Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Driven a Ford lately?
Driven a Ford lately?
Jul 12, 2025 3:33 AM

If you’re like most Americans, the answer is probably “No.” Faced with loss of market share and declining revenues, Ford announced a restructuring plan that would cut nearly a quarter of its workforce and close 14 plants over the next six years. The moves are intended to bring the auto giant back to profitability by 2008.

What has caused petitiveness of Ford to plummet? It’s part of the larger trend among American automakers. Ford’s “Way Forward” plan was preceded by GM’s flirtation with a “cloud of bankruptcy” and was followed by DaimlerChrysler’s announcement of layoffs (many of which would be in Germany).

NBC Nightly News featured a story on the U.S. auto industry’s woes on Tuesday night (Netcast available here). Patriotism is being replaced by pragmatism, says NBC’s Anne Thompson.

MSNBC’s Roland Jones writes, “Like its U.S. rival GM, Ford has struggled in recent years with a loss in U.S. market share to Asian rivals, a decline in sales of its large SUVs because of higher gasoline prices and a crippling healthcare bill and pension costs for its U.S. workforce and retirees.”

If we look at each of these three points, we can see clear reasons why Americans have stopped buying American cars. While all of them are interrelated, the loss of market share can be largely seen as an artifact of consumers not feeling they are getting appropriate value for what they spend on American cars. With reliability, safety, and generous warranty offerings from Asian carmakers at an all-time high, and prices approaching all-time lows, panies have plete package to offer. American panies tend to offer less-reliable cars at higher prices. Early last year, Toyota even briefly considered the idea of voluntarily raising it’s own prices to give petitors some breathing room before it wisely decided to recognize that “prices are something for the market to determine.”

Vigorous SUV sales had been the backbone of American profitability in recent years, but spikes in gasoline prices have caused many to turn in the keys of their Explorer for something that has lower mileage costs. Clearly it was an error to for Ford and others to “put all their eggs in one basket,” as the saying goes.

And finally e to what is perhaps the greatest contributing factor to the lack of petitiveness: huge labor costs associated with UAW contracts. Paul of Hattiesburg, Miss., responding to the MSNBC story, sums up the problem, “As much as I would prefer to ‘buy American,’ I am not going to subsidize the huge pensions and inflated salaries that the United Auto Workers union (UAW) has extorted from Detroit by buying a sub-standard automobile. The UAW and their kind are going to be the undoing of the American car manufacturing industry as we currently know it. What rises from the ashes may be an automobile manufacturer that will stand up to the UAW and build cars that actually give people their money’s worth.”

Well, Paul, those manufacturers already exist, and have opened new plants in the US. The Asian automakers have opened 29 new plants in the US, which are staffed largely by younger non-union and therefore cheaper workforces than their American counterparts. Much or all of the Honda or Toyota model bought today might have been made in the US.

The Asian “Big Three,” Toyota, Honda, and Nissan, have their petition from other growing automakers like the South Korean Hyundai, which opened a $1 billion plant in Montgomery, Alabama last year. As Kia Motors considers where to build a new plant, could Montgomery be the new “Motor City” of the South? All together, panies garnered nearly 40% of the US auto market last year.

Next year looks to be a pivotal year for the American “Big Three,” since all of them “are readying for tough union negotiations in 2007 when their contract with the UAW is set to expire.”

As for the “Way Forward” plan, merely cutting staff and closing plants won’t be enough for Ford. They’ll need to negotiate a sane labor contract, improve their product quality, and make prices petitive. American loyalty goes only so far.

“What you’re finding in the automotive business is the products you design today affect your profitability three to four years down the road,” Brett Hoselton, an automotive analyst with KeyBanc Capital Markets, said. “What we are seeing today is some pretty good changes at General Motors, but nothing like that at Ford, and I think Ford is really going to be in dire straits in five to 10 years from now.”

Not many people will pay more for a car that is less reliable, no matter where it’s made. Voluntarily spending more to put my family in a car that is more likely to break down and leave us stranded would hardly be responsible.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
How did money-lending stop being a sin?
“Moneylending has been taboo for most of human history,” notes Alex Mayyasi. “So how did usury stop being a sin and e respectable finance?” Today, a banker listening to a theologian seems like a curiosity, a category error. But for most of history, this kind of dialogue was the norm. Hundreds of years ago, when modern finance arose in Europe, moneylenders moderated their behaviour in response to debates among the clergy about how to apply the Bible’s teachings to an...
Explainer: What you should know about civil asset forfeiture
Earlier this week, Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced the Justice Department would be reinstating the Equitable Sharing Program, a controversial policy related to civil asset forfeiture. Several states have been making it more difficult to apply such forfeitures so this allows state and local law enforcement to explicitly circumvent state forfeiture restrictions. Here’s what you should know aboutcivil asset forfeiture. What is civil asset forfeiture? Civil asset forfeiture (hereafter CAF) is a controversial legal tool that allows law enforcement officials...
Review: A visually powerful tribute to The Dunkirk Spirit
In a new blockbuster film, director Christopher Nolan faithfully captures for the big screen the frantic chaos and desperation of the Allied forces at Dunkirk in 1940. It is another vivid reminder that, as so many throughout history have reminded us, “War is hell.” Those who know their history understand that on the French beaches of the Strait of Dover, the Allied forces are thrown once again into another world conflict, this time to protect Western freedom and its democratic...
Maximizing profit under competition
Note: This is post #42 in a weekly video series on basic microeconomics. In petitive market, pany can’t control how much they charge for goods and services. So how do firms maximize profits when they don’t control prices? In this video by Marginal Revolution University, Alex Tabarrok defines profit, including how to calculate total revenue and total cost, and covers costs, variable costs, marginal revenue, and marginal cost. (If you find the pace of the videos too slow, I’d mend...
The kind of ‘tolerance’ the West needs
In the modern lexicon, “tolerance” stands alongside “equality” as an unquestioned and absolute good, a cornerstone of transatlantic values. True tolerance has brought the West unparalleled prosperity. But what kind of “tolerance” should we advance, and what other cultural concepts must support it? In a new essay for Religion & Liberty Transatlantic,Josh Herring examines “The foundation of true tolerance.” He begins with the triumph of tolerance in public discourse: In The Ethics of Rhetoric, University of Chicago rhetorician Richard Weaver...
Did the Reformation lead to ‘economic secularization’?
In his famous work, The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, Max Weber attempted to draw a clear link between the Protestant Reformation and the rise of capitalism, focusing mostly on the Puritans and their (faulty) connections between spiritual significance and economic prosperity. But while Weber may have offered some significant observations on the developments of his day, his overall theory has long been dismissed and discredited on a number of grounds, whether historical, theological, or economic. “Weber missed...
New teaching program aims to revive Catholic education
For the past decade, Catholic education has been on the decline. Data from the 2016-2017 National Catholic Education Association Report shows that since 2006, the number of Catholic schools has decreased by 14 percent and the number of students attending Catholic school has decreased by 17.6 percent. Perhaps Teach for Christ can help reverse this trend. The name may ring a bell, as it bears resemblance to the existing program Teach for America. However, Teach for Christ, which will be...
Work too much? You might have the ‘Proletariat Touch’
Two weeks ago, a group of scholars from around the world gathered in Notre Dame, Indiana for Holy Cross College’s Labor and Leisure Conference. Among the many present was scholar Joseph Zahn, who presented his paper, “The Status of Leisure in the Human Person: Whether Leisure is a Virtue?” With levity in his voice, Zahn began: “Writing a paper on leisure without leisure is a difficult, if not utterly futile, task.” Set to begin his doctoral studies in philosophy at...
Evaluating Trump’s tax reforms
In April, the Trump administration provided a broad outline of proposed reforms, including simplifying tax brackets, eliminating the marriage penalty, and creating child care deductions. The National Catholic Register recently published an article on the reforms, focusing on its effect on the family. Rev. Robert Sirico, co-founder and president of the Acton Institute, provided his thoughts on Trump’s plan: “A refundable tax credit, instead of a direct subsidy from the government, is more in line with the principle of subsidiarity,”...
The most effective way to reduce child poverty
A vital fact lies buried in the recent IFS study on e inequality: the most effective way to alleviate poverty. This was true even though the IFS study, and UK government statistics, don’t actually measure poverty but rather inequality. Maybe it’s best to say the IFS study contains the secret to reducing both phenomena. Whichever metric one uses, according to the IFS report the most effective way to reduce that number is through work. The UK government defines “poverty” as...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved