Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
A Cultural Case for Capitalism: Part 8 of 12 — Capitalism and Cronyism Confused
A Cultural Case for Capitalism: Part 8 of 12 — Capitalism and Cronyism Confused
Jul 6, 2025 6:03 AM

[Part 1 is here.]

In his case against capitalism, Wendell Berry argues that the average person not only is anxious because he depends upon so many other people for his wellbeing (truckers, panies, etc.) but that he ought to be anxious. There’s a grain of truth here. We shouldn’t e helpless sheep without a clue what to do were the power to go down for a couple of days in January. But inter-dependency, far from a sign of cultural sickness, is the mark of a healthy society, one where enough trust exists to allow for broadening circles of productivity and exchange, for markets that extend beyond clan and tribe.

Berry’s disdain for the cities of present-day capitalism knows few bounds. “No longer does human life rise from the earth like a pyramid, broadly and considerately founded upon its sources.” he writes. “Now it scatters itself out in a reckless horizontal sprawl, like a disorderly city whose suburbs and pavements destroy the fields.” No longer? Cities have been displacing fields for as long as there have been cities, though now that we have the technology to build vertically, they are able to cover fewer acres per capita than they might otherwise.

I’ll agree that there’s plenty of thoughtless sprawl and soulless architecture out there, but why the image of a pyramid? The Egyptian pyramids were built by slave labor and used as lavish tombs for the Pharaohs, geometrical monstrosities without light or whimsy, orchestrated by deeply unfree, top-down political regimes. Sure, they’re cool for being really big and really old, but they’re devoid of the contours, variety, and vibrancy that characterize the cultural artefacts of the Western tradition at its best.

The problem with Berry runs deeper than an unfortunate choice of figurative language. There’s much that is good, true, and beautiful in his writings, but running throughout his work is something bordering on land idolatry, something that goes well beyond a healthy love and appreciation for the natural order of God’s Creation.

Then, too, there his conflation of the free economy with what alternately has been described as state capitalism, crony capitalism, or crony socialism—an economy where the rich and well-connected get together with politicians and bureaucrats to tilt the playing field in their favor and wall small businesses out of the game. Every economy has some of this, but the freest economies in the world today have far less of it.

In Berry’s oft-reprinted essay “The Total Economy,” there are flashes of clarity on the issue of cronyism and how it shouldn’t be conflated with genuine market freedom. For instance, at one point he notes, “The global economy is now institutionalized in the World Trade organization, which was set up, without election anywhere, to rule international trade on behalf of the ‘free market’—which is to say on behalf of the supra-national corporations—and to overrule, in secret sessions, any national or regional law that conflicts with the ‘free market.’”

His use of quotation marks around “free market” here is at least a start on making the crucial distinction between crony markets and truly free markets. Unfortunately, the work of clarification proves abortive. The piece, in toto, makes it sound like the World Trade Organization and other international governing bodies are the unflinching, if bullying, defenders of unbridled economic freedom across borders, when really these governing bodies are deeply implicated in the game of market manipulation.

James Sheehan gets at this point in “Who Needs the WTO?”:

In trade negotiations, bureaucrats have an incentive to maintain trade barriers as bargaining chips for the negotiating process. This is why the GATT/WTO have been at it for over five decades and we still do not have free trade. It is not in the bureaucrats’ interest to adopt free trade, because they would have nothing left to do. They would prefer a perpetual series of negotiations where they can broker power between various governments and interest groups.

Similar criticisms can be leveled against specific “free trade” agreements such as the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) and the Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA). U.S. Congressman Ron Paul, a consistent defender of free trade, emphasized the problem during Congressional testimony against CAFTA:

If we were interested in free trade, as the pretense is, you could initiate free trade in one small paragraph,” he said. “This bill is over 1000 pages, and it is merely a pretext for free trade.… I believe in free trade, but this is not free trade. This is regulated, managed trade for the benefit of special interests.

Berry misses all this. Instead of doing the patient spade work needed to uncover the distinction between cronyism and economic freedom, he is content to toss out fog bombs like this: “Communism and free market capitalism are both modern versions of oligarchy” (65). But to the degree an economy is an oligarchy it isn’t a free market.

A bit later Berry tosses another fog bomb, calling the global free market a “new colonialism without restraints or boundaries … as if the rabbits have now been forbidden to have holes, thereby ‘freeing’ the hounds” (66). This is also confused. Where the poor of the developing world have gotten access to wider circles of exchange and some measure of economic freedom, they’ve climbed out of extreme poverty literally by the billions, with a World Bank study finding that the percentage of people now living in extreme poverty has dropped from 52% of the global population in 1981 to 22% in 2008.

Apparently unaware of this development, ments in a mocking tone that “sentimental capitalism,” the “free market,” and the “great corporations” promise “unprecedented security and happiness to ‘the many’—in, of course, the future.”

Berry needs to realize that the two billion people who have moved out of extreme poverty by way of global capitalism aren’t living in the future. They’re living now, and living much longer on average than their parents and grandparents. Poverty and injustice haven’t vanished, and they won’t this side of the Second Coming, but a global economic sea change this tangible and sweeping shouldn’t be dismissed as a mere fantasy.

Also, when Berry speaks of a pie-in-the-sky promise from the purveyors of capitalism, he obscures the fact that among the leading approaches to political economy in the modern era, the American Experiment of broad economic freedoms and limited government is the one that is manifestly anti-utopian, since it takes into account the Fall. Its petitor—socialism in its various guises— is the one with the utopian streak, imagining as it does that a new man can be fashioned by a clever class of political mandarins from the top down.

Even the Distributism extending from Chesterton and Belloc, for all its homely virtues, has a utopian streak running through it. Two streaks, really. First there’s its falsely idealized vision of Merry Old England before mean old capitalism arrived. Then there’s its groundless expectation that the government could be given vastly expanded powers to redistribute, and to keep properly distributed, everyone’s productive property without those enhanced powers fueling all kinds of unintended consequences, cronyism, and corruption.

The rise of large corporations is partly fed by economies of scale and has, in hundreds of millions of cases, improved the lives of the global poor. Some of those large corporations have abused their power, hurting many vulnerable people in the process. No serious student of economic history would deny this. But what Distributists and other proponents of increased top-down redistributive justice miss is that the growth of powerful multinationals is fed not just by economies of scale, but by the leviathan state teaming up with big business to limit the economic freedom of the poor and wall out small ers.

Doubling and trebling the power of the leviathan to range ever more deeply into the economy will not turn the creature into a beneficent shepherd.

[Part 9 is here.]

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
‘Enablement has no place in this ministry’
Abner Ramos, an alumnus of Acton’s September 2005 Toward a Free and Virtuous Society conference, experienced a change of heart not so long ago. In his work at the the East Los Angeles College Intervarsity Fellowship, he was seeing how some people displayed a sense of entitlement on matters of charity and financial assistance (like the students who were using financial aid checks to buy fancy wheels for their cars). And Abner, as he tells it on the El Acceso...
A few suggestions for World Environment Day (or “how to get a free gift from Honda Motors”)
Hear ye, hear ye! The U.N. Environmental Programmmmme’s World Environment Day is June 5. Wiki – The topic for WED 2006 is Deserts and Desertification. The slogan for WED 2006 is “Don´t desert drylands”. The slogan emphasises the importance of protecting drylands, which cover more than 40% of the planet’s surface. This ecosystem is home to one-third of the world’s people who are more vulnerable members of society. The main international celebrations of the World Environment Day 2006 will be...
Mexican politics and the economy, part II
Writing in the San Diego Union Tribune, Ruben Navarette explains how the Mexican economy and corruption are related to the U.S. immigration problem. After talking with a Mexican born, U.S. citizen, Navarette observes: In Mexico, the elites take pride in the fact that Mexicans abroad send home nearly $20 billion a year. But for González, that figure is a national embarrassment – an advertisement of a government’s failure to provide sufficient opportunity for its own people. So Navarette presses him:...
Debt forgiveness in developing nations
We often hear about the “need” for debt forgiveness. Our movie stars and celebrities like to clamour about it being a “moral obligation” and, of course, leaders of developing nations like the idea as well. But is debt forgiveness really going to help out the people of these developing nations? Samuel Gregg, Acton’s director of research, argues that debt forgiveness is not a moral obligation, nor is it necessarily such a great idea for the economies of some of these...
Logic, natural law, and right reason
In some of my reading lately, a connection occurred to me of the sort that is so obvious once consciously realized that you feel almost idiotic for not making the linkage before. G. K. Chesterton considered logic to be a tool, an instrument of reason to be used only in service of the truth. He writes, The relations of logic to truth depend, then, not upon its perfection as logic, but upon certain pre-logical faculties and certain pre-logical discoveries, upon...
‘Worth More than Many Sparrows’
“Animals are less valuable than human beings,” says John Martin, Professor of Cardiovascular Medicine at University College London (UCL). This seemingly uncontroversial statement is under fire, as Helene Guldberg at sp!ked writes, “There seems to be an emerging consensus within the munity that we should reject the philosophical outlook that says humans are ‘categorically superior’ to animals.” Keith Burgess-Jackson, who blogs at The Conservative Philosopher, says he is “an egalitarian about interspecific value,” and passes along the following quote: For...
‘I don’t get no respect!’
Rodney Dangerfield is famous for saying, “I don’t get no respect!” plaint is shared in the laments that I often hear from academics, that electronic journals are not afforded the same respect as print journals. I explored some of the reasons for this as well as some of the results that have implications for journal publishers in an article published last year, “Scholarship at the Crossroads: The Journal of Markets & Morality Case Study,” Journal of Scholarly Publishing 36, no....
Crass opportunism
“Cultural institutions are latching on to the issue of global warming to provide a focus and urgency to their work. At a time when museums and heritage organisations feel somewhat outdated and directionless, global warming provides a quick-fix rallying point…. This is an almighty cop-out. Institutions are avoiding the challenge of making history and science attractive to the public. Instead of inspiring visitors, institutions end up hectoring and lecturing them.” Read the rest here: Josie Appleton, “The tide turns against...
China-Vatican dispute addendum
In an earlier post on illicit Catholic ordinations in China, I noted that there appeared to be a rift developing between the Patriotic Association and the rest of the government. Chinese Cardinal Joseph Zen confirmed that impression in remarks he made yesterday in Rome, as reported by AsiaNews: The Patriotic Association wanted “it to be a slap in the face, but actually, they were defeated by the clear statement of the Holy See, to which the government responded very mildly”,...
Video games can save lives and more…
Not directly, of course, but the implication of a recent story from NPR’s Future Tense is that video games have a positive stimulative effect on doctors who are about to perform surgery. A new study is out, and according to FT, “Surgeons who played games for 20 minutes immediately prior to performing surgical drills were faster and made fewer errors.” The study focused on a particular type of surgery, specifically “laparoscopic” procedures. Again, from FT, “The results supported findings from...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved