Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Does David Beckham have a moral obligation to get ‘soaked’?
Does David Beckham have a moral obligation to get ‘soaked’?
Nov 20, 2026 11:16 PM

Retired soccer legend David Beckham was denied knighthood in 2013after British authorities flagged him for “tax avoidance,” according to a new story in theTelegraph. Beckham had invested in Ingenious Media, pany that supported the British film industry – and also allowed investors to write off their losses.Officials at pany say its model providedwealthy people like Beckham the opportunity to reduce their tax liability while following existing tax law; the case is still being thrashed out in the courts.

David Beckham. Pressebilder. CC BY-ND 2.0)

Beckham’s saga joins those of numerous Premier League soccer players who have been denigrated in the media forusing indisputably legal means to maximize their net e. Strange as it is to American ears, even the conservative-leaningDaily Mailreported in shock that their tax avoidance methodswere“all legal.”

That raises an important moral question: For generations, economic leftists have campaigned on a promise to “soak the rich.” But do the rich have a moral obligation to be “soaked?

Richard Teather, a senior lecturer in tax law at Bournemouth University and a fellow at the Adam Smith Institute, addresses that question in an essay published todayinReligion and Liberty Transatlantic.

“Is it immoral to take advantage of an opportunity offered to us by the government?” he asks. “It is difficult to see why.” The law’s only moral precept is that it be kept.

Significantly, the tax code’s intertwining layers of Byzantine calculationsand labyrinthine exemptions did e about by following any defined moral code.As in the United States, cronyism influenced its haphazardand often conflicting development:

The tax system is plex, because of deliberate decisions by the government over decades. … With all these variables, it is impossible to say that there is any general obligation to pay a certain amount of tax. The tax system is entirely a creation of statute; a system based on general morality could not e up with anything like plexities, variations and exemptions.

Foisting a moral burden of paying maximum taxation, regardless of the relief explicitly provided by the law, is particularly troublesome in the case of professional athletes and others who have only a few years to earn peaksalaries:

By looking at annual rather than lifetime e, the tax system can be unfair to people with erratic or variable e. Top footballers will pay the top 45 percent tax, but most will only earn at that level for a few years. If their e were averaged over an ordinary working life, many would be in a lower bracket.

The average professional football (soccer) career lasts eight years, according to an analysis fromThe Guardian.

One should ask if the same issue applies in the United States, not merely to sports stars, but to those who climb the ladder of success. Taxing “the rich” means taxing changing groups of people experiencingdifferent stages oflife. Nearly two-thirds of people born into the lowest e bracketwill leave that position over the course of their lifetimes. In all, “28 percent of the children of parents in the top quintile of the residual wealth distribution will end up in the bottom two quintiles, and 28 percent of the children of parents in the bottom quintile of the residual wealth distribution will end up in the top two quintiles,” according to a report published last July by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

A progressive annual e tax cannot distinguish between Paris Hiltonand Horatio Alger.

Finally,Teather raises anoverlooked issue: Is giving your e to the government the best way to indulge in “charity”? He writes:

That is not to say that we can be selfish and keep our money to ourselves. What we do with our money, and our time and other talents, is an area where morality and the obligations of charity and society play an important role. But so long as we pay the amount of tax that is legally due, the best use of our remaining e is not necessarily to give it to the government.

You can read his full article here.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Global Warming Consensus Alert: NBC Pitches In!
In what might be the dumbest attempt yet by any large corporation to appear “green,” NBC decided to turn off the lights on their Sunday Night Football broadcast’s studio set last night. This was apparently an effort to offset the carbon footprint of Matt Lauer in Greenland, which – judging by the size of the huge area lit by the lights they hauled up there – must have been pretty huge. It’s just too bad that NBC didn’t team up...
The Few, The Proud, The Marines
U.S.M.C. War Memorial Last summer I visited the National Museum of the Marine Corps in Quantico, Virginia. It is an impressive and moving tribute to the U.S. Marines, focusing especially on WWII to the present War on Terror. There was an even a section which chronicled the transformation of young recruits to Marines who embody the virtues of “honor, courage, mitment.” David Zucchino of the Los Angeles Times has written a piece titled, “From Boys to Marines.” The article is...
Sunset Boulevard: A haunting look at spiritual emptiness
In the classic 1950 film Sunset Boulevard, the character of film star Norma Desmond, played by Gloria Swanson, declares, “I am big. It’s the pictures that got small.” I watched Sunset Boulevard for the first time last night, thanks to the mendation from a friend in Virginia. As a fan of classic films, I had high hopes for this film, which was directed by Billy Wilder. Wilder also directed one of my favorite classics films, Stalag 17. William Holden starred...
2007 Honor Roll: Reactions Buzzing
Since the 2007 Catholic High School Honor Roll was released, reactions have been buzzing. We’ve been consistently floored by the Honor Roll’s impact. Here’s some highlights: • Huge Roar: “When we announced the award to our students yesterday, a huge roar of spontaneous cheering filled the building. What a glorious day!” Margaret Miller, Holy Cross Academy – Oneida, NY. 4-time honoree. Enrollment Impact: “The Honor Roll is really making an impact for us. This year we have had already over...
This Week is GodblogCon
I’ll be leaving on Wednesday and returning on Saturday to attend GodblogCon 2007 in Las Vegas, held in conjunction with the Blog World & New Media Expo. The Acton Institute is a sponsor of this year’s GodblogCon. I’ll be representing the PowerBlog at the conference, and if you are a reader of this blog and will also be attending, drop me a note in ment box on this post. I’ll also be scouting talent for next year’s Acton University, which...
New Blog of Note: The Immanent Frame
A new blog has been added to our blogroll sidebar (along with a much-needed round of housecleaning on old and out-of-date links). Announcement below: The Social Science Research Council is pleased to announce the launch of The Immanent Frame, a new SSRC blog on secularism, religion, and the public sphere. The blog is opening with a series of posts on Charles Taylor’s A Secular Age, including recent contributions from Robert Bellah, Wendy Brown, Jose Casanova, Elizabeth Shakman Hurd, and Colin...
Acton Media Alert
Heads up: Acton Research Fellow Anthony Bradley will be making an appearance today on NPR’s News and Notes program. Braodcast times may vary, so check your local NPR affiliate’s schedule to see if you can catch the show. If you miss it, you can check the show archives right here. Update: Here’s the audio (3 mb mp3 file). Update II: Rome office director Kishore mented on the S-CHIP issue for Vatican Radio today; listen by clicking here (230 kb mp3...
Samuelson on ‘The Global Poverty Trap’
Washington Post columnist Robert J. Samuelson discusses a new book on economic history that looks at the poverty problem from the perspective of “nature vs. nurture.” Comes now Gregory Clark, an economist who interestingly takes the side of culture. In an important new book, ” A Farewell to Alms: A Brief Economic History of the World,” Clark suggests that much of the world’s remaining poverty is semi-permanent. Modern technology and management are widely available, but many societies can’t take advantage...
Misguided Hop Hip Protests: Media Companies Aren’t The Problem
The New York Times reports of a well-intentioned protest by a pastor to protest the ridiculous and dehumanizing lyrics of the type of hip hop shown on networks like BET and MTV. Wearing white T-shirts with red stop signs and chanting “BET does not reflect me, MTV does not reflect me,” protesters have been gathering every Saturday outside the homes of executives in Washington and New York City. The orderly, mostly black crowds are protesting music videos that they say...
A Worthy Definition of Freedom
Here’s a definition of freedom worth noting: The Word of God teaches that the Christian is a free man and should “stand in the freedom which Christ has made him free.” What is meant by Christian freedom? What is freedom in general? We answer: it is not the right and the ability to do as one pleases, but the ability to move without constraint in the sphere for which God made us. Freedom therefore is not inconsistent with limitation and...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved