Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The ‘Great Repeal Bill’ and the long shadow of EU law
The ‘Great Repeal Bill’ and the long shadow of EU law
Jul 12, 2025 2:03 AM

Millions had assumed that Brexit meant that, in the words of Prime Minister Theresa May,“our laws will be made in Westminster, Edinburgh, Cardiff, and Belfast.” But the government has announced that it will continue to be bound by thousands of EU regulations, passed in Brussels, for the foreseeable future.

The revelation is part of the government white paperon the ing“Great Repeal Bill.” It will revoke the European Communities Act of 1972,the legislation that maintains the UK’s membership in the EU. But it will also adopt the entire body of EU law into the UK’s legal code, where it will remain in force until the day when (or if) each individual measure is changed or repealed.

The size and scope of this legal corpus – known as the “acquis” – is hard to convey. One study from Thomson Reuters estimates that the EU has passed 52,741 pieces of legislation since 1990, including 6,718 laws that affect the UK since 2010.The governmentplaces the figure much lower, at more than 12,000, while other sources list the number of Brussels’ regulations at 19,000.

That alone does not do justice to the shadow that four decades of remote, international government will cast over the UK’s economic future.The EU regulates such minute tasks as:

“the collection, processing, storage and transport of [pig] semen”;the proper curvature of bananas; andthe exact levels of vehicle noise emission.

No fewer than 41 directives deal with the treatment of animals.European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker recently boasted that the EU finally gave up a bid to regulate the flushing of toilets.

Everyday consumers have already paid a steep price for EU overregulation, whether they stem from the best motivations (worker safety, environmental preservation) or the worst (special interest lobbying and ideological extremism).

The think tank Open Europe calculated that EU regulations siphoned £13 billion ($16.2 billion U.S.) out of the UK’s economy a year.The Telegraph reports that the EU’s Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), which placeshigh tariffs on imported food, “reportedly costs £10 billion in direct costs and by inflating food prices” annually. These analyses do not includeanother estimated 14.3 percent of all acts passed by the UK’s Parliament from 1980 to 2009, which “incorporated a degree of EU influence.”

By freeing itself of EU regulation, the UK can manifest another kind of European economic culture: one that frees the wealth-creating powers of the private sector by valuing innovation, growth,dynamism, initiative, entrepreneurship, subsidiarity, choice, and the traditional charitable role of intermediary institutions. This contrasts sharply with Brussels’ economic culture: one that empowers global governance institutions by valuing regulation, preservation of the economic status quo, stability, bureaucracy pliableto the lobbying of labor unions and special interest constituencies, public-private “partnerships,” centralization, and the social assistance (welfare) state.

Why would London wish to maintain this edifice after declaring independence? Should it do otherwise, the government warns, “UK’s statute book would contain significant gaps once we left the EU.”

That is precisely what many British experts hope for. “Brexit gives us the opportunity: all regulations, but not directives, will fall away automatically,” writes Tim Ambler at the Adam Smith Institute’s blog.“The Great Repeal Bill White Paper has it the wrong way round: we should let them all go and invite Whitehall to re-present those we really need.”

That would bring government ever-closer to the electorate. The white paper envisions a nation in which “power sits closer to the people of the UK than ever before” through “a significant increase in the decision making power of each devolved administration.” Former Environmental Secretary Owen Patterson says clearing out EU regulation allows the British people to settle upon a path that is “tailored to what is right for us.”

That is the heart of subsidiarity, the social justice principle that no function should be undertaken by a higher level of government that can be handled by a lower order.

However, the government faces opposition within and without. Up to 1,000 EU statutes must be updated in order to work with the post-Brexit legal code. The government is asking Parliament for a form of deferred authority to rewrite them, invoking the “Henry VII clauses.” This has invited considerable skepticism – and concern that the Tory government will deregulate too much for the Labour Party’s liking.

Ironically, UK Parliament is invoking subsidiarity to defend the concentration of power at the international level.

The EU also has no interest in a dynamic post-Brexit Britain that thrives after cutting ties – or petes with it globally. European Council President Donald Tusk announced that, should the UK ask for a transition period to smooth the exit process for businesses, Brussels will demand that all EU “regulatory, budgetary, supervisory and enforcement instruments and structures [continue] to apply.”Germany’s deputy economy minister has insisted that post-Brexit London adopt a “reasonable framework” of tax and regulation, because “a race to the bottom in tax and regulation matters”– the Eurosocialists’ term for freeing the economy from government intervention – “would make trade relations difficult.” The EU27 hope to impose enough regulatory burden on the UK’s economy to petition globally.

The scene calls to mind the words of the priest and philosopher Antonio Rosmini, who died more than a century before the founding of the EEC, the predecessor of the EU. “These legislators are inclined to let the government into all those enterprises that should be freely left to private industry,” he wrote, “because they care very little about the damage that is caused to private entrepreneurs and to capitalists.” (Quoted in Hoevel, “The Fiscal and Tributary Philosophy of Antonio Rosmini,” Journal of Markets and Morality, Spring 2007.)

By heeding his words, the UK could show the transatlantic sphere a better model – and its people a future of greater flourishing.

This photo has been modified for size. CC BY 2.0.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
5 facts about the Russian Revolution
This week is the hundredth anniversary of the second Russian Revolution, one of the most transformative political events in the history of the modern world. Here are five facts you should know about the world’s most destructive revolution: 1. The second Russian Revolution (the Bolshevik Revolution) began on November 6 and 7, 1917. (Because the Russians were still using the Julian calendar, the date for them was October 24 and 25, which is why the event is often referred to...
Edmund Burke, free marketer
It’s not just millennials and other young people who are souring on free markets (44 percent according to a new poll) — there’s also a growing disenchantment among some conservatives. Acton Research Director Samuel Gregg explains the conservative angst as rooted, among other things, in the threat that upheaval in market economies presents to the “permanency, order, tradition, and strong and munities.” Conservatives who advocate for free markets should take this critique seriously and “rethink about how to integrate their...
Renewed covenant or populism? Rabbi Lord Sacks on the West’s alternatives
The deepest division running through the West is not between Right and Left, or liberty and collectivism. Western civilization must choose this day whether it is grounded in a covenant or a degraded and authoritarian form of populism, according to the former Chief Rabbi of the UK. While receiving AEI’s highest honor, Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks distinguished between two rival views of society derived from his exegesis of I Samuel 8. A social contract creates a government, while a covenant...
From the Reformation to Austrian economics
The implications of the Reformation are more than ecclesiastical or theological, says Timothy Terrell,professor of economics at Wofford College in Spartanburg, South Carolina. They include shifts in economic thought as well, and Protestant ideas have had a lasting impact on our way of thinking about markets and liberty. There is, of course, no one religious—or irreligious—group that can claim to have birthed Austrian economics, and certainly Protestants, Catholics, Jews, atheists, and others have had a part in its development. However,...
100 years of false religion
Today – November 7, 2017 – marks the hundredth anniversary of the Russian Revolution, touching off worldwide events mourning or celebrating the event. At its centenary, Communism deserves to be remembered as the most successful false religion to take root in the West in two millennia, unparalleled in the swiftness of its destruction and unequaled in its potential to generate misery from abundance. Communism determined to overthrow the entire Judeo-Christian cosmology 100 years ago today. Karl Marx’s promise of an...
Is education signaling or skill building?
Note: This is post #55 in a weekly video series on basic microeconomics. Do you learn about things, because the learning itself matters, or is education all about the signal you—and your degree—send out to the world? Is education really about building skills, or does it serve only to transmit intangible traits, like your level of talent or your persistence? In this video by Marginal Revolution University, economists Tyler Cowen and Alex Tabarrok debate these questions and consider education’s effect...
Unemployment as economic-spiritual indicator — October 2017 report
Series Note: Jobs are one of the most important aspects of a morally functioning economy. They help us serve the needs of our neighbors and lead to human flourishing both for the individual and munities. Conversely, not having a job can adversely affect spiritual and psychological well-being of individuals and families. Because unemployment is a spiritual problem, Christians in America need to understand and be aware of the monthly data on employment. Each month highlight the latest numbers we need...
Rev. Sirico and R.R. Reno to debate the merits of the free market
Over the past year there has been an ongoing debate carried out online in outlets like the Acton Institute blog, Public Discourse, and First Things magazine over the legitimacy of free markets. Many of us advocates of the free market have been dismayed at the openness—if not outright embrace—of socialism as a better option than free enterprise by conservative Christians. A prime example is the recent essay by First Things editor R. R. Reno revisiting Michael Novak’s 1990 classic The...
Spain: Remembering the forgotten Red Terror
As the world remembers the hundredth anniversary of the Bolshevik Revolution, memorates the thousands of Christians martyred by the Communists during the Spanish Red Terror. Historian Stanley G. Payne calledthis periodthe “most extensive and violent persecution of Catholicism in Western history, in some way even more intense than that of the French Revolution.” Every November 6, the Roman Catholic Church in Spain remembers those martyred for their faith by socialists during this anti-Christian persecution, whichpeaked at the outset of the...
Millennials in America have a troubling view of communism and socialism
“We discovered a rampant amnesia about the crimes munist regimes,” says Marion Smith, “and a growing inclination among younger Americans toward favorable views munism and socialism.” Their latest survey was recently released—and the responses are just as troubling: • 7 in 10 Millennials (like most Americans) either don’t know the definition munism or misidentify it for socialism. • 7 out of 10 underestimate number killed munism. Less than one third know more than 100 million people were killed munism. •...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved