Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The state of entrepreneurship in America
The state of entrepreneurship in America
Jun 6, 2025 7:11 AM

Alexis de Tocqueville’s Democracy in America is primarily and rightly regarded as a work of political science. But the book is also replete with economic observations. One of the most significant was Tocqueville’s astonishment at “the spirit of enterprise” that characterized much of the country. Americans, Tocqueville quickly realized, were mercial people.” The nation hummed with the pursuit of wealth. Economic change was positively ed. “Almost all of them,” Tocqueville scribbled in one of his notebooks, “are real industrial entrepreneurs.”

America and entrepreneurship were, to Tocqueville’s mind, synonymous. That’s one reason it remains very important to keep an eye on the state of entrepreneurship in the United States. There are few better insights into this than the Indicators of Entrepreneurship produced on a regular basis by the Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation.

Perusing one of their latest publications, 2017 State Report on Early-Stage Entrepreneurship (February 2019), provides a revealing look into how entrepreneurship in its rawest form is doing on a state-by-state basis. Looking at all 50 states and the District of Columbia for 2017, some of the report’s most salient points include the following:

“The rate of new entrepreneurs ranged from a low of 0.16 percent in Delaware to a high of 0.47 percent in Wyoming, with a median of 0.30 percent. Nationally, the rate of new entrepreneurs in 2017 was 0.33 percent, meaning that an average of 330 out of every 100,000 adults became new entrepreneurs in a given month.”“The opportunity share of new entrepreneurs estimates the percentage of those new entrepreneurs who created their businesses out of opportunity instead of necessity. This indicator ranged from a low of 68.7 percent in Rhode Island to a high of 94.0 percent in Nebraska, with a median of 84.7 percent. The national opportunity share of new entrepreneurs in 2017 was 84.4 percent.”“Startup early job creation captures job creation, measured as the total number of jobs created by startups per capita. This indicator ranged from 2.95 jobs per 1,000 people in West Virginia to 10.34 in the District of Columbia, with a median of 4.71. The national startup early job creation in 2017 was 5.27 jobs per 1,000 people.”“Startup early survival rate reflects the one-year survival rate for new firms. It ranged from 73.48 percent in Georgia to 88.13 percent in Maine, with a median of 79.1 percent. Nationally, the startup early survival rate was 79.8 percent in 2017.”

These numbers tell that the picture for entrepreneurship is quite mixed throughout America, the exception being the survival rate of new firms. That’s relatively consistent across the nation.

It’s also revealing that states as culturally and politically different as Wyoming (0.47) and California (0.44) share very high levels of new entrepreneurs entering the marketplace. Among other things, I think this tells us that entrepreneurship is very much a question of attitude and can flourish in very different settings.

At the same time, the report underscores that economic conditions are crucial for shaping people’s motivations for starting new businesses. Over time, the more prosperous the economy, the more likely it is that entrepreneurship will be embarked upon as a question of opportunity than simply a matter of necessity (e.g., someone loses their job). That’s important because businesses established through opportunity entrepreneurship tend to have higher survival-rates than necessity entrepreneurship.

This, I’d suggest, affirms one of the crucial insights of perhaps the world’s foremost scholar of entrepreneurship, the economist, rabbi and Talmudic scholar, Israel Kirzner. In his work on this subject, Kirzner maintains that entrepreneurship is partly a question of people looking through “the fog” of the future that looms before them, seeking opportunities to actualize hitherto unknown potentialities. The term used by Kirzner to describe this process of searching is “alertness.”

Is America still the land of entrepreneurs that Tocqueville suggested it was in the 1830s? Is it a land of “alertness?” The answer is, generally-speaking, yes, though some parts—such as Delaware, Rhode Island, and Pennsylvania—are clearly not.

Obviously not everyone is called to be an entrepreneur. But the unevenness of this vocation across the United States is something that legislators and the shapers of culture need to be concerned about. For entrepreneurs are crucial to the wealth-creation process. When they are absent from munity, everyone in munity loses—and not just economically.

Image source: Pxhere

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Dear Millennials: Get Over Yourselves and Get to Work
This is a guest post by Michael Hendrix in response to the recent debate sparked by a provocative poston millennials and Gen Y “yuppie culture.” Michael serves as the director for emerging issues and research at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce in Washington, D.C. He is a graduate of the University of St. Andrews and a Texas native. By Michael Hendrix Over the past few weeks, much has been written on GYPSY unicorns and my generation’s dashed hopes (warning: strong...
Hours Cut Due To Obamacare? Follow Your Passion, Says Pelosi
According to Investor’s Business Daily, over 300 businesses are cutting employee hours and jobs to avoid Obamacare. If employers restrict employee work hours to 30 per week, then they avoid Obamacare mandates for health insurance. Jed Graham of Investor’s Business Daily says, “Data also point to a record low workweek in low-wage industries.” Casinos are one industry that exemply these cuts. In Grantville, Penn., the Hollywood Casino has told part-time workers they are now limited to no more than 30...
Audio: Sirico on Pope Francis, the Media, and the Future of The Catholic Church
Last week, the first major interview with Pope Francis was released to the world via a number of Jesuit journals; you can read the interview for yourself at America Magazine. As usually happens, major media outlets reported on the interview, often putting their own spin on it (the New York Times provides an example of this type of coverage here). This morning, Frank Beckmann of Detroit, Michigan’s WJR Radiocalled upon Acton President Rev. Robert A. Sirico to discuss what the...
Audio: Tea Party Catholic Heads to the Heartland
Samuel Gregg, Acton’s Director of Research, continues to promote his fine new bookTea Party Catholic: The Catholic Case for Limited Government, a Free Economy and Human Flourishing via radio interviews all across the country. Today, Sam spoke with Jan Mickelson on Des Moines, Iowa’s 50,000 watt WHO Radio. It was a fine conversation, with Mickelson calling the book “a spirited read,” well worth your time. To pick up a copy of your own, head over to the book’s website. Listen...
Multiple Companies Changing Insurance Plans Due To Obamacare
With Obamacare (the Affordable Health Care Act) set to begin on October 1, panies are changing their employee health care. For some, it’s a change in what benefits employees will receive; for others, employees will be losing health care all together and told to sign up under Obamacare. The Wall Street Journal did a “round-up” panies who’ve announced changes. Walgreens is the largest employer yet to disclose employee health care changes. [T]he drugstore giant disclosed a plan to provide payments...
Even in Prison There is Dignity in Work
In a program at Colorado’s Crowley County Correctional Facility, prisoners hand-make roof trusses and oak cabinets for use in Habitat For Humanity home. The inmates not only learn carpentry skills but the dignity of work: “For me, personally, having that apprenticeship was priceless,” said Mike Voss. He learned carpentry when he served time at Crowley and now, five years after being hired as a benchman carpenter, is a co-owner of Artisan Cabinetry in Denver. “Everything I’d done in the past...
Samuel Gregg: The Jesuit, Pope Francis and The Poor
Acton’s Director of Research, Samuel Gregg, offers some fresh thoughts on Pope Francis today at Crisis Magazine. Gregg points out that there has been much talk about “poverty” and the “poor” since the election of Pope Francis, but that this is nothing new in the Catholic Church. …Francis isn’t the first to have used the phrase “a poor church of the poor.” It’s also been employed in a positive fashion by figures ranging from the father of liberation theology, Gustavo...
Revival, Calvin Coolidge, and Recovering America’s Foundations
Often many on the political right believe that reform or change in the country is just one election or another president away. Some declare another Ronald Reagan can fix America’s problems, but entirely miss that there may be no culture left to support a president like Reagan. For almost every problem in this nation, there is not a political solution that will make any lasting impact or change for the better. This point is entirely missed by so many during...
Deadlines Approach for Novak Award and Calihan Fellowships
Are you seeking scholarships to offset graduate school costs? Have you e acquainted with an emerging scholar and would like to recognize this individual by nominating him/her for a prestigious award? If you are involved in academia and have a passion for work that values rule of law, limited government, religious liberty, and freedom in economic life, we mend you look into the Acton Institute’s scholarship programs. And we encourage you to do so quickly, for important deadlines are rapidly...
A Confederacy of IRS Dunces
A few months ago I wrote about how when I was a young Marine I learned that when manding officer says, “I wish” or “I desire,” these expressions have the force of a direct order and should be acted upon as if they had given a direct order. If our CO were to say, even in musing to themselves, “I wish there was something that could be done about that,” we knew we should jump into action. The main problem...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved