Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Supreme Court: Yes, Of Course the Fifth Amendment Applies to All Property
Supreme Court: Yes, Of Course the Fifth Amendment Applies to All Property
Mar 28, 2026 5:04 PM

“The Fifth Amendment applies to personal property as well as real property,” wrote Justice Roberts in a Supreme Court rulinghanded down earlier this week. “The Government has a categorical duty to pay pensation when it takes your car, just as when it takes your home.”

You might be thinking, “Was that ever in doubt?” The answer is apparently yes—at least it was by the federal government since the time of FDR’s New Deal.

During theNew Deal era, Congress gave the USDA the authority to take raisins, along with many other crops, from farmers pensation and keep them in a government-controlled “reserve” to prevent them frombeing sold in U.S. markets. But while many of the other reserves faded away, the governmenthas continued to take raisins from farmers—and claims it’s allowed to do so for because the taking benefits the farmer.

The raisins are given to the Raisin Administrative Committee, a California-based organization made up of industry representatives, whichis allowed to sell off some of those reserve raisins to pay its own expenses and to promote raisins overseas. Many raisin farmers were fine with this price-fixing cartel. But one farmer refused to go along.

Marvin Horne refused to surrender his raisins to the government. Because of his refusal to allow his crops to be taken pensation Hornepotentially “owed” hundreds of thousands of dollars in fines and over 1 million pounds of his crops to the federal government.

Horne challenged the law (Horne v. US Department of Agriculture), arguing the taking of his property pensation is a violation ofthe Fifth Amendment, while the Obama administrationclaimed they can take personal property pensating the owner. More broadly, the government argued they have the ability to take a broad range of personal property—from raisins to iPhones from Americans pensation. A lower court had agreed, ruling that while the Fifth Amendment protectsrealproperty (i.e., land) it does not apply topersonalproperty (e.g., your car).

Fortunately, all nine Supreme Courtjustices disagreed (though they expressed differing views pensation). As Roberts notes in his opinion, “This principle [of pensation], dating back as far as Magna Carta, was codified in the Takings Clause in part because of property appropriations by both sides during the Revolutionary War. This Court has noted that an owner of personal property may expect that new regulation of the use of property could “render his property economically worthless.”

Roberts cites some of the instances of government taking property prior to the American Revolution and notes, “Nothing in this history suggests that personal property was any less protected against physical appropriation than real property.”

In legal terms, real property is land or anything attached to land. Personal property is property that can be moved, i.e., anything that can be subject to ownership that is not land. So if it was not clear before, the Court made it clear now: All your property is covered by theFifth Amendment.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Tattooing Justin Bieber’s Heart
Justin Bieber is no different than many 20-year-olds in the US and Canada. He is naturally searching for identity, meaning, and purpose — and searching for munity with whom to pursue those things. This is a normal process of transitioning from the teenage years into adulthood. Bieber, like many 20-year-olds, has shown a lack of judgement at times that has landed him not only in the news but also in jail. Many of us remember our own antics in those...
Chevron, Ecuador, and the Interfaith Rush to Judgment
In 2005, religious shareholder activists of various stripes jumped aboard the bandwagon filing resolutions against Chevron for an environmental disaster it allegedly caused. Chevron asserted its innocence, but the activist shareholders put the squeeze on: Chevron’s Ecuador environmental disaster, considered by experts to be the worst oil-related ecological problem on the planet and currently the subject of a high-stakes law suit estimated to cost pany upwards of $6 billion, will be high on the agenda of pany’s 2006 annual shareholder...
Bitcoin is (Nearly) Dead
Last year I wrote a series of blog posts about what Christians should know about Bitcoin. In response, one astute reader pointed out an odd juxtaposition: my conclusion seemed to imply that Christians should avoid Bitcoin “at all cost” and yet the Acton Institute accepts donations in Bitcoin. “I really want to know the rationale behind this,” he said. Well, the rationale is easy enough to explain: Not everyone at Acton agrees with me. Like other nerds who have an...
Student loan update: ‘I’m from the government, and I’m here to entice you into debt slavery.’
The massive federal student loan program is creating a gargantuan higher education bubble and unsustainable levels of student loan debt, but at least all that borrowed money is going primarily to educate people, right? Apparently not. Yahoo Finance reports on yet another way that the nanny state is creating moral hazard and impoverishing the culture: A number of factors are behind the growth in student debt. The soft jobs recovery and the emphasis on education have driven people to attain...
Radio Free Acton: Egypt in Transition
As Egypt moves through the process of establishing a new, stable government after not just one but two revolutions, the security of the Coptic Orthodox munity in Egyptian society has at times been in doubt. Dr. Magdy El-Sanady, an Egyptian Coptic Christian, has worked for over 30 years in health planning, management munity development, and in non-governmental organization institutional strengthening in Egypt. Dr. El-Sanady holds postgraduate degrees in pediatrics and public health from Egypt and an M.B.A. and Ph.D. from...
Why Attitudes About Competition Matter
In an excerpt from the splendidPovertyCure series, Michael Fairbanks offers a helpful bit on why our attitudes petition matter for economic development: I can predict the future of a developing nation better than any IMF team of economists by asking one question: “Do you believe petition?” When I go to Venezuela and I say, “do you believe petition?,” they say petition means the rich get richer and the poor get poorer.” They say petition is the unnecessary duplication of effort...
Samuel Gregg: ‘Must Catholics Favor Socialized Medicine?’
Acton Director of Research, Samuel Gregg, recently discussed Catholicism and healthcare over at Crisis Magazine. In his article, he asks “Must Catholics favor socialized medicine?” Gregg begins by addressing whether or not “access to healthcare may be described as a ‘right.'” He asserts that Catholics should agree it is a right based on a 2012 address Pope Benedict XVI made to healthcare workers, in which he unambiguously spoke of the “right to healthcare.” Gregg continues: But the real debate for...
Welcome To Paradise: Taking A Look At Legalized Prostitution
It’s the oldest profession, right? It’s worldwide, and attempts to criminalize it don’t seem to work. Does legalizing prostitution solve any problems? That’s the question Nisha Lilia Diu of The Telegraph set out to answer. In a lengthy piece that focuses on Germany, Diu visited brothels, talked to their owners, visited with prostitutes – all in order to see if the legalization of prostitution “works.” Germany legalized prostitution in 2002. The law was meant to to do a number of...
Michael Novak: ‘Capitalism is Lifting the World out of Poverty’
Philosopher and theologian, Michael Novak recently delivered a speech at the Catholic University of America on the vocation of business and Forbes published the transcript. Novak argues that “capitalism is lifting the world out of poverty.” As many Asian and African economies shift from socialist to capitalist, they are seeing enormous economic growth, and small businesses are the force behind these economic gains: Even in developed nations, most jobs are found in small business. In Italy, over 80 percent of...
Book Review: ‘A Mother’s Ordeal – One Woman’s Fight Against China’s One-Child Policy’
Steven W. Mosher, president of the Population Research Institute, has written a book that is brutally truthful and brutally hard to read. It should be: it’s about the most brutal of government policies, China’s one-child policy. Written in the first person, Mosher writes as “Chi An,” a young woman he first met in 1980. While he has changed certain facts and names in order to protect the woman he gives voice to, the story of her life in China is...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved