Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The beauty of trade: How sharing creates civilization and culture
The beauty of trade: How sharing creates civilization and culture
Aug 23, 2025 9:11 AM

In plex and globalized economy, it can be hard to remember that trade and markets are fundamentally about relationships—channels for human interaction in pursuit of goods and services. That basic reality may be easier to seeand feelat the local farmer’s market or the neighborhood diner, but it nonetheless translates across more intricate and extensive networks of exchange.

Likewise, when es to what occurswithinandthroughoutthose trading relationships, it isn’t just a petty transfer of material stuff—and that’s true from the bottom to the top, from the local to the global, from the tangible to intangible. It’s a creative exchange among creative persons, driven by service and, ideally,love of neighbor.

Through this lens, we see a beauty and transcendence in very things that others regard as cold and transactional. Indeed, such beauty can be observed by beholding the simple and spontaneous flow of goods and services from here to there:

Over at EconLog, Pierre Lemieux finds something similar in somewhere less expected: the line-item logs of UPS package tracking.

After ordering a customized ThinkPad laptop from China, Lemieux beholds a seamless succession of middle men.Despite the interference of two customs bureaus, one in China and one in the United States, not to mention the mountains of regulations in each place, trade had worked its magic,” he concludes.

Again, whereas some may see the simple or “impersonal” efficiency of supply chain and logistics, Lemiux spots the civilizing and socializing aspect of it all:

InJohn Hicks’sextraordinary bookA Theory of Economic History(1969), one sees beautiful trade as an essential part of the modern economy. In the primitive economy based on custom mand, Hicks writes, “[t]here are farmers, and soldiers, and administrators; but there are no traders, no one who is specialized upon trade.” There are nomiddlemen. The modern economy, on the contrary, is filled withmiddlemen, from traders of raw materials, to stock exchange traders, a multitude ponent and service suppliers, panies, and at the end of the long chain, Amazon or Best Buy for the puter buyer.

The reason for the beauty of trade lies in its bringing utility to the individuals involved and, in the long run, to most if not all individuals in society. Even monks benefit from trade. At any rate, there is no way to know if a poor of today would have been happier in a pre-modern economy; he might as well have been a serf.

This is not just an economics lesson in the mutual benefits of voluntary exchange. It provides a picture of how trade orients our work toward relationship and fellowship. For all our talk about work as a means for service, it is trade that connects the giver to the receiver.

As Lester DeKoster writes in Work: The Meaning of Your Life, “work creates civilization and culture,” but this doesn’t occur if we’re only working for ourselves. Detached munity, DeKoster writes, “people have to do everything for themselves”:

Civilization is sharing in the work of others. It is a circle we will finally see close: Our working puts us in the service of others; the civilization that work creates puts others in the service of ourselves. Thus, work restores the broken family of humankind…

The difference between barbarism and culture is, simply, work. One of the mystifying facts of history is why certain people create progressive cultures while others lag behind. Whatever that explanation, the power lies in work.

We see the beauty of trade in its power to amplify the service aspect of work. It is here, in the sharing,that the modern economy finds its flourishing.

The more we trade, the more we specialize our service. That creates “value,” but the bigger story and the better aesthetic is not in the value of the material stuff, but in the fellowship behind it.

Image: Commerce on the Water, Xu Yang (Public Domain)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Competitive taxing
In this season of taxation, it is refreshing to consider strategies for lowering taxes and making governments more efficient. London’s Institute of Economic Affairs recently published a fascinating monograph by Richard Teather, The Benefits of Tax Competition. It’s available for download here. Teather examines from various angles the issue of petition among nations—that is, the practice of national governments’ lowering taxes for the purpose of attracting panies and fostering and retaining domestic ones. He reviews the relevant existing research, analyzes...
Who argues that the environment doesn’t matter?
The Chicago Tribune has a story about the Evangelical Climate Initiative (ECI) launched February 8th. (See my initial response here.) Most reports of this story have been somewhat fair. But the Chicago Tribune story takes an unjustified swipe at evangelicals who disagree with the ECI statement. The reporter, Frank James, describes the disagreement among evangelical Christians this way: But environmental issues have proved divisive within the body of believers who identify themselves as evangelicals. Some who believe the world is...
Aid does not equal growth
The traditional formula for understanding the relationship between the developed and the developing world is the following: Aid = Economic Growth. That is, foreign aid spurs economic development in poorer nations. A new study released by the National Bureau of Economic Research challenges this wisdom, however. “Aid and Growth: What Does the Cross-Country Evidence Really Show?” by Raghuram G. Rajan and Arvind Subramanian shows that “regardless of the situation — for example, in countries that have adopted sound economic policies...
Family and the new economy
On January 21, 2006, Dr. Jennifer Roback Morse, author of Smart Sex: Finding Life-long Love in a Hook-up World and a Senior Fellow in Economics at the Acton Institute, gave this lecture at the Centesimus Annus Conference in Rome. Dr. Morse talks about the failure of the European welfare state to sustain economy and the demographic implications resulting from the “marginalization of the family.” Dr. Morse covers quite a bit of ground in this lecture, beginning with a critique of...
‘With God’s help, we can stop global warming’
A few others have addressed this issue in previous posts, but I wanted to jump in with my two cents. Yesterday’s New York Times notes that a group of evangelical leaders have entered the debate over climate change: Despite opposition from some of their colleagues, 86 evangelical Christian leaders have decided to back a major initiative to fight global warming, saying “millions of people could die in this century because of climate change, most of them our poorest global neighbors.”...
Schelling on species extinction
Following the recent discovery of new species and a reports of a “lost world,” a primitive pristine paradise on the Indonesian island of Papua, I thought I’d pass along some thoughts of F. W. J. Schelling, the 19th century philosopher and contemporary of G. W. F. Hegel and Friedrich Schleiermacher, who was one of the last great German idealists. German idealism in general, and Schelling’s philosophy in particular, have exercised great influence down into contemporary theology, having effected, among others,...
A love/hate relationship with science
One aspect of the evangelical involvement in debates over global warming and climate change that has intriqued me has been what I deem to be a rather large blind spot about the relation of religious conservatives to science. By this I mean that if there is any group of people who ought to understand the rigidity of scientific dogma, it should be evangelical Christians. Given the treatment of their views in debates about evolution and more recently “intelligent design,” it...
Religion and the EU
Kishore Jayalaban, Director of Acton’s Rome office, appeared on Kresta in the Afternoon yesterday to discuss a number of topics relating to religious freedom in the European Union, including abortion, homosexuality, “retrograde” Poland, and the troubles in Slovakia relating to the approval of a concordat with the Vatican. To listen to the interview, click here (3.1 mb mp3 file). It will also be available on Acton’s podcast, which is available for free through the iTunes Music Store. ...
The state of American science and culture, cont’d.
Following Michael Miller’s recent Acton Commentary, “Why Johnny Can’t Compete with Sanjay”, and the ments, two of America’s best mentators have also weighed in on the subject. First there’s Charles Krauthammer’s Time article, arguing that America is doing fine, partly as a result of less dependence on government-funded research. Then Michael ments on Krauthammer’s argument, along with a request for more information on the role of the private sector in research. Any takers? ...
Evangelicals and global warming
After much whispering and pre-publicity, a group of 86 evangelical leaders has announced their support for what The New York Times calls “a major initiative to fight global warming.” As part of the “Evangelical Climate Initiative,” they are calling for “federal legislation that would require reductions in carbon dioxide emissions through ‘cost-effective, market-based mechanisms.'” (For a response from another group of evangelical leaders, go to the Interfaith Stewardship Alliance.) I have great respect for the supporters of this initiative, and...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved