Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Video: Sirico on Ayn Rand’s ‘false gospel’
Video: Sirico on Ayn Rand’s ‘false gospel’
Nov 4, 2025 10:46 AM

Acton President Rev. Robert A. Sirico appeared in a a video interview released yesterday by Catholic News Service, following a press conference in Rome last week held to introduce his new book “Defending the Free Market: The Moral Case for the Free Economy” to the local media.

CNS Rome bureau chief Frank Rocca interviewed Siricoregarding his own moral defense of market economics and asked his opinion of the libertarian novelist and intellectual Ayn Rand, whose philosophy of objectivism and rational-self interest gained widespread support from laissez faire capitalists in the United States and Europe.

Rev. Sirico expressed his opinion of Rand’s “false gospel” of laissez faire capitalism in these words:

Ayn Rand is a very interesting character … She attempts to defend capitalism by the use of Aristotelian and, even at times, Thomistic categories. But I think that Rand has a counterfeit form of Christianity. Her success … to a very great extent, is [due to] the moral passion she brings to the question of economics.

Sirico told CNS that Rand’s “false gospel” is most manifest in John Galt, the fictional philosopher-inventor of her popular novel “Atlas Shrugged,” who just like Jesus was rejected by the establishment, persecuted, tortured and is “the redeemer es to the world to show [us] the right way”.

Sirico explains, what Ayn Rand should be really looking for in the heroic character John Galt is Jesus Christ. In Galt we find the defender-until-death of humanliberty while the libertarian author “rejects all the fundamental principles of Christianity, such as human solidarity, even a clear sense of human dignity … She coverts the notion of the uniqueness of the human person that we find that at the heart of Christianity … into a radical individualism.”

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The Right to Health Care is Wrong
History shows us that civil rights can exist as nothing more than legal fiction. Take, for example, the right to vote. Although suffrage was extended to African-Americans under the Constitution in 1870, that right was little more than a nice idea until the Voting Rights Act of 1965. With many activists and politicians calling for America to recognize the “right” to health care, it is well worth looking at what this means. Making promises that cannot be met is a...
Acton Commentary: Healthcare, Democracy, and Freedom
With health care continuing to be a hot button issue, Hunter Baker brings to light a new argument in mentary. While Baker provides us with many prudential reasons to oppose the expansion of government health care, such as the currently proposed government plan not having any provision for preventing the trial lawyer windfalls that have helped contribute to medical inflation, he also articulates the fundamental problems that arise with the expansion of government health care: If we move from being...
The Redemption of Journalism
In the current issue of The City, a journal published by Houston Baptist University and just arrived in my mailbox, I review a book on the oft-maligned relationship between journalism and religion. In Blind Spot: When Journalists Don’t Get Religion, the case pellingly made for a deeper and more authentic integration of religion into every aspect of the news media. The City, and this issue in es highly mended from the likes of Russell Moore of The Southern Baptist Theological...
Cash for Clunkers and the Poor
I just read today that the cars traded in for the Cash for Clunkers program are rendered unusable by running liquid glass through the engines. Has anyone considered the impact of this on the poor? What has happened is that a huge number of low cost cars are being removed from the market. These are cars low e earners would ordinarily drive or teenagers would buy them who need to get to school or work. What happens when we radically...
Acton Commentary: The Not-So-Green Pope
In mentary, Samuel Gregg, director of research at the Acton Institute, explains how labeling Pope Benedict XVI as the “greenest pope in history” is actually misleading. Instead, Benedict’s attention to the environment is grounded in an orthodox Christian theological analysis. Gregg articulates this assertion by citing Benedict’s most recent social encyclical Caritas in Veritate: Also telling is Benedict’s insistence upon a holistic understanding of what we mean by the word ecology. “The book of nature”, Benedict insists, “is one and...
Report Fishy Mobs to the Government
[UPDATED BELOW] The DNC has released a mercial and an email warning Americans about dangerous mobs gathering to do dangerous things (protest socialist health care reform). Meanwhile, the White House has issued a call for loyal citizens to report fishy behavior to a special White House website. Well, I want to do my part to inform on my fellow Americans. The three images below show just how deep the problem runs. It’s fishy mobs all the way down. [UPDATE: ANOTHER...
Money, Greed and God on Bible Answer Man
The Bible Answer Man is in the middle of an extended, two day interview of Jay Richards, about Jay’s new book, Money, Greed and God: Why Capitalism is the Solution and Not the Problem. It’s the most in-depth discussion of the book I’ve encountered on the internet, and Hank Hanegraaff’s introduction alone makes it worth a listen. Yesterday’s interview is here. Today’s interview will stream here. ...
Acton Commentary: The Problem with “Business Ethics”
Samuel Gregg, director of research at the Acton Institute, reflects on business ethics in his mentary. Gregg explores the presence of business ethics courses in business schools; however, with the large presence of business ethics courses we still have a lack of ethics present in business. The lack of ethics in business became a major factor in our current financial crisis. Gregg further explains that business is not just about management or the business ethics that are taught, but businessmen...
Money, Greed and God at NRO
“We talk about what caused the financial crisis, whether ‘greed is good,’ and if ‘it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God.’ It’s John J. Miller describing his podcast interview with Jay Richards here at NRO. They discuss Jay’s excellent new book, Money, Greed and God: Why Capitalism is the Solution and not the Problem. ...
Greeks Bearing Gifts
In a Wall Street Journal article titled “The Great Philanthropy Takeover” Arkansas based writer David Sanders reports on a recent conference of the nationwide Council of Foundations in his home state.Sanders’ article aligns with Michael Miller’s blog of July 30 “Healthcare – Don’t Forget The Morality Of It” and deserves your attention because of the author’s conclusion that the Obama administration “is beginning to nationalize another sector of the American economy.” How could that happen? Well it would happen because...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved