Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
Eliot, Kirk and the moral imagination
Eliot, Kirk and the moral imagination
May 13, 2026 3:01 PM

The following is adapted from a speech on the occasion of the republication of Russell Kirk's Eliot and His Age, given to the Intercollegiate Studies Institute student group at Central Michigan University in September 2008.

What makes T. S. Eliot and Russell Kirk so important that we should be here tonight to discuss them? Well, for one, both fathered "ages"--the twentieth century was, according to Kirk, "The Age of Eliot" and Kirk himself inaugurated the contem- porary Conservative Age with the publication of The Conservative Mind in the early 1950s. Both men recognized that there is no culture without cult, cult in this instance, for Kirk, "a joining together for worship--that is, the attempt of people mune with a transcendent power. It is from association in the cult, the body of worshippers, that munity grows." Additionally, both Eliot and Kirk agreed that a worldview is only viable inasmuch as it reflects what Edmund Burke called the moral imagination, which he defined as, "the power of ethical perception which strides beyond the barriers of private experience and events of the moment--especially the higher form of this power exercised in poetry and art."

For Eliot, the moral imagination derived from his Anglo-Catholicism; for Kirk, his Roman Catholicism. Devoid of moral imagination, all systems--political, social, economic, familial and spiritual--are bound to fail. True conservatives, both men believed, place moral considerations ahead of ideology. In fact, both held that true conservatism is the negation of ideology.

Dr. Benjamin Lockerd, in his excellent new preface to Eliot and His Age, quotes Kirk: "Recovery of moral understanding cannot be merely a means to social restoration: it must be its own end, though it will produce social consequences. In the words of T.S. Eliot, 'If you will not have God (and he is a jealous God) you should pay your respects to Hitler or Stalin.'" Eliot hints at this jealous God in his verse play, "Murder in the Cathedral":

Those who put their faith in worldly order. Not controlled by the order of God, in confident ignorance, but arrest disorder. Make it fast, breed fatal disease, Degrade what they exalt.

Eliot witnessed the results of catastrophically destructive ideologies. He had seen nationalistic fervor ignite the conflagration of world wars; he had seen the passion for atheistic "social justice" strip whole populations from nations; he had witnessed members of his own generation embrace fascism and members of the succeeding generation embrace Marxist solutions; he had witnessed the tremendous sway of Freud and Jung, which had pointed the way to so many blind alleys for so many writers of so-called Modernist sensibilities.

Revisiting Eliot's works--and being able to do so with Kirk's invaluable guidance-- serves to remind readers that nurturing one's mind also nurtures one's character, and that chasing after utopian goals as ideologues often do is a fool's errand. As Kirk wrote about Eliot's masterpiece, "The Four Quartets":

Ideology, it must be remembered, is the attempt to supplant religious dogmas by political and scientistic dogmas. If one's first premise is that religion must be a snare and a delusion, for instance, then it follows that Eliot es an enemy to be assaulted, rather than a pilgrim whose journey one may admir--even if one does not believe in the goal of that quest. Truly there exists such a state as the invincible ignorance of the learned. If Liberalism, or Socialism, or Communism, has e a god-word, not to be questioned; if Science has e an uncritical faith, amounting really to Scientism-- then the captive of ideology will be unable to read with understanding what Eliot wrote painfully and carefully.

Both Kirk and Eliot understood that there is no terrestrial paradise, only that which exists in the hereafter. The best one can hope for is a world that cherishes its traditions, holds on to them, nurtures them, and passes them on to one's munity, family, and the world-at-large. This is a world that constantly renews itself not through revolution, but through regular revisits to those texts that reveal the best of humanity's thoughts and practices guided by a moral imagination that acknowledges something greater than the whims of the individual, something more honorable than political ideologies, something that places humanity under the rubric of the Divine to keep in check the arrogance of earthbound makers--those artists, intellectuals, and leaders who cease placing themselves as creations of something bigger, something more noble, something beyond even the best human minds to prehend.

Lacking this, we are ideologically hidebound, pushing our personal agendas in attempts to reverse the Fall and reclaim an earthly paradise.

Lacking this, we find ourselves morally bankrupt--enslaved by our own appetites, greed, lusts and desires; subject to not only the bankruptcy of our financial and business institutions, but cultural bankruptcy as well--the decadence of what now passes for art and entertainment and the horrors perpetrated from one to another on an hourly basis.

Lacking this, we are Eliot's "Hollow Men," manifested in the evils of socialism espoused by George Bernard Shaw, Lenin, and Marx; the atheism proudly defended by Bertrand Russell; the dystopian visions of H.G. Wells--and for the rest of us the myriad of social and political correctives and their unforeseen consequences generations later. And, as Eliot concluded in that poem: "This is how the world ends. Not with a bang but a whimper." For, when the pass is bent, it no longer serves as a trusted guide through the troubles that demand a moral response.

Bruce Edward Walker is manager munications for the Mackinac Center's Property Rights Network.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
How does Acton's Rome office contribute to the mission of the Acton Institute?
The Acton Institute has a number of affiliates around the world, but when it came time to establish a presence in Rome, the institute opted not to start another affiliate, but to open a new Acton office, Istituto Acton. This allows the institute and its Grand Rapids staff to work closely with the Rome staff on a number of important projects that further our mission to promote a free and virtuous society on the international stage. A large part...
Europe without roots
Optimism is obligatory, but it's cheap. In the current situation, there is a heavy price to pay. Relativism has wreaked havoc, and it continues to act as a mirror and an echo chamber for the dark mood that has fallen over the West. It has paralyzed the West, when it is already disoriented and at a standstill, rendered it defenseless when it is already acquiescent, and confused it when it is already reluctant to rise to the challenge. One...
Doubled-edged sword: The power of the Word - Genesis 17:3
Genesis 17:3 “When Abraham prostrated himself, God continued to speak to him: 'My covenant with you is this: you are to e the father of a host of nations'” (Gen. 17:3). Within decades of the crucifixion and resurrection of Christ, the good news had spread from Jerusalem through the Hellenistic culture of the eastern Mediterranean to Rome, and to ends-of-earth places such as India and the British Isles. In the following centuries, holy men and women protected the heritage...
Jewish theology and economic theory
There has been very little work by orthodox Jewish scholars on the relationship among socialism, capitalism, and Judaism. Careful reading of the relevant literature, however, suggests that it is possible to posit five basic axioms of Jewish economic theory from which many economic policy implications can be deduced. Although not exhaustive, our five axioms represent, to the best of our knowledge, the first attempt to formulate a parsimonious list of basic principles that help systematize the foundations of what...
Be wary of power
Some people imagine that there is a third way between the market economy and socialism, and in a sense they are right. But the way to it does not lie with government programs. Before I explain that, let us consider the unseen effects of substituting government means for voluntary human energies. We often use the word voluntary to identify charitable actions taken in society that do not result in profit. But consider that profit in a market economy also...
The challenge of globalization to the Church
The Acton Institute is midway through a series of lectures – eight in Rome and one in Poland – celebrating the fifteenth anniversary of Centesimus Annus, Pope John Paul II's landmark social encyclical. The lecture series started in October 2005 and will continue through 2007. The following is taken from Centesimus Annus, Globalization, and Individual Development, an ing monograph itself expanded from Lord Griffiths's address delivered on October 19, 2006, in Rome. The church has the potential to tackle...
Interest and responsibility
Since at least the Middle Ages, the payment and receipt of interest has existed under a moral cloud, due mainly to a misunderstanding concerning what interest is and why it exists. Medieval theologians gradually came around to the view that now prevails in economic science. What connects all forms of interest is the insight that interest is nothing more or less than the exchange ratios between different time horizons. If I prefer to save now, I must put off...
Editor's note
In our feature interview in this issue of R&L, Chuck Colson makes reference to the now-famous lecture Pope Benedict XVI gave at Regensburg last September. The heart of that lecture was the relationship of faith and reason. In the course of arguing that each needs the other, Pope Benedict raised questions about Islam that garnered worldwide attention. But Pope Benedict's point was not principally about Islam. His point was that religious faith, when not purified by reason, can lose...
Health within limits: A reading of Wendell Berry
A few months ago, a friend and I drove to Indianapolis on a pilgrimage to see and hear Wendell Berry. I was struck by the difference between my own heroic construct and the reality before me. Here in Indianapolis stood an elderly man, albeit a sharp, irascible, very tall and vigorous personage. He reflected on the limitless demiurge of consumerism that e to blight our culture, on the anachronistic vigor with which he seeks to guard over his own...
The creative imperative
This article was excerpted from Samuel Gregg's The Commercial Society: Foundations and Challenges in a Global Age, a new book published by Lexington Books. Commercial society's impact upon poverty is not simply a result of the unintended consequences of market exchange. It owes much mercial society's particular moral foundations. By moral foundations, we mean particular values and habits of action indispensable for the workings mercial society. What follows is an attempt to mercial society's basic moral foundations. Taken together,...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved