Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Eroding judicial activism (more than) one nation at a time
Eroding judicial activism (more than) one nation at a time
Aug 27, 2025 7:50 AM

Judicial activism is a transatlantic problem. Thus, it requires a transatlantic analysis. The Acton Institute has helped link English-speaking citizens concerned with preserving the Constitution in a conversation with the world’s 270 million Francophones.

Last month, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the 1964 Civil Rights Act included sexual orientation and gender identity, paving the way for new rounds of lawsuits and potentially rendering it impossible for some employers to operate their businesses in accordance with their faith. The justices’ conceit of rewriting statutory law threatens the rule of law itself — a verity as true in the U.S. as in France, the UK, or the European Union.

French courts have recently decimated Uber’s business model by ruling that drivers are bona fide employees, not independent contractors. The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom proved all-too-willing to assist the Remain campaign‘s endless series of parliamentary delays and administrative hurdles to Brexit. And the European Court of Justice has vitiated laws and protections long considered sacrosanct, including the right of a religious institution to act according to its own moral code.

These and other rulings erode the rule of law by calling into question its fixed character and permanence — and hence, throw everyone into uncertainty about how the law will be applied each time a new administration takes power. Trey Dimsdale makes this point eloquently in his Acton Commentary, “The Supreme Court’s transgender ruling undermines the rule of law,” just translated into French for the Acton Institute’s Religion & Liberty Transatlantic website by Benoît H. Perrin. Dimsdale writes:

Cette porte des implications importantes pour l’autodétermination démocratique de la nation américaine et les droits inaliénables des Américains. La Cour a certifié que la liberté religieuse n’a pas été prise pte dans cette affaire, de sorte que ni la loi sur la restauration de la liberté religieuse (RFRA), ni les droits exclusifs des églises à consacrer leur propre clergé, tels que reconnus par la Cour dans l’affaire «Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church & School contre EEOC », ne sont en péril. Il est cependant difficile de s’en remettre à cette déclaration, étant donné la facilité avec laquelle six juges ont sapé l’ordre constitutionnel et réécrit le Civil Rights Act de 1964.

You can read the full translation here.

UK Supreme Court. )

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Connecting France with good economics
It seems that it may be possible. An interesting article from yesterday’s International Herald Tribune: Danielle Scache tries to avoid using the term “capitalism” in her economics class because it has negative connotations in France. Instead, she teaches her high school students about the market economy, a slightly less controversial term she started using last year after a two-month internship at the dairy giant Danone. That was an experience that did away with more than one of her own prejudices,...
Immigration is a symptom
Large numbers of migrant populations going out of a particular area or nation should be viewed in large part as a signal of something. There are reasons for people to pick up and move, and policy and governing bodies would do well to examine these reasons. When business close facilities and open elsewhere, it is usually because the destination location has a better economic and business-friendly environment. So the natural course of action when examining this phenomena is to ask...
AIDS: not that bad?
Bryan Caplan at EconLog says that he has long wondered about the validity of the statistics of the spread of AIDS on the African continent: The whole story had a quasi-Soviet flavor to it. The main difference: Soviet growth statistics were too good to be true, while African AIDS statistics were too bad to be true. Reflecting on the incentives cemented my skepticism: Just as the Soviet Union had a strong incentive to exaggerate its growth numbers in order to...
Chirac waves the white flag
French President Jacques Chirac has given in to the student protests in his country, protests that called for the removal of the First Employment Contract. This is a controversial new law giving employers greater freedom in whom they fire amongst under-26 employees. The law, as I am sure you’ve seen, sparked students protests for weeks. Michael Miller in last Wednesday’s Acton News and Commentary addressed the deeper issue here: economic ignorance and moral apathy–I won’t repeat his analysis here. But...
The sweetness of the Law
menting briefly on Psalm 19, C. S. Lewis observes the description of God’s Law as “sweeter than honey” and “more precious than gold,” the kind of descriptions that occur again and again throughout the Psalter. Lewis writes, In so far as this idea of the Law’s beauty, sweetness, or pireciousness, arose from the contrast of the surrounding Paganisms, we may soon find occasion to recover it. Christians increasingly live on a spiritual island; new and rival ways of life surround...
First Things imbroglio
A former editor at First Things, Damon Linker, has written a piece for The New Republic, which attacks, among others, his former boss, Fr. Richard John Neuhaus. Linker claims that Neuhaus is a “theocon,” who wants to merge religious authority and political power. Rick Garnett at Mirror of Justice has all the details, including links to blog discussions and his previous post, criticizing Linker’s argument. I’ve read First Things for years and, in my judgment, the truth lies with Linker’s...
Surprise! Evangelical politics isn’t univocal
“Letter on Immigration Deepens Split Among Evangelicals,” trumpets a story from the Washington Post. Ever since evangelicals received such credit in the election and reelection of George W. Bush, the ins and outs of evangelical politics has recieved a greater share of media attention. A great part of this attention has focused on so-called “splits” among evangelicals, as a way to highlight the newly recognized reality that all evangelicals aren’t card-carrying Republicans. So from issues like immigration to global warming,...
‘Overwhelmed by orphans’
Where will they go? Churches and religious relief organizations are playing a much more active role in U.S. foreign policy. And that has been obvious in recent months in the recovery efforts for the South Asian tsunami and the Pakistan earthquakes. In March, the Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life invited Andrew Natsios, who recently left the U.S. Agency for International Development as chief administrator, to talk about his five-year term there. This is a must-read for anyone who...
Catholics on immigration
Jordan’s post below observes the divisions among evangelicals on the hot-button issue of immigration. Its divisiveness—cutting across the usual lines of conservative/liberal and Democrat/Republican—has made the immigration debate an unusual and therefore extraordinarily interesting one. The issue also divides Catholics. Los Angeles Cardinal Roger Mahony has been among the most promising national voices in favor of immigrant rights. But ments have not gone unchallenged among Catholics. Activist Jim Gilchrist denounced Mahony’s views. Kathryn-Jean Lopez at NRO questioned them more delicately....
French ‘security’ and economic reality
As student demonstrations in France mount, the government finds it increasingly difficult to dismantle restrictive labor laws that are directly tied to high unemployment rates. Michael Miller examines the political and cultural factors that are behind the French fear of economic risk taking. Read mentary here. ...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved