Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Eroding judicial activism (more than) one nation at a time
Eroding judicial activism (more than) one nation at a time
Dec 16, 2025 9:04 AM

Judicial activism is a transatlantic problem. Thus, it requires a transatlantic analysis. The Acton Institute has helped link English-speaking citizens concerned with preserving the Constitution in a conversation with the world’s 270 million Francophones.

Last month, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the 1964 Civil Rights Act included sexual orientation and gender identity, paving the way for new rounds of lawsuits and potentially rendering it impossible for some employers to operate their businesses in accordance with their faith. The justices’ conceit of rewriting statutory law threatens the rule of law itself — a verity as true in the U.S. as in France, the UK, or the European Union.

French courts have recently decimated Uber’s business model by ruling that drivers are bona fide employees, not independent contractors. The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom proved all-too-willing to assist the Remain campaign‘s endless series of parliamentary delays and administrative hurdles to Brexit. And the European Court of Justice has vitiated laws and protections long considered sacrosanct, including the right of a religious institution to act according to its own moral code.

These and other rulings erode the rule of law by calling into question its fixed character and permanence — and hence, throw everyone into uncertainty about how the law will be applied each time a new administration takes power. Trey Dimsdale makes this point eloquently in his Acton Commentary, “The Supreme Court’s transgender ruling undermines the rule of law,” just translated into French for the Acton Institute’s Religion & Liberty Transatlantic website by Benoît H. Perrin. Dimsdale writes:

Cette porte des implications importantes pour l’autodétermination démocratique de la nation américaine et les droits inaliénables des Américains. La Cour a certifié que la liberté religieuse n’a pas été prise pte dans cette affaire, de sorte que ni la loi sur la restauration de la liberté religieuse (RFRA), ni les droits exclusifs des églises à consacrer leur propre clergé, tels que reconnus par la Cour dans l’affaire «Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church & School contre EEOC », ne sont en péril. Il est cependant difficile de s’en remettre à cette déclaration, étant donné la facilité avec laquelle six juges ont sapé l’ordre constitutionnel et réécrit le Civil Rights Act de 1964.

You can read the full translation here.

UK Supreme Court. )

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Calvin Coolidge: A Rare Kind of Hero
Calvin Coolidge is ripe for national recognition and his wisdom is being sought out perhaps now more than ever. If you’re a voracious reader mentary and columns you’ve noticed mon sense adages are being unearthed at a rapid pace. Most of the credit and recognition for the Coolidge revival goes to Amity Shlaes. Her newly released and splendid biography Coolidge can’t be mended enough. (Full review on the PowerBlog ing) Coolidge was the last president to oversee federal budget surpluses...
The Image of God and the Dignity of Work
Being made in the image of God, says Art Lindsley, is a powerful concept for finding our vocations and living a purposeful life. While the image of God remains after the Fall, it is certainly marred and defaced. As we are redeemed, what will we look like when the process pleted? As God restores us, our unique design in the image of God will shine even more brightly, and our gifts will reach their full potential. We will also look...
Black Marriage Matters
Brittney C. Cooper, Assistant professor of Women’s and Gender studies and Africana Studies at Rutgers University, writes at Ebony that President Obama is being unfair to the munity by pointing out that many of the violence-related pathologies in inner cities are a result of fatherlessness. Cooper objects saying, Instead when the president began by suggesting that we need to “do more to promote marriage and encourage fatherhood,” I started shaking my head. Rather than empathizing with those Black families that...
Toiling for Pharaoh
My friend John Teevan of Grace College sends out a monthly newsletter, “Economic Prospect.” He passes along this in the current edition: I found this note from a newly retired accountant (age 66) who has not gone on social security yet. His e as a part-time accountant in his town was $60,000. “My e is $60,000 and my IRS taxes are 10,000, my FICA deduction is $8,000, my state e tax is $2500, and my property tax is $6000. So...
Radio Free Acton Podcast: Reflecting on the Legacy of Pope Benedict XVI Part 2
The latest Radio Free Acton Podcast is part 2 of “Reflecting on the Legacy of Pope Benedict.” Director of Research Samuel Gregg and Research Fellow Michael Matheson Miller discuss the ing papal conclave. They explain the process that will be used to choose Benedict XVI’s successor and what should be on the cardinals minds as they go about this process. Click the play button below to enjoy the podcast: ...
Commentary: Is America the Federal Government?
“While president, Calvin Coolidge warned Americans that if it was thefederalgovernment that came to their mind when they thought of ‘the government,’ it would prove costly,” writes Ray Nothstine in this week’s Acton Commentary. But as Nothstine points out,everywhere we turn the federal government is increasingly visible and intrusive.The full text of his essay follows. Subscribe to the free, weekly Acton News & Commentary and other publicationshere. Is America the Federal Government? byRay Nothstine Writing about his observations of America...
From the Roots of Society to the Fruits of Discipleship
I recently wrote about the need to reach beyond an earthbound economics, re-orienting our thinking around a more transcendent framework that requires active spiritual engagement and discernment. Even as Christians, far too often we set our focus too strongly on temporal features like material needs, happiness, and quality of life—all of e into play accordingly—without first concerning ourselves with what God is actually calling us to do as individuals. Transcendent ends will e from transcendent beginnings, and those beginnings will...
How to Become Pope
While most Catholics are likely to already be familiar with the process, my fellow Protestants will likely find this video on how the pope is selected to be helpful and informative. ...
Vice, Virtue, and Shareholder Activism
King Louis XIV censored Moliere’s 1664 play Tartuffe after determining audience members might too easily confuse the titular priest’s hypocritical nature with every priest in real life. According to the king, some priests’ “true devotion leads on the path to heaven,” while others’ “vain ostentation of some good works does not prevent mitting some bad ones.” The king’s judgment in many ways also describes individuals who pursue their religious vocations while simultaneously championing secular causes such as proxy shareholder resolutions....
Check Your Rhetoric: What Common Good?
According to Daly, Soviet government sought to dictate every aspect of life in the name of mon good, including the indexing of Soviet publications by libraries. He writes, “[I]f Soviet publications failed to end up in libraries, then, as Lenin railed, ‘we have to know precisely whom to imprison.'”In the Winter-Fall 2012 issue of Modern Age (54, nos. 1-4), Jonathan Daly contributes a helpful exploration of what happens when desire for mon good goes bad. His article, “Bolshevik Power and...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved