Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
Sweden’s coronavirus response defies— and promotes—big government
Sweden’s coronavirus response defies— and promotes—big government
May 9, 2025 9:25 PM

Thanks to its unique response to the coronavirus, Sweden is once again being discussed as an international oddity. Sweden seemingly relishes its status as a global anomaly: It is the world’s most secular-individualistic nation but has a strong apparatus of state control. For most of its history, it has been ruled by the Social Democratic Party. Today, Sweden is praised or disparaged, because it is one of few nations in the Western world that has not enforced a national lockdown in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.

To be sure, Swedish universities, high schools, and churches responded by meeting online. But kindergartens pulsory schools have carried on as usual. As of this writing, only five restaurants in the nation have been shut down by the authorities for being too crowded. (Two of them were allowed to reopen again within less than 48 hours.) In general, the Swedish Social Democrat-led government has more or less followed the motto: “Stay at home or stay apart. But if you don’t follow this rule, we won’t punish you.”

It is too early to state conclusively whether Sweden’s relaxed attitude towards the pandemic has been successful. Some nations with stricter lockdowns have higher death tolls, while others have a lower number of deaths by infection. It must be noted, however, that at this time parisons between Sweden and other coronavirus-stricken nations or regions show that Sweden has a distinctly smaller increase in the number of deaths. Therefore, it is not evident that this state-sanctioned openness has had worse effects than the strict lockdowns enjoined elsewhere.

How did this laissez-faire model emerge in one of the West’s most pronounced social assistance states? The peculiar Swedish model of a strong welfare bined with broad and robust individual autonomy may at first glance appear contradictory. But actually, the Swedish coronavirus strategy constitutes a practical example of what could be called Swedish “state individualism.”

Several causes lie behind this particular model of national organization, but it is largely the product of political decisions. Sweden is characterized by the uniquely long hegemony of a single political party. The Social Democrats ruled the nation from 1932 to 1976 and for many years since then. During their tenure, the power of the church, family, and civil society was gradually weakened. Civil society and apolitical connections steadily eroded. All rivals that pete with the political order’s claim on the citizen fell by the wayside.

The Social Democratic vision of government connected an isolated individual to a strong, collectivist state. After Sweden’s unique archetype, which accords the highest place to the isolated individual, permeated so many branches of society for so many decades, it became difficult to change perspective even during a crisis. The Social Democratic/Green coalition government’s path of permitting greater personal choice when es to social distancing and virus-reducing behaviour grows out of this history.

Swedish state individualism does, however, accord strong powers to governmental decrees. This is why Anders Tegnell, a state epidemiologist at the Public Health Agency, has seemingly replaced Prime Minister Stefan Löfven as leader of the nation during this outbreak. When Tegnell speaks, both government officials and private citizens obey. This may sound contradictory, but it follows the state-individualistic principle. The Swedish people are ready to follow almost any rule proclaimed from above—as long as it maintains the independence of the detached individual as a basic virtue.

The future of this relationship between the individual and the state will largely rest on the social consequences it produces as a result of this health crisis. Sweden could join in the backlash against postwar individualism which has swept parts of the plete with the rise of authoritarian leaders. However, such a development remains remote in Sweden. Here, the critical attitude against different forms of authority has permeated Swedish society for so long, and coercive measures are considered so foreign, that they will not be embraced even to stop the spread of the coronavirus.

Still, Swedes’ frustration over the practical consequences of their nation’s secular-individualistic dynamic has grown in recent years. It remains unclear whether the coronavirus outbreak will provide new impetus for “state individualism” or whether it will strengthen these concerns, awakening a thirst for another way of life. There are signs that people are beginning to resist Sweden’s peculiar, purely autonomous pattern and seek new ways to forge relationships within munities during this time of isolation. They long to end their loneliness by building up Burke’s “little platoons,” although they would never use that phrase.

In the long run, the COVID-19 crisis will be the pivotal factor in evaluating Sweden’s ingrained perspective of the isolated individual dominated by a paternalistic, secular government. Will the global pandemic create new criticisms of the ideological and practical materialism pervading Western culture? Will the populace find state-dominated, autonomous individualism less appealing? Will the need to cooperate within families and civil society open up space for the spiritual values embedded within munity-based way of life distinct from the state? These relationships could allow subsidiarity to replace the anachronism of Europe’s most atomized, government-dominated society.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
Choosing to Walk in Love
  Choosing to Walk in Love   By: Anne Peterson   And walk in love, as Christ loved us and gave himself up for us, a fragrant offering and sacrifice to God. - Ephesians 5:2   All of us have choices. Our choices determine our actions.   God tells us we can choose to walk in love. And when we make that choice, our other...
Unstuck and Unstoppable
  February 24, 2025   Unstuck and Unstoppable   BRITTANY MAHER   Lee en español   “He is like a tree planted by streams of water that yields its fruit in its season, and its leaf does not wither. In all that he does, he prospers.” Psalm 1:3 (ESV)   Can I be honest with you? For a long time, I felt spiritually stuck—newly married in...
Deregulating Legal Education
  Nearly every law school in the country is effectively under the thumb of the American Bar Association (ABA). The ABA’s power rests on its role as the recognized accreditor for law schools through the federal Department of Education. This official endorsement effectively determines whether students can obtain federal loans and whether state courts or bar associations will grant those schools...
Seven Easy Steps for Reforming Healthcare
  The new administration has at last come to DC, and opportunities for genuine reform, it seems, abound. Positive energy has been flowing since the recent “vibe-shift” made cracks in the edifice of the progressive status quo. The breadth of the new governing coalition—from post-liberal populists to libertarians and practically everything in between those poles—has opened up a realm of creativity...
Faith in Action
  Saturday, February 22, 2025   Faith in Action   “What good is it, dear brothers and sisters, if you say you have faith but don’t show it by your actions? Can that kind of faith save anyone?Suppose you see a brother or sister who has no food or clothing, and you say, ‘Good-bye and have a good day; stay warm and eat...
Counter
  If I were to describe the four thousand people who attended the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship 2025 Conference last week—added to a who’s who of speakers—the phrase that comes to mind is “Counter-Elites Assemble,” with a nod to 2012’s The Avengers. Given London’s ExCeL is approximately the size and scale of Heathrow’s Terminal 5, the sense that one was in...
How to Hang onto God (John 15:5)
  How to Hang onto God (John 15:5)   By: Anne Peterson   Today's Bible Verse:I am the vine, you are the branches; the one who remains in Me, and I in him bears much fruit, for apart from Me you can do nothing. - John 15:5   So often in life when things get tough, we hear the words, “Just hang in there.”...
When Adversity Leads to God
  When Adversity Leads to God   By Lynette Kittle   Bible Reading:   “When my life was ebbing away, I remembered you, Lord, and my prayer rose to You, to Your holy temple” – Jonah 2:7   It’s difficult for us to watch people going through hardships, even more difficult to experience them ourselves. Earthquakes, fires, hurricanes, wars, and terror attacks, with the destruction...
The Return of Political Economic Nationalism
  To many, President Donald Trump’s victory on November 5 seems to be a symbol of a major shift in the way our politics is practiced. But what is the nature of that shift? It is often seen as a turn away from “globalism” and toward a nationalism based on “race … religion, national origin” more at home in nineteenth-century continental...
Avoiding Economic Pseudo
  It’s commonplace today that governments should try to promote prosperity by building their economic policy around a family of “general theories” developed in the 1930s, known today as “macroeconomics.” Over the past century, this field has legitimized centralizing a wide range of governments’ spending decisions and central banks’ policies, even when it raised deficits and debts. However, it turns out...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved