Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Westminster Abbey praises God for the NHS
Westminster Abbey praises God for the NHS
Jun 30, 2025 10:00 PM

Westminster Abbey held a service on memorating the 70thanniversary of the United Kingdom’s National Health Service (NHS). At the service Justin Welby, Archbishop of Canterbury, said that the “NHS is the most powerful and visible expression of our Christian heritage, because it sprang out of a concern that the poor should be able to be treated as well as the rich.”

Holding a service for the NHS raises two questions: Why does the Anglican Church no longer believe itself to be the “most powerful and visible expression” of the UK’s Christian heritage? And should the Anglican Church be holding a service for the NHS at all?

During the service at Westminster Abbey, the Very Reverend John Hall praised the NHS for its presence at every point of life, whether at the “blessing of new life or the intrusion of our own mortality.” But unlike the sick calls from caring clergy, thecradle-to-grave presence of the NHS is less forting.

The NHS is a Bernie Sanders-style single-payer healthcare system, which means there is no upfront cost to British citizens for medical care. This “free” system is what mended as “concern for the poor.” This single-payer system, es with severe drawbacks. Whenever the state offers healthcare, the state must ration care. This creates a huge problem that has already manifested itself in the United Kingdom: When the state rations care, innocent people die.

In the case of Alfie Evans, a toddler who was taken off life support, his parents had no choice whether he lived or died. In the case of Charlie Gard, who had a debilitating genetic condition, he died after his parents were barred by the government from taking him out of the country for treatment. In the case of the Liverpool Care Pathway, the NHS made a policy in which doctors decided when the elderly were no longer worth the investment of hospital services, placing them on heavy drugs and what patients call “the road to death.” In instances like these, the family is the best institution to make difficult choices about human life, but is too often usurped by government control.

Yet the NHS’s problems are not limited to individual outliers. Compared to the healthcare systems of countries with similar wealth, the NHS does an atrocious job of caring for its citizens. According to economist Kristian Niemietz of the Institute of Economic Affairs, “In parisons of health system performance, the NHS almost always ranks in the bottom third, on a par with the Czech Republic and Slovenia.”

In today’s sermon, Hall quoted Aneurin Bevan, a founder of the NHS, who said, “I’m proud about the NHS. It’s a piece of real socialism; it’s a piece of real Christianity, too.” This quote sheds light on the real issue at stake. The Anglican Church’s love of the NHS does not necessarily spring from a love of the institution itself, which does not provide the best possible quality healthcare, but from the misconception that the only way for a Christian to care about healthcare is to have the government provide it. In John 21:17, Jesus tells the Apostle Peter to “feed My sheep.” In this and countless other verses, Jesus taught that it is the role of the church to care for the hurting in the world. The church is the best institution to passion and practical service. Hall and Welby are confusing the charity of the church with the charity of the government and diluting the power of the church by denying its ability to minister in the world.

So, yes, the Anglican Church should hold a service for the NHS, but it should either be a Service of Lament or a Funeral.

(Photo source: Crux.CC BY-SA 2.5.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The Intellectual Exploration Of Michael Novak
It is no stretch to say that Michael Novak is a towering figure in 20th century Catholic social thought. His 1982 seminal work, The Spirit of Democratic Capitalism, influenced thinkers in the U.S., Latin America and Soviet-controlled countries. George Weigel has summed up Novak’s vocation and contribution to Catholic social teaching, economic thought and moral culture in an article at City Journal. Weigel begins by stating that Novak’s work wasn’t simple: Novak has applied his philosophical and theological skills to...
What Liberal Evangelicals Should Know About the Economic Views of Conservative Evangelicals (Part 3)
Why do liberal and conservative evangelicals tend to disagree so often about economic issues? This is the third in a series of posts that addresses that question by examining 12 principles that generally drive the thinking of conservative evangelicals when es to economics. The first in the series can be foundhere. Part 2 can be found here.A PDF/text version of the entire series can be foundhere. 7. The best way pensate for structural injustice is to increase order and individual...
Explainer: What You Should Know About the Jobs Report
This morning the federal government released the latest jobs report. You may have noticed confusing headlines andreporting about the data, such as this story from NPR, “Job Growth Less Than Expected, But Unemployment Hits 5-Year Low.” What does that mean? Is that bad news mixed with good news?How should we interpret the jobs report? Here’s what you need to know to understand what the job report is, what it tells us, and what it means for the economy: What is...
We Don’t Have a Poverty Problem, We Have a Dependency Problem
“There is no material poverty in the U.S.,” says the always-provocative Walter E. Williams. “What we have in our nation are dependency and poverty of the spirit, with people making unwise choices and leading pathological lives aided and abetted by the welfare state.” The Census Bureau pegs the poverty rate among blacks at 35 percent and among whites at 13 percent. The illegitimacy rate among blacks is 72 percent, and among whites it’s 30 percent. A statistic that one doesn’t...
Fr. Sirico on ‘How Charity Can Be Selfish’
Forbes contributor Jerry Bowyer recently interviewed Fr. Robert Sirico about PovertyCure and charity. Bower has split his interview into several parts and you can read the previous post here. In this section, their discussion focuses on “Bad Almsgiving:” Jerry: “Charity can be selfish, can’t it?” Fr. Sirico: “Yeah, it can be very self-indulgent.” Jerry: “Let’s say ‘philanthropy’. I mean, genuine charity is a Christian virtue, but the philanthropy industry can be selfishly structured and selfishly supported.” Fr. Sirico: “Well, what...
Hildegard of Bingen and the Living Light: An Acton Co-Sponsored Event
The Acton Institute is pleased to co-sponsor (with Calvin College, Aquinas College, Diocese of Grand Rapids, and Holy Family Radio) the one-woman production, Hildegard of Bingen and the Living Light. Starring Linn Maxwell, the free event will take place on Sunday, March 23 at 6 p.m. at the Acton Building in Grand Rapids. Hildegard of Bingen (1098-1179) memorated on both the Catholic and Anglican/Episcopal Calendars, and was declared a Doctor of the Catholic Church by Pope Benedict XVI. This one-woman...
‘Defiant’ Portrays Heroism on Every Page
In an age where words like “courage” and “bravery” are often tossed about casually, a new book captures the immense heroism and resolve of 11 American POWs during the war in Vietnam. Alvin Townley closes his new book Defiant with these words, “Together, they overcame more intense hardship over more years than any other group of servicemen and families in American history. We should not forget.” Townley easily makes that case by telling their stories and expanding on previous accounts...
Swedish Researcher Says Culture Matters for Innovation
West Michigan is ing a new researcher to the area, and Dr. Stefan Jovinge says that culture matters a great deal for incubating innovation. Jovinge, previously of Lund University in Sweden, is one of the world’s foremost scientists investigating the ability of cardiac cells to repair themselves, and he’s joining the Van Andel Institute and at the Spectrum Health Frederik Meijer Heart & Vascular Institute in Grand Rapids. As Sue Thorns reports, the entrepreneurial culture of West Michigan played a...
When Did The United Nations Become A Theology School?
From the Charter of the United Nations: The Purposes of the United Nations are: To maintain international peace and security, and to that end: to take effective collective measures for the prevention and removal of threats to the peace, and for the suppression of acts of aggression or other breaches of the peace, and to bring about by peaceful means, and in conformity with the principles of justice and international law, adjustment or settlement of international disputes or situations which...
The CBO Report on the ACA: Between Right and Left
A recent report from the CBO contains an appendix detailing updated estimates of the labor market effects of the Affordable Care Act (ACA). Pundits for and against the ACA have wasted no time in putting their own particular spin on the projections. Republicans and some other opponents have seemingly celebrated the idea that these estimates may show that the ACA is “a job-killing, economy-crushing villain,” while Democrats and some other supporters have claimed that in times of high unemployment, it’s...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved