Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Want to Hurt the Poor? Double Their Pay
Want to Hurt the Poor? Double Their Pay
Sep 13, 2025 5:20 PM

Would you be in favor of a pay increase of 107 percent for your current job?

Most of us would be thrilled at having our pay more than double, and would readily support such a change. Imagine if all that was required was to vote for your industry to e unionized. Who wouldn’t support unionization if it resulted in a bigger paycheck?

But what if the change came with one caveat: If the pay increase were approved you’d not only lose your job, you’d no longer be qualified to work in the same industry. Would you still support the pay increase if it cost you your job?

That’s the choice a lot of food-service workers face—though few understand the true implications of their decision. Most fast-food workers going on strike for higher wages simply believe they are deserving of more money and aren’t aware of the basic economic factors that could cause them to e unemployable.

Let’s assume for the moment that doubling the price of labor would not speed up the process of businesses replacing fast-food workers with automated machines. Let’s say that the number of burger-flipping jobs taken over by robots is exactly zero. The change would still lead to massive unemployment for the poorest, low-skilled workers. This isn’t even a contentious claim: Almost all economists, whether on the right or left, agree that significant increases to the minimum wage or attempts to bring it in line with a “living wage” (e.g., $12-15 an hour) would lead to significant increases in unemployment.

Fast-food businesses are currently willing to hire low-skilled workers and serve as remedial-training vocational schools because it’s in their economic self-interest to do so. But raising the minimum wage takes away that incentive and will motivate businesses to replace many of their current employees with more highly skilled workers. As Anthony Davies explains, “the minimum wage prevents some of the least skilled, least educated, and least experienced workers from participating in the labor market because it discourages employers from taking a chance by hiring them. In other words, pete for jobs on the basis of education, skill, experience, and price. Of these factors, the only one on which the lesser-educated, lesser-skilled, and lesser-experienced worker pete is price.” Double the hourly rate for fast-food workers and you double the incentive for employers to hire workers whose labor is worth $15 an hour.

You also increase petition for fast-food jobs. While Buffy (and other teens from upper-middle class families) may not be willing to trade her job folding shirts at Abercrombie & Fitch for a cashier job at Burger King, many other people would jump at the chance to earn a higher wage. If you’re a worker currently earning $12 an hour doing construction work in the blazing sun, getting paid $15 an hour to make milkshakes in the air-conditioning sounds like a dream job.

The result of this bined with the unwillingness of businesses to hire low-skilled workers means that many of the poorest Americans will e unable to find a job at all.

So why does the Service Employees International Union (S.E.I.U.) support the raise? Because they care more about the union than they do the poor. What they care about is that the jobs be unionized. As long as there is some worker in the union job paying the union dues, they don’t really care who they are. It’s not that the union is evil—S.E.I.U. is just acting in its self-interest. Expanding into the fast-food sector increases the revenue and political power of the union. And hundreds of thousands of the poorest, low-skilled workers losing their jobs is regrettable, but a cost the union is willing to pay.

Let me be clear: I’m not anti-union; I’m just pro-poor folks. When the interests of worker associations clash with the interests of low-skilled workers, I’ll side with the latter every time. Those of us who truly care about the poor should oppose attempts to increase wage rates that price the low-skilled out of the job market. We should also explain to fast-food workers that while it may sound great to be promised a doubling of their pay, unionization can’t protect them from the effects of basic economic reality.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Digital rights fiasco
The newest phase in the fight for digital/intellectual property rights involves the recent Digital Rights Management software from Sony. Apparently, Sony’s “protected” audio CDs have been installing a “rootkit” onto puter, and opening up puter to yet more malicious software on the Internet (as if it isn’t bad enough already without a Sony rootkit). There are a couple of things I want to say about this – first, a short description of exactly what the problem is; and secondly, a...
Don’t wait for government
This month’s Esquire magazine is the annual “Genius” issue (with Bill Clinton as the coverboy, which might seem strange until you realize that the word “genius” is related to the words “genii” and “jinn,” which in mythology were often negative spiritual beings, monly believed to be responsible for diseases and for the manias of some lunatics”). Speaking about the trouble with working through and for bureaucratic governments in his article “What I Did on My Summer Vacation: I Went to...
Impact hunger. Impact poverty.
Join us in ing poverty. Acton is starting a new ad campaign which aims to raise awareness of effective ways to e poverty and world hunger. We encourage everyone to view our ads and to consider them seriously as they join the rest of the developed world in extending a hand to those in need. If you’re interested in promoting real solutions to poverty, join our partnership of religious leaders. Visit our website to access valuable educational materials and connect...
Faith in science
To expand the “scientist” as “priest” metaphor a bit, you may find it interesting to read what Herman Bavinck has to say on the fundamental place of “faith” with respect to all kinds of knowledge, including not only religious but also scientific: Believing in general is a mon way in which people gain knowledge and certainty. In all areas of life we start by believing. Our natural inclination is to believe. It is only acquired knowledge and experience that teach...
“If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. If it stops moving, subsidise it.”
Alan Anderson of the Sydney Morning Herald notes that Ronald Reagan’s joke about the Government’s view of the economy has e United Nations policy toward the internet. The Belmont Club blog notes that placing control of the Web into the hands of UN regulators will have far reaching negative consequences: One of the reasons the Internet has been so successful is that it has so far escaped the restraints of Filipino judges, Tunisian government officials and United Nations bureaucrats. Addresses...
Acton Portuguese articles now available
For those of you who are fluent in Portuguese, from a Portuguese speaking country, or who are just interested in Português, please check out our newly updated Portuguese language section. We have many translated articles, papers, editorials, interviews, and a whole catalog of biographies from “In The Liberal Tradition.” ...
How to win enemies in Brussels
Every now and then e across something in the news that makes you want to laugh and weep at the same time. Today’s International Herald Tribune contains one such article. Titled “Poles on ramparts of EU culture war”, it relates how the newly-elected Polish members of the European Parliament are causing so much rancor in Brussels. Their crime: being Christian, pro-economic growth, and friendly to the United States. It turns out that some of the new members of the European...
‘Your mind makes it real’
Check out this Marketplace story about real money being spent in the virtual world. modities of online gaming have real-world value to people, to the extent that a virtual island can cost upwards of $26,000 in the world of Project Entropia. This leads me to ask with the Matrix’s Morpheus: ‘What is “real”? How do you define “real”? If you’re talking about what you can feel, what you can smell, what you can taste and see, then “real” is simply...
There has to be a better way
The system that administers special education in the United States is one that “parents find unresponsive, and schools find expensive,” writes Jennifer Morse, Acton Senior Fellow in Economics. She takes a look at the implications of a recent Supreme Court ruling es up with a solution that involves the dreaded V-word: Vouchers. Read the mentary here. ...
Bishops against death penalty
The US Bishops have issued a statement calling for an end to the use of the death penalty, part of their larger campaign to end the death penalty. I’m sympathetic to the thrust of the statement and to many of its claims. The statement makes its case firmly, yet invites dialogue and debate. It adverts to the Catechism of the Catholic Church, accurately reflecting the Church’s teaching on the matter. It pelling arguments against the death penalty on theological and...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved