Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Why banning dollar stores won’t save ‘food deserts’
Why banning dollar stores won’t save ‘food deserts’
Aug 26, 2025 10:01 AM

Reducing food insecurity and improving overall nutrition continue to be key priorities in the fight to alleviate poverty, particularly given the continued rise of diseases like diabetes and their increased prevalence among e and disadvantaged populations.

Among the proposed solutions, few are more prominent than the goal of reducing “food deserts”—a term for neighborhoods that lack traditional grocery stores or affordable and nutritious food options. Given that more than half of e neighborhoods fall in this category, it’s a worthwhile aim.

Unfortunately, as with many things activists and policymakers have more typically approached the challenge from the top-down—wielding external control munity enterprises, subverting local preferences, and distorting economic signals.

In an essay for City Journal, Steven Malanga highlights the latest target of progressive legislative efforts: discount retailers and dollar stores. “Communities like Oklahoma City, Tulsa, Fort Worth, Birmingham, and Georgia’s DeKalb County have passed restrictions on dollar stores, prompting numerous munities to consider similar curbs,” he writes. “New laws and zoning regulations limit how many of these stores can open, and some require those already in place to sell fresh food.”

The reasoning is predictable. “Behind the sudden disdain for these retailers…are claims by advocacy groups that they saturate poor neighborhoods with cheap, over-processed food, undercutting other retailers and lowering the quality of offerings in munities,” Malanga explains, pointing to a list of recent think pieces that highlight the underlying philosophy (e.g. 1, 2, 3).

Yet as several studies now demonstrate, though nutrition is lacking in many of these neighborhoods, the mere existence of a “food desert”—or, conversely, a plentiful grocery supermarket—actually has little effect on the health, diet, or nutrition of neighborhood inhabitants.

In a paper published in the Quarterly Journal of Economics, three economists chart grocery purchases in 10,000 households located in former food deserts, where new supermarkets have since opened. They found that people didn’t buy healthier food when they started shopping at a new local supermarket.

“We can statistically conclude that the effect on healthy eating from opening new supermarkets was negligible at best,” they wrote. In other words, the food-desert narrative—which suggests that better food choices motivate people to eat better—is fundamentally incorrect. “In the modern economy, stores have e amazingly good at selling us exactly the kinds of things we want to buy,” the researchers write. In other words, “lower demand for healthy food is what causes the lack of supply.”

By imposing restrictions on what these neighborhoods are actually asking for, city planners are bypassing the core issues and embedded behaviors, pretending as though lofty constraints will educate and empower. Worse still, such efforts end up limiting much positive development in these areas, preventing or erasing plenty of affordable options well outside the category of “food and nutrition.”

But if reducing or expanding the number of specific types of grocery stores isn’t the solution, what else can be done? In his own reflections, Malanga proposes that the priority should be “educating people to change their eating habits,” and doing so by “subsidizing the purchase of fresh fruits and vegetables through the federal food-stamp program” and “working harder to encourage kids to eat better—as Michelle Obama tried to do with her Let’s Move! Campaign.” Richard Florida hints at much of the same in his own reflections on the same study.

Subsidizing select food purchases and implementing tailored educational campaigns may be more fruitful than outright banning needed enterprises from feeding the hungry at an affordable price. But even this still tackles the issue from the top down. If we expand our imaginations to look beyond the levers of policy, we see far more opportunities for truly empowering our neighbors.

Churches, in particular, have seen significant success in improving nutrition in munities. For example, at Baltimore’s Pleasant Hope Baptist Church, Pastor Heber Brown III sought to fight what he calls “food apartheid” due to the impact on his neighborhood’s minority population. As Amy Sherman explains at Made to Flourish, what began as a modest effort to convert the church grounds into a 1,500-square-foot garden soon led to a city-wide coalition of churches and food markets.

“Over the past five years Brown has mobilized more than two dozen area congregations into the Black Church Food Security Network (BCFSN) to provide what he calls a ‘soil-to-sanctuary’ pipeline of healthy food for families living in ‘food deserts,’” she explains.

Unlike the typical coercive methods of activists and policymakers, the BCFSN has instead created a thriving institution with incentives that lead to actual ownership, education, and discipleship—from the bottom up and inside out. In addition to providing kick-start grants to churches for starting their own gardens, “it also assists them in recruiting volunteers, establishes pop-up farm stands at local churches, and offers Bible studies and presentations on topics like creation care and food justice,” Sherman explains.

In Brown’s perspective, this is not a “relief-oriented” program, but one that focuses on munity transformation. “The network is a more empowering and sustainable model bating hunger,” Sherman writes, paraphrasing Brown. “It strengthens black farmers and gives city residents more control over their food supply.”

We should continue to explore the various ways that policy might be used to empower greater health in munities. But based on plexity of the individual behaviors and economic signals at play, as well as the failed approaches of the past, we have much to gain by shifting our focus more closely toward those in munities themselves. As demonstrated by Brown, the power of actual boots-on-the-ground initiative and discipleship is far more likely to succeed and endure.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The Forgotten Sin of Covetous Envy
Modern rhetoric of e inequality is driven by covetous envy, says Russell Nieli. Caritas, humility, gratitude, and goodwill toward others are a healthy society’s answer to the ancient curses of envy and pride: The problem of the chronically poor is that they are chronically poor, not that some people make a lot more money than other people and bring about “inequality.” The fact that some fail to earn enough to live at a decent level is a genuine social problem....
Does the Moral Consensus on Human Trafficking Apply to Economics?
Over at the Kern Pastors Network blog, Greg Forster uses The Locust Effect–Gary Haugen’s new book on violence, poverty, and human trafficking –as a springboard for discussing the reach and interconnectedness of various mitments. “The mitments that mobilize evangelicals to fight human trafficking have much broader application,” he writes, “and point to the possibility of a larger Christian vision for the public square.” Yet, for whatever reason, we continue to stall when es to expanding, integrating, and applying things such...
Crony Capitalism’s Favorite Trick
Many who reject capitalism in favor of some “third way” do so because they often mistake it for government-corporate cronyism, says Jonathan Witt in this week’s Acton Commentary. But in countries that have begun extending true economic freedom to the masses, capitalist activity has already lifted hundreds of millions of people out of extreme poverty. Happily, a new piece in The Economist magazine offers some helpful medicine for the confusion, insisting on the distinction between cronyism and capitalism while also...
Trillium’s Unholy McKibben Alliance
It’s been a long, cold winter. Not to mention expensive due to heating bills depleting bank balances for those fortunately possessing enough scratch to pay their utilities. For others forced to wear sweaters around the clock and sleep with three dogs to stay warm while keeping the thermostat tuned just above freezing to save money, it may take months before reaching a zero balance on the monthly propane/gas/natural gas/electricity statement. Imagine how prohibitive those bills would be if we relied...
The Torah’s ‘Hearty Echo of the Gospel’
“Are there then no laws in the legal sense in the law of Moses?” asks Cornelis Vonk, the Dutch Reformed pastor and preacher. “Of course there are, but there is much more besides.” This, and what es from Vonk’s newly translated Exodus, the second primer in CLP’s growing Opening the Scriptures series: Through his law, the Lord also taught Israel what sorts of social measures did and did not please him… Neither did the Lord forget to teach his people...
How the IRS Killed Bitcoin as a Currency
“For federal tax purposes, virtual currency is treated as property.” With those ten words, the IRS has made it more difficult — if not impossible — for bitcoin and other virtual currencies from gaining widespread, mainstream acceptance as a currency mercial transactions. Because they are now treated as property, virtual currencies are considered, like stocks, bonds, and other investment property, as capital assets and will be subject to capital gains tax. But why does this hinder bitcoins use a currency?...
Pope Francis and President Obama discuss religious freedom, poverty alleviation
Pope Francis, the first Latin American pontiff, and Barack Obama, the first black American president, finally met today in an historic tête-à-tête inside the Vatican Apostolic Palace – and for nearly double the originally scheduled time. Romans could peer inside the fortified Vatican walls via a special streaming set up on Vatican TV’s web site, where they saw a U.S. delegation (which included Secretary of State John Kerry, National Security Adviser Susan Rice and White House Press Secretary Jay Carney)...
When Work is a Holy Undertaking
At Patheos, Joel J. Miller discusses how God uses work to fashion our souls: Not long ago I looked at an icon of Archbishop Luke of Simferopol and Crimea, a recent Orthodox saint who lived from 1877 to 1961. Following the fashion, the image was timeless. It could have been painted a thousand years ago. But there in the icon — to my surprise — were surgical implements! The archbishop worked as a surgeon and scientist. He was well known...
No Cigarettes For You, No Birth Control For Me?
The CVS chain made an announcement a few weeks ago: they would no longer sell tobacco products at their stores. CVS President and CEO Larry Merlo said: As the delivery of health care evolves with an emphasis on better health es, reducing chronic disease and controlling costs, CVS Caremark is playing an expanded role through our 26,000 pharmacists and nurse practitioners. By removing tobacco products from our retail shelves, we will better serve our patients, clients and health care providers...
Bye-Bye for the Bishop of Bling … And Hello Obama?
In USA es this story from the Associated Press: VATICAN CITY (AP) — Pope Francis on Wednesday permanently removed a German bishop from his Limburg diocese after his 31 million-euro ($43-million) new plex caused an uproar among the faithful. Francis had temporarily expelled Monsignor Franz-Peter Tebartz-van Elst from Limburg in October pending a church inquiry. At the center of the controversy was the price tag for the construction of a new bishop’s plex and related renovations. Tebartz-van Elst defended the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved