Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The ‘Great Repeal Bill’ and the long shadow of EU law
The ‘Great Repeal Bill’ and the long shadow of EU law
May 21, 2025 1:38 AM

Millions had assumed that Brexit meant that, in the words of Prime Minister Theresa May,“our laws will be made in Westminster, Edinburgh, Cardiff, and Belfast.” But the government has announced that it will continue to be bound by thousands of EU regulations, passed in Brussels, for the foreseeable future.

The revelation is part of the government white paperon the ing“Great Repeal Bill.” It will revoke the European Communities Act of 1972,the legislation that maintains the UK’s membership in the EU. But it will also adopt the entire body of EU law into the UK’s legal code, where it will remain in force until the day when (or if) each individual measure is changed or repealed.

The size and scope of this legal corpus – known as the “acquis” – is hard to convey. One study from Thomson Reuters estimates that the EU has passed 52,741 pieces of legislation since 1990, including 6,718 laws that affect the UK since 2010.The governmentplaces the figure much lower, at more than 12,000, while other sources list the number of Brussels’ regulations at 19,000.

That alone does not do justice to the shadow that four decades of remote, international government will cast over the UK’s economic future.The EU regulates such minute tasks as:

“the collection, processing, storage and transport of [pig] semen”;the proper curvature of bananas; andthe exact levels of vehicle noise emission.

No fewer than 41 directives deal with the treatment of animals.European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker recently boasted that the EU finally gave up a bid to regulate the flushing of toilets.

Everyday consumers have already paid a steep price for EU overregulation, whether they stem from the best motivations (worker safety, environmental preservation) or the worst (special interest lobbying and ideological extremism).

The think tank Open Europe calculated that EU regulations siphoned £13 billion ($16.2 billion U.S.) out of the UK’s economy a year.The Telegraph reports that the EU’s Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), which placeshigh tariffs on imported food, “reportedly costs £10 billion in direct costs and by inflating food prices” annually. These analyses do not includeanother estimated 14.3 percent of all acts passed by the UK’s Parliament from 1980 to 2009, which “incorporated a degree of EU influence.”

By freeing itself of EU regulation, the UK can manifest another kind of European economic culture: one that frees the wealth-creating powers of the private sector by valuing innovation, growth,dynamism, initiative, entrepreneurship, subsidiarity, choice, and the traditional charitable role of intermediary institutions. This contrasts sharply with Brussels’ economic culture: one that empowers global governance institutions by valuing regulation, preservation of the economic status quo, stability, bureaucracy pliableto the lobbying of labor unions and special interest constituencies, public-private “partnerships,” centralization, and the social assistance (welfare) state.

Why would London wish to maintain this edifice after declaring independence? Should it do otherwise, the government warns, “UK’s statute book would contain significant gaps once we left the EU.”

That is precisely what many British experts hope for. “Brexit gives us the opportunity: all regulations, but not directives, will fall away automatically,” writes Tim Ambler at the Adam Smith Institute’s blog.“The Great Repeal Bill White Paper has it the wrong way round: we should let them all go and invite Whitehall to re-present those we really need.”

That would bring government ever-closer to the electorate. The white paper envisions a nation in which “power sits closer to the people of the UK than ever before” through “a significant increase in the decision making power of each devolved administration.” Former Environmental Secretary Owen Patterson says clearing out EU regulation allows the British people to settle upon a path that is “tailored to what is right for us.”

That is the heart of subsidiarity, the social justice principle that no function should be undertaken by a higher level of government that can be handled by a lower order.

However, the government faces opposition within and without. Up to 1,000 EU statutes must be updated in order to work with the post-Brexit legal code. The government is asking Parliament for a form of deferred authority to rewrite them, invoking the “Henry VII clauses.” This has invited considerable skepticism – and concern that the Tory government will deregulate too much for the Labour Party’s liking.

Ironically, UK Parliament is invoking subsidiarity to defend the concentration of power at the international level.

The EU also has no interest in a dynamic post-Brexit Britain that thrives after cutting ties – or petes with it globally. European Council President Donald Tusk announced that, should the UK ask for a transition period to smooth the exit process for businesses, Brussels will demand that all EU “regulatory, budgetary, supervisory and enforcement instruments and structures [continue] to apply.”Germany’s deputy economy minister has insisted that post-Brexit London adopt a “reasonable framework” of tax and regulation, because “a race to the bottom in tax and regulation matters”– the Eurosocialists’ term for freeing the economy from government intervention – “would make trade relations difficult.” The EU27 hope to impose enough regulatory burden on the UK’s economy to petition globally.

The scene calls to mind the words of the priest and philosopher Antonio Rosmini, who died more than a century before the founding of the EEC, the predecessor of the EU. “These legislators are inclined to let the government into all those enterprises that should be freely left to private industry,” he wrote, “because they care very little about the damage that is caused to private entrepreneurs and to capitalists.” (Quoted in Hoevel, “The Fiscal and Tributary Philosophy of Antonio Rosmini,” Journal of Markets and Morality, Spring 2007.)

By heeding his words, the UK could show the transatlantic sphere a better model – and its people a future of greater flourishing.

This photo has been modified for size. CC BY 2.0.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The persistent advantage of private virtue
Several years ago, in a discussion on Charles Murray’s bookComing Apart, Ross Douthat included a brilliant observation about what he dubs the “persistent advantage of private virtue“: Finally, Murray makes a very convincing case . . . for the power of so-called “traditional values” to foster human flourishing even in economic landscapes that aren’t as favorable to less-educated workers as was, say, the aftermath of the Treaty of Detroit. Even acknowledging all the challenges (globalization, the decline of manufacturing, mass...
Appreciating the importance of vocational education
If there is one thing young people believe in collectively, it is their individuality. “No two people are alike,” the refrain goes. But in the age of Common Core, educational systems too often treat all students alike, glossing over their unique skills and abilities. A top-down, cookie-cutter curriculum and the decline of vocational education have left too many children, on both sides of the Atlantic, without an ability to exercise their gifts. Erik Lidström, who has written extensively on educational...
6 Quotes: C.S. Lewis on government, economics, and freedom
The beloved novelist and Christian thinker C. S. Lewis was born on Nov. 29, 1898, in Belfast, Ireland. In honor of his 119th birthday, here are six quotes from Lewis on government, economics, and freedom: On democratic government: “I am a democrat because I believe in the Fall of Man. I think most people are democrats for the opposite reason. A great deal of democratic enthusiasm descends from the ideas of people like Rousseau, who believed in democracy because they...
Why increasing job safety lowers workers wages
Note: This is post #58 in a weekly video series on basic microeconomics. Here’s a surprising fact: Firms have an incentive to increase job safety, because then they can lower wages. In this video by Marginal Revolution University, economist Alex Tabarrok explores this claim in much greater depth and answers the questions: Why do riskier jobs often pay more? Why has job safety increased over the years? How does a firm’s profit motive play a role? (If you find the...
Wealth creation within global cultural perspectives
Economic development is a key aspect of culture—and at the same time, a challenge to cultural norms. How should Christians reconcile such tension? What is culture’s impact upon the biblical mandate to create wealth for holistic transformation? Earlier this year two evangelical groups, theLausanne MovementandBAM Global, released apaper exploringwealth creation within global cultural perspectives to address these and other questions about culture and wealth creation. In particular, the paper examines the ‘anthropological temptation’: the temptation to idolize culture, and to...
Transatlantic intelligence: Fast facts on the UK Budget 2017
As Americans made their final arrangements for Thanksgiving, UK Chancellor of the Exchequer Philip Hammond unveiled the annual Budget on Wednesday. Here’s what you need to know. The Budget will spend a total of £809 billion ($1 trillion U.S.), adding £41 billion to the national debt. It makes two policy changes to address the housing shortage, the most important issue to young Brits. Hammond pledged £15.3 billion to build 300,000 homes a year – but none on the so-called greenbelt,...
Russia still denies the Holodomor was ‘genocide’
Saturday marked “Holodomor Remembrance Day,” honoring the millions of Ukrainians who died of forced starvation at the hands of the Soviets in the 1930s. Some 80 years later, and a quarter-century after the Soviet Union’s dissolution, the Russian government still denies that this atrocity constitutes a “genocide.” Two days earlier – Thanksgiving Day in the U.S. – Russian Foreign Ministry Spokesperson Maria Zakharova told the international press that the Ukrainian government’s use of the phrase “the genocide of Ukrainians” is...
Natural rights revisited during Salamanca University’s 800th anniversary
Note: Some PowerBlog readers might be wondering why the Acton Institute is holding a Rome, Italy, conference on November 29:Globalization, Justice, and the Economy on 16th and 17th Century Spanish scholasticism (The conference will be broadcast on LiveStream. More information here.) Below is an overview of the importance of this school of thought and the historical implications for the nascent era of globalization. With a royal charter established in 1218, a vibrant cathedral school became the Universidad de Salamanca, the...
Why we need the profit system
There is a paradox when es to profits, says economist Arnold Kling: while the profits that accrue to any given individual may be unjust, the profit system itself is necessary in order to have a modern, progressive society. There is no simple way for us to enjoy the benefits of the system while ing all of the instances of injustice. Yet despite the injustice, says Kling, the profit system is the most effective, humane way to organize economic activity. The...
Against canned food drives: When gift-giving is wasteful
During a season such as Christmas, when hyper-consumerism and hyper-generosity often converge in strange and mysterious ways, how much of our gift-giving is inefficient or wasteful? It’s a question that economists continue to ponder, but to which many a gift-giver is prone to shrug. In one sense, isn’t the whole pointto mirror the most extravagant gift of all? Why be concerned about “wasteful” giving? But if the starting points of our generosity e decidedly apathetic or misaligned with actual human...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved