Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
Toward a New Liberty
Toward a New Liberty
Jul 18, 2025 7:29 PM

The 1991 papal encyclical Centesimus Annus has been described as prompting a springtime in Christian social teaching because it makes it easier to see freedom, specifically economic freedom, as a moral mandate. The sad truth is that the two traditions e together in Centesimus Annus–religious orthodoxy and classical liberal social theory–have appeared to be at odds with each other for the better part of three centuries.

Although the classical liberal tradition sprang out of a Christian humanism rooted in the scholastic tradition, some of the classical liberals of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, while keeping the scholastic’s habit of rigorous social thought, abandoned their high regard for ecclesiastical and social authority. And the Church, during certain periods, has strongly criticized what was construed to be the free society, partly because some social thinkers conflated the theories of economic liberalism with moral libertinism, viewing them as one in the same and as mutually reinforcing.

This was a great tragedy in the history of the relationship between church authority and the liberal tradition. As the tensions mounted in the latter half of the nineteenth century, the allegiances of men such as Lord Acton were torn as they came to believe that they had to choose between spiritual authority and the dictates of reason, a situation the late scholastics would have seen as a grave departure from teaching of their master, Saint Thomas.

Friedrich A. Hayek’s last book had the interesting title The Fatal Conceit. The conceit he speaks of is not something as simple as the suggestion that the government can run the economy or that all things can be owned mon, two errors that only the most dogmatic of mit today. Instead, the conceit he wanted us to recognize is the idea that human reason is capable of designing a social order without taking into account the evolved patterns of human law, relationships, economy, and traditions. This conceit, he says, leads us to empower institutions such as the state to override the natural order of liberty in an attempt to impose a plan on society.

We find here in Hayek the potential plementarity between an indispensable principle of Christian social teaching–namely, subsidiarity–and the classical liberal tradition. And if we are looking for the extent of plementarity, we need look no further than Pope John Paul’s 1991 encyclical Centesimus Annus, which plished the great task of repairing the damage done by centuries of unnecessary separation between these two great traditions. Because of the courage of John Paul II and his case in favor of the free society now that socialism is being discredited worldwide, we have entered into a new era of intellectual and social history. No longer do we pelled to speak of classical liberalism and religious orthodoxy as belonging to two separate intellectual worlds. We have begun to speak of them as one and to repair the split that was unnecessary and proved so dangerous to the cause of human liberty.

So our task is one of education and intellectual and social engagement. This engagement will be made all the more potent to the extent that the principle of subsidiarity is authentically observed, and the scope of the Church’s moral and evangelistic influence is broadened by taking back from secular political institutions its primary role passion and social service. It is an engagement we must all throw ourselves pletely, and not only because the stakes are so high for the future of civilization. We must also do so because it is our vocation and our duty to tell the truth to man. In doing so, may we continue to work to heal the scars left from the statist errors of this century. May the advent of the third millennium of the Church see us occupied with the construction of a civilization of love, meaningful and free human labor, and the vigorous embrace of a free and virtuous society.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
The Evolving Religion of Journalism
With the 2016 presidential election looming, the New York Times published a journalism manifesto that was disguised as a mere mentary. If coverage by “mainstream” media of religion, values, culture, and education seem hostile to the beliefs of many Americans, there’s a reason for that. There’s been a paradigm shift in how journalism is done, and for whom. The candidate’s name was in the headline, but the implications of the August 7, 2016, essay “Trump Is Testing the Norms...
Antigone: A Hero for Our Time
Sophocles’ Antigone is a Rorschach test. People see in it whatever they are thinking. To the self-professed and much munist philosopher Slavoj Žižek, Antigone is a “bitch,” though she may also be an admirable figure in her zealous and determined striving against her government. Or perhaps, Žižek suggests alternately, she is a troublemaker creating havoc within an otherwise healthy, well-organized state. In recent versions of the play that he has published with differing endings, Žižek has put forward both...
Reason and Revelation in the Singularity
Harris Bor’s Staying Human: A Jewish Theology for the Age of Artificial Intelligence is an ambitious book. Its message can be put simply: Jewish religious tradition has the resources to respond to a world in which technology controls human beings. Bor is responding to the promise and threat of a future in which artificial intelligence renders human choice and individuality obsolete, a future Bor refers to as “the singularity,” following techno-futurist Ray Kurzweil. Bor is convinced that the singularity...
In the Liberal Tradition: Francisco de Vitoria
Francisco de Vitoria probably isn’t a name that rolls off the lips or even vaguely registers in the minds of most, but he is worth knowing. This highly influential 16th-century Spanish Dominican priest is known as no less than the “father of international law.” What does a late Renaissance Catholic priest have to do with the “liberal tradition”? When you’re also the founder of the “School of Salamanca,” more than you think. Born in Burgos, Spain, in 1483, Vitoria...
The Existential Threat of Anti-Christian Nationalism
In the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic—well beyond the initial two weeks to flatten the curve, but in August of 2020—the New York Times reported, in an article entitled “Your Coronavirus Test Is Positive. Maybe It Shouldn’t Be,” on scientists’ worries about the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) test. The means by which public health workers and government officials (not to mention journalists) were assessing the spread of the virus was, some feared, too sensitive. People were testing positive...
Plato’s "Republic" and Our Own
The expectations of justice reside deeply within us. Figures in both the Hebraic and Hellenic worlds placed the demand for a just society at the center of their work. Those demands have echoed through the ages and into our streets. At the earliest of ages plain about things we deem unfair and dog our parents over broken promises. Of all the virtues, justice seems most ingrained. And yet it is the one most likely to create havoc and wreak...
Our Smartphones, Our Humanity
By now it’s fairly well known just how much harm digital technology and the internet can do to individuals munities. They’re addictive distractions that isolate people from one another, and they have e the powerful propaganda tools, supplying a constant stream of misleading narratives, periodic outrages, and blatantly false information—all while claiming the mantel of truth and objectivity. Already adults suffer from their excessive consumption of shallow social media, mindless entertainment, and abundant pornography, but today’s children stand to...
The Black Church: A World Within a World
What we mean when we use the word “Black” (and whether or not we capitalize it) causes constant confusion in American life. We are liable to contrast Black with white, and to treat the two terms as though they belong to the same category: race. But this is a mistake. As a matter of historical fact, Black Americans formed separate cultural institutions because they were excluded from white institutions or forced to be subordinate within them on account of...
The Cult of Celebrity in the Church of Christ
In a profile for The Guardian from 2012, Kim Kardashian was perplexed. “When I hear people say [what are you famous for], I want to say, ‘what are you talking about?’… I have a hit TV show. We’ve shot more episodes than I Love Lucy!” In the wake of multiple scandals that have rocked the evangelical world, from Mars Hill to Hillsong, the role of the celebrity pastor e in for intense scrutiny. Why be faithful when you can...
Methods Out of Madness
In his famous poem “The Second Coming,” W.B. Yeats warns about what happens when a society, or in our case a church, descends into anarchy and lawlessness: Turning and turning in the widening gyre The falcon cannot hear the falconer; Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold; Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world, The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere The ceremony of innocence is drowned; The best lack all conviction, while the worst Are full of passionate...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved