Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Why we should oppose both Skynet and minimum wage increases
Why we should oppose both Skynet and minimum wage increases
Nov 4, 2025 1:20 AM

Terminator 2: Judgment Day poster / TriStar Pictures

I oppose implementing Skynet and increasing minimum wage laws for the same reason: to forestall the robots.

It’s probably inevitable that a T-1000 will return from the future to terminate John Connor. But there is still something we can do to prevent (at least for a time) a TIOS from eliminating the cashier at your local fast food restaurant.

For example, Wendy’s is adding customer service machines to at least 1,000 restaurants, or about 15 percent of its stores, by the end of the year.

In Europe, McDonalds ordered 7,000 TIOSs (Touch Interface Ordering Systems) to take food orders and payment. In America, Panera Bread is moving toreplace all of their cashiers with wage-free robots in all of their 1,800 nationwide locations. There is even a burger-making robot that can churn out 360 gourmet hamburgers per hour.

As Andy Puzder, the head of Hardee’s and Carls Jr.’s pany and briefly US president Donald Trump’s nominee for secretary of labor, said in a 2016 interview,“With government driving up the cost of labor, it’s driving down the number of jobs. You’re going to see automation not just in airports and grocery stores, but in restaurants.”

“This is the problem with Bernie Sanders, and Hillary Clinton, and progressives who push very hard to raise the minimum wage,” addedPuzder. “Does it really help if Sally makes $3 more an hour if Suzie has no job?”

I, for one, e our new fast-food robot overlords. I’m just not ready for them yet. Andneither are millions of American workers.

Over the long run,the adoption of technological innovations tends to increase prosperity and economic flourishing. For example, we are all much better off because of 19th century workers who lost their farm jobs. Likewise, we’ll also be better off (again, in the long run) because a HAL 9000 is flipping our burgers and freeing up the human Hals and Hallies of the world for more productive labor. But in the short-run, the use of robot replacements for low wage employees will hurt the poorest, most low-skilled workers.

The main advantage such workers have now is that they are cost efficient. Fast-food businesses are currently willing to hire low-skilled workers and serve as remedial-training vocational schools because it’s in their economic self-interest to do so. But raising the minimum wage takes away that incentive and will motivate businesses to replace those workers with automated machines.

It’s certainly the rational choice. If you were the owner of a fast-food restaurant, would you rather be staffed by efficient, reliable robots or low-skilled workers (e.g., teenagers, ESL-adults) who tend to have higher than normal human problems? As Puzder said, “[Robots are]always polite, they always upsell, they never take a vacation, they never show up late, there’s never a slip-and-fall, or an age, sex, or race discrimination case.” If it suddenly es cheaper to buy robots than pay a premium for human labor, what do you think businesses will choose?

We already have the answer — you can find it at your local gas station. If you’re younger than 40 you aren’t likely to remember full-service filling stations (unless you live in Oregon or New Jersey where self-service if forbidden by law). Yet they were once the norm.

In 1950, there were over 81,000 gas stations and only about 200 self-service stations (almost all in California). It wasn’t until the two gas shortages in the 1970s (1973 and 1979) caused higher fuel prices which led consumers to look for pricing relief. Almost overnight, full-service stations became all but extinct — taking an entire sector of low-skilled jobs with it.

The recent move in California and New Yorkto rapidly increase the minimum wage to $15 over the next several years will have the same effect. A small group of employees willsee their pay increase while many more willfind their jobs pletely, never e back. Keeping the minimum wage at it’s current rate (or, better yet, eliminating wage pletely) won’t prevent the robots from taking those jobs in the long run. As even the Obama administration’sown internal team of economists admitted, low-payinghave an 83 percent chance of being automated. But letting the free market determine the price of laborwould allow for a smoother transition and give low-skilled workers time to adjust.

Sometimes what initially appears to be a noble and humane idea has unforeseen and dramatic consequences. Proponents of minimum wage increases have (mostly) good intentions. But so did Dr. Miles Bennett Dyson and the engineers at Cyberdyne Systems. And we know how that turned out.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Changing the shape of magazine delivery
New postal rates went into effect yesterday, but the biggest impact of the new rates and policies hasn’t yet been felt. A new set of policies governing the delivery of magazines through the mail has been postponed until July. That’s a bit of needed good news for small magazines that will face rather hefty price increases. The increases have even got The Nation’s Katrina vanden plaining that “the Postal Service is a monopoly.” Maybe it’s time for magazines that can’t...
The (civil) religion test
Commentators call it “The Religion Test.” What does it mean when the Constitution says there should be no religious test for holding office in the United States? Historically it has plainly meant that no candidate, be they a Quaker, a Baptist, a Pentecostal or a Mormon can be barred from office because of their religion. The question is once again on the table with the serious candidacy of Mitt Romney for the presidency. And many who are concerned about Romney’s...
New bookshoppe items
There are two new items that should be noted in the Acton Bookshoppe. The first is The Call of the Entrepreneur DVD which is now available for pre-order. The DVD is not expected to ship until the fall but you can start lining up for one of the first copies right now. The second item is The Call of the Entrepreneur Study Guide by Rev. Robert Sirico. The study guide touches on many of the same themes as the DVD,...
Government divides, families unite – Pope Leo XIII saw it coming
Jennifer Roback Morse takes a look at The War Between the State and the Family, a book that examines some of the family unfriendly social policies of the United Kingdom. The state, she finds, is in the process of atomizing the family into a loose association of persons with easily separated relationships. posing society into nothing but a collection of unattached individuals has been destructive of individuals and society alike,” Morse writes. Read the mentary here. ...
Business ed in Catholic Universities Conference
The John Ryan Institute at the University of St. Thomas announces its 2008 symposium in the series Catholic Social Thought and Management, to be on the topic of “Business Education at Catholic Universities.” These biennial conferences are large affairs passing a refreshingly diverse array of viewpoints. The conferences page is here, though the link to the 2008 event seems not to be operational yet. ...
Do unto music as is done unto movies
There once was a time when it was, in practice at least, more difficult and costly to copy videocassette tapes than it was music pact discs, puter programs. That, in part, is the justification for how the US Copyright code treats music puter software differently than, say, movies. It’s also why you see panies, like Blockbuster and Netflix, that specialize in delivering rental videos for limited home usage. panies, like Gamefly, specialize in the rental of video games for consoles...
Christians in the marketplace
This week’s ACT 3 weekly essay, “Why Christians Ought to Make a Difference in the Marketplace,” by David L. Bahnsen: I have heard it said in my life on more than one occasion that God sent his Son to save souls. Indeed, for evangelicals, that is certainly true. However, for the professing believer who talks of a deep concern for individual souls my question and answer will either be a gigantic disappointment or it may be a true experience of...
Sponsor a child’s education
There are details about how you can sponsor a child to receive an education at the new Christian Primary School in Kabala, Sierra Leone at the project’s blog. The school is an effort pursued by Fraser Valley Christian High School in Surrey, British Columbia, in conjunction with Christian Extension Services in Sierra Leone. I have mentioned the new school in a previous Acton Commentary. The cost of sponsoring a child is $200. Some more details about the education offered by...
Does the Pope blast capitalism?
Jesus of Nazareth, the new book by Pope Benedict XVI, has been described as an attack on capitalism. But Rev. Robert A. Sirico offers a closer reading and finds that no such thing is true. The book, he says, “is explicitly a spiritual reflection on our own interior disposition toward those who are ‘neighbors’ to us and for whom we have some moral responsibility.” Read the mentary here. ...
Austrians at Acton University 2006
A contingent from Austria that attended last year’s Acton University produced a video on their experiences: Want to learn more? Register for next month’s Acton University 2007 (June 12-15, 2007) today. Applications are also open next month for the Toward a Free and Virtuous Society conference to be held in Sonntagberg, Austria, Sept. 20-23, 2007. Applications will be accepted June 1-July 1, 2007. ...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved