hold aloof from politics, keeping the unwritten law in his heart. But when Christ said: “Render unto Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and unto God the things that are God’s,” those words, spoken on His last visit to the Temple, three days before His death, gave to the civil power, under the protection of conscience, a sacredness it had never enjoyed, and bounds it had never acknowledged; and they were the repudiation of absolutism and the inauguration of freedom.

This is what I like to call the liberal tradition, a tradition that locates ultimate sovereignty in people created in the image of God and endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights. It puts people, particularly individual consciences, at the center of our conception of the social order:

Our conscience exists and acts for ourselves. It exists in each of us. It is limited by the conscience of others. It is enough for oneself, not for another. It respects the conscience of others, Therefore it tends to restrict authority and enlarge liberty. It is the law of self government.

Actondraws out the political implicationsof this view beautifully:

The more es to the front, the more we consider not what the state plishes, but what it allows to be plished. Not the action of the state—its powers of action, and its use of them, but the limitation and division of those powers. The Society that is beyond the state—the individual souls that are above it.

This is not simply a naive individualism. Power is limited, but that does not mean there is no place for institutions munity in shaping the consciences of individuals:

Conscience: Do I decide or munity? If I, there is not authority. If they, there is no liberty. Some mediator wanted. That is the Church. Sustains alike liberty and authority.

We see Lord Acton’s vision in the guiding principles of theActon Institute, whose mission statement reads, “The Acton Institute is a think tank whose mission is to promote a free and virtuous society characterized by individual liberty and sustained by religious principles.” We are a think tank dedicated, like Lord Acton, to the proposition that ideas are fundamental. We promote freedom, as Lord Acton argued, as the highest political good. We realize that freedom is central, because it is necessary to virtue, to people fulfilling their duties of conscience. In this sense, when we speak of individual liberty, we are speaking of the reign of conscience. Authority, best embodied in religion, is necessary to form consciences, sustain liberty, and promote mon good.

We often think of Europe from the end of the Napoleonic Wars to the beginning of the First World War as the age of liberalism, and in many ways it was. But these liberal ideas were contested in Acton’s day as well as our own. The twin horrors of nationalism munism that dominated thegreater part of the 20th century had their seeds sown in Acton’s own 19th century. The 21st century—which many, following the collapse munism in Eastern Europe in 1989, believed to be the end of history and the beginning of a neoliberal order—has seen the reemergence of statist ideas in the forms of nationalism and socialism. These old and yet new challenges are ones the Acton Institute looks forward to engaging in 2022 and beyond.

We must realize thatdistinctions between church and state, as well as power and authority, are important. If those distinctions collapse, it will inevitably crush those unique individuals who bear the image of God beneath them. God created man, andno state can re-create him better. It can only twist, distort, and destroy human nature. Acton’s vision is the liberal vision, a vision of a society that is beyond the state. It sees individual souls above the state and that God rules it all through his providence. Acton’s vision is still worth defending and offers hope to us now in thesepolarizedand troubled times.Take and read!

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Unsanctified Mercy: Integrating Compassion and Conviction for Human Flourishing
Compassion is a marvelous virtue. Feeling concern for others and acting sacrificially — especially on behalf of those that cannot return the favor — reveals mature character and contributes to human flourishing. Compassion moves missionaries and monks to great efforts as they plant churches, pioneer institutions, and work for justice across cultures and geographies. Paul’s words are the motivation for his apostolic proclamation that, “…the love of pels us…” and, “one died for all, therefore all died. And those who...
Are We Better Off if We Buy Local?
Over the past few decades buying locally produced goods and services over those produced farther away has e increasingly fashionable. However, this “modern” trend is really a reversion to an earlier period when most all products were produced and bought from people in a localized area. For most of human history, “buying local” was the only option. There may be many reasons we may want to buy local goods and services—but improving the local economy is not one of them....
The Same-Sex Marriage Decision: Ruling by Judicial Fiat
The U.S. Supreme Court decided today that it is unconstitutional for a state to declare that marriage is only between one man and one woman. There is nothing in the Constitution that requires states to redefine marriage, but the Court decided that the Due Process Clause prohibits defining marriage as it has been defined for millennia just as it found a right to an abortion in the same Due Process Clause over 40 years ago. The role of the Court...
Mahoney: New Václav Havel biography is ‘moving and intelligent’
Daniel J. Mahoney reviewed Michael Zantovsky’s 2014 book Havel: A Life in the City Journal last week, calling it “a remarkable book about plex and genuinely admirable human being.” Václav Havel was a Czech writer, philosopher and dissident who served as the first democratically elected president of Czechoslovakia and then the first president of the Czech Republic. Zantovsky’s “moving and intelligent book guarantees that Havel’s monumental achievement will not soon be forgotten,” Mahoney writes. As Zantovsky shows, Havel was “one...
50 Key Quotes from the Supreme Court’s Same-Sex Marriage Ruling
The Supreme Court issued its ruling today on the case of Obergefell v. Hodges, legalizing same-sex marriage in all 50 states. (You can find our explainer article on the case here.) Justice Kennedy delivered the opinion of the Court, which was joined by Ginsburg, Breyer, Sotomayor, and Kagan. Justice Roberts filed a dissenting opinion, in which Scalia and Thomas joined. Scalia also wrote an opinion that was joined by Thomas. Thomas also filed a dissenting opinion that was joined by...
‘El Papa es imprudente al hablar de conjeturas científicas’
Sirico appearing on InfoBae TV in March. While at Acton University not too long ago, Buenos Aires journalistAdrián Bono sat down with Rev. Robert Sirico to discuss Laudato Si’. Bono recently wrote about his interview with Acton’s president and co-founder at Infobae. “Muchos no saben que la encíclica depende de la hermenéutica,” Sirico argued, “que significa cómo puede interpretada. No es un documento infalible.” Simply put, Laudato Si’ is not a binding document for Catholics, but many don’t understand that....
Taxing Churches (and other Charitable Non-Profits) is Un-American
Within 48 hours of the Supreme Court issuing its diktat on same-sex marriage, there were already calls for religious organizations that oppose gay marriage to lose their tax-exempt status. But Mark Oppenheimer goes even further. The writer of a regular column on religion for the New York Times argues in Time magazine that “the Supreme Court’s ruling on gay marriage makes it clearer than ever that the government shouldn’t be subsidizing religion and non-profits.” There is a lot that could...
Fifteen Theological Foundations of Stewardship from ‘A Biblical Perspective on Environmental Stewardship’
Since its publication in 2007, the Acton Institute’s Environmental Stewardship in the Judeo-Christian Tradition has been one go-to source for religious thought on environmental stewardship. The following list gathers information from “A Biblical Perspective on Environmental Stewardship,” an essay from the book that offers the Christian perspective on humanity’s place in nature. 1. God, the Creator of all things, rules over all and deserves our worship and adoration (Ps. 103:19—22). 2. The earth, and, with it, all the cosmos, reveals...
Big Oil Advocacy for Carbon Taxes
Today at The Federalist I explore “Why Big Oil Wants A Carbon Tax.” Perhaps such advocacy isn’t just made out of a sense of global citizenship and environmental stewardship. On the surface such advocacy may seem counter-intuitive. Why on earth, other than out of selfless benevolence, would a firm (or group of firms) advocate for higher taxes on their products? But on reflection, it makes some sense, and the reasoning is similar to why an online retailer like Amazon might...
Seven Judaic Points from ‘The Spiritual Nature of Human Work’
The Acton Institute’s 2007 book Environmental Stewardship in the Judeo-Christian Tradition offers insight on Jewish theology as it connects to creation and our place in the world. The following list provides seven key quotes from “The Spiritual Nature of Human Work,” an essay in the book written by Jewish scholars. 1. The religious Jew has much appreciation for the beauty of nature. We are filled with gratitude for these natural treats to our senses that are also natural treats to...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved